4 ms·
ESA satellites to test razor-sharp formation flying
- throw0101c 3y agoAnother application of satellites in formation is measure gravity fields: > That brings us to GRACE—a backronym for gravity recovery and climate experiment—a pair of satellites that orbited the Earth at a fixed distance from each other. Or they would be fixed if the Earth’s gravity didn’t change in time and space. GRACE used a radar system to measure the distance between the two satellites to track those changes, providing information about the gravitational field it was traveling through. * https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/07/satellites-play-chase-to-measure-gravity-achieve-picometer-accuracy/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/07/satellites-play-chas... * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GRACE_and_GRACE-FO https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GRACE_and_GRACE-FO
- _factor 3y agoA space interferometer as well. Unfortunately, the planned SIM mission was shelved. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Interferometry_Mission?wprov=sfti1#Planet_hunting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Interferometry_Mission?w...
- perihelions 3y agoThere's also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LISA_Pathfinder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LISA_Pathfinder ("LISA Pathfinder") I wonder how precisely they can control the relative separation of those interferometer spacecraft? (They advertise they can measure the separation to <0.01 nanometers—but that's not quite the same thing).
- dotnet00 3y agoI think with those the idea is to make the arms so long that the precision of the relative separation matters less, especially since LISA is trying to listen for much longer wavelengths than LIGO. On top of that, they likely just need to get the unpredictable component of the relative acceleration to vary (unpredictable component of the relative jerk?) slower than the time taken for a gravitational wave to pass through. Probably more a matter of precisely measuring the gravitational fields and accounting for those than of controlling their relative position extremely precisely (besides of course the precision needed to target the lasers across such a large distance).
- 27theo 3y agoTIL backronym.
- dylan604 3y agoUS Congress is a fan of its use, even if they might not know there's a word for it
- verisimi 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backronym https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Backronym > A backronym is an acronym formed from an already existing word by expanding its letters into the words of a phrase. Backronyms may be invented with either serious or humorous intent, or they may be a type of false etymology or folk etymology. The word is a portmanteau of back and acronym.[1] > A normal acronym is a word derived from the initial letters of the words of a phrase,[2] such as radar from "radio detection and ranging".[3] By contrast, a backronym is "an acronym deliberately formed from a phrase whose initial letters spell out a particular word or words, either to create a memorable name or as a fanciful explanation of a word's origin."[1] Many fictional espionage organizations are backronyms, such as SPECTRE (special executive for counterintelligence, terrorism, revenge and extortion) from the James Bond franchise. > For example, the Amber Alert missing-child program was named after Amber Hagerman, a nine-year-old girl who was abducted and murdered in 1996.[4] Officials later publicized the backronym "America's Missing: Broadcast Emergency Response".[5]
- sandworm101 3y ago"Strategic Homeland Enforcement and Logistics Division." "And what does that mean to you?" "It means someone really wanted our initials to spell out "S.H.I.E.L.D."
- HPsquared 3y agoThat would be a good name for an artillery division.
- HankB99 3y agoI graduated from Purdue University Calumet Campus in northwest Indiana (PUCC.) At one point they considered renaming as the South Hammond Institute of Technology. Ba-dump-tish.
- jdiez17 3y agoVery cool! We're actually doing something quite similar (although on a much smaller scale) at the TU Berlin: https://www.tu.berlin/en/about/profile/press-releases-news/nanoff-satellites https://www.tu.berlin/en/about/profile/press-releases-news/n... Just recently, we completed a series of correction burns to match the semi-major axis of the orbit of both satellites to stop them drifting away from each other. In a few weeks/months we'll bring them back together and send a software update that will allow them to autonomously maintain formation flight. Also, we will be doing live satellite operations at the Lange Nacht der Wissenschaften (22. June 2024) :)
- consumer451 3y agoIs this your first work in orbit? Does it feel as cool as one would imagine?
- jdiez17 3y agoIt is and it does feel about as awesome as you can imagine. In our case we also had a tough integration and testing campaign where we were changing software and running into hardware issues, etc. so I was personally quite tense until we got first contact :) and since then, the satellites are surprising us every day with how well they work! (although we still have lots of things we want to improve)
- consumer451 3y agoCongratulations and major respect!
- mlyle 3y agoI'm mentoring a group of high school students who were just selected by the CubeSat Launch Initiative to put a smallsat up. It's not quite my first rodeo with this stuff, but it's still incredible to be a part of and see. [It's incredible to be a part of, but it's also just a whole lot of attention to detail, paperwork, and paranoia] People don't tend to let HS students do much, so it's pretty stirring when they get an email that said approximately "We appreciate your... dedication to furthering humanity’s presence in space and knowledge of the cosmos."
- rrr_oh_man 3y agoWait, what? They'll create artificial solar eclipses?
- zith 3y agoThey'll use one spacecraft to block the sun shining on the other spacecraft,yes.
- rcxdude 3y agoOnly for each other: it's more like holding up a plate to cover the sun, not making an eclipse for a large portion of the earth.
- mackman 3y agoDamn, this would have been a great way to combat global warming. We just need much bigger plates.
- bee_rider 3y agoThe idea of a solar shade to manage the amount of sunlight we get has been around for a while. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_sunshade https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_sunshade
- contravariant 3y agoWhat if we just nudge the moon into an orbit that always eclipses the sun?
- frederikvs 3y agoI work at the company building these satellites, I've seen them sitting in our clean room. If there's any questions, I might be able to give some answers. However, I'm not involved with Proba-3 directly, so no guarantees.
- _hl_ 3y agoI understand that part of the objective is to demonstrate precise autonomous navigation and choreography, but for the "main" scientific objective re. observing the solar corona, why not just stick a big stick with a disk on the observing satellite?
- frederikvs 3y agoThat's what's been done so far [0], both on the ground and in space. As I understand it, the further your disk is from your telescope, the better. But your stick needs to be rigid enough to keep the disk exactly in its place. And a rigid stick has weight. For Proba-3 the goal is to have the two satellites more than 100m apart. If you want to do that with a stick, your stick has to be longer than the ISS. That should tell you a thing or two about the complexity and cost of building and launching that stick. I do have to admit I'm not exactly sure what the advantages are of having the disk further away from the telescope. I suspect it's to do with the interaction between the light and the edge of the disk, but I'm not sure. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph
- _hl_ 3y agoHuh, very interesting- and counterintuitive that distance matters. If anyone here knows why I’d love to learn more!! EDIT: maybe not so counterintuitive after all: if you scale everything up, you get a higher fidelity sensor and more signal to noise. Same reason telescopes want to be big: to collect more light especially from dim signals. Distance of the occulter then reduces perspective distortion that would eclipse the inner parts of the sensor more than the outer ones. Just my speculation though.
- dr_orpheus 3y ago
- jsemrau 3y agoInteresting that they still use cold gas thrusters. Electric propulsion (FEEP) is much more efficient for this kind of maneuver.
- ooterness 3y agoEverything has tradeoffs, and everything depends on use case. The FEEP thrusters I've seen had a hefty power penalty to keep it on standby, and a long warmup time. Cold gas uses more propellant mass per unit impulse, but it can still come out ahead in total size/weight/power.
- jsemrau 3y agoIs the power penalty really such a big issue anymore? The Enpulsion Nano for example uses 10-15 Watt only on hot standby.
- frederikvs 3y agoFrom the article, Proba-3 has 10 thrusters, so that would bring the total to 150 Watt. I don't know the power budget for the satellite, but we can make an educated guess : the occulter is 1.4 meter diameter, or a surface area of 1.54 square meter. That's an upper bound for the surface area of the solar panels - there's nothing sticking out beyond the disk, that would interfere with observations. Solar power at earth is about 1.3kW/sqm, solar panels are maybe 20% to 30% efficient. That puts you in the ballpark of 400 to 600W. 150W on standby would be a pretty big bite out of your power budget.
- dr_orpheus 3y agoYep, definitely power is an issue and a trade-off even with low levels of power. The other item is cost. Cold gas thrusters are super cheap and reliable. So the savings in amount of propellant in going to an electric propulsion system is not going to be worth it in the overall program. This is also because the total amount of maneuvering they are doing (in terms of deltaV) is probably not very large. Lots of little maneuvers. This is compared to something where you have large delta V for big maneuvers or continuously overcoming drag in low LEO orbits where the amount of propellant will become a huge design driver.
- brutusborn 3y agoDoes anyone else read “formation flying” and instantly think “Kessler syndrome”
- psunavy03 3y agoNo because it's exactly the opposite. Kessler syndrome results from satellites smashing into each other with high relative velocities. The entire point of formation flying is zeroing out relative velocity. That's how you stay in formation with something.
- brutusborn 3y agoI was imagining them flying close-by, so any failure would have a higher chance of causing a cascade. I couldn’t find any info on how close they are, but I imagine it’s too far for this to be an issue.
- frederikvs 3y agoThe goal is to have them a bit more than 100m apart. During observations they aim to maintain millimeter precision. I'm pretty sure the risk of collision has been analysed to death. I would expect they've analysed what would happen if one or both devices suddenly stop listening to commands, and that even then there's essentially no risk.
- dotnet00 3y agoThe article says they're going to be 144 meters apart. A collision of things that are in basically the exact same orbit is also not going to be much of a risk, as the collision would be at a low relative velocity. Collisions between satellites are a kessler syndrome risk because due to differing orbits, the collision velocities can be in km/s, which can spread debris into a wide range of orbits, thus causing the heightened risk of cascading failures.
- psunavy03 3y agoIt still doesn't matter according to physics. There's a reason why two NASCAR cars can be going 150+ miles an hour, and yet "rubbin's racin'," but a head-on collision at 60 miles an hour will kill you. The two race cars going 151 and 149 mph rub at ~2mph relative velocity, while the head-on collision with the drunk occurs at 120mph relative velocity. And flying formation, be it in space or in the air, by definition involves getting as close to zero relative velocity as possible . . . or else you aren't in formation.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoSpeaking of razor-sharp formation flying satellites, reminder Interferometer Space Antenna (LISA) got the go ahead this year. Incredibly ambitious & cool attempt to build a much much much bigger space based version of the already 4km long Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory (LIGO). Requires absurdly stupensously precise formation of three satellites. https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Capturing_the_ripples_of_spacetime_LISA_gets_go-ahead https://www.esa.int/Science_Exploration/Space_Science/Captur...
- panick21_ 3y agoYes. Super cool project. The free flying cores that get manipulated with magnets are crazy. Will allow gravitational wave observation in a totally different domain.
- visviva 3y agoThe combination of mm-level precision and a highly elliptical orbit with a very high apogee (60+ kkm) is really impressive.
- bgnn 3y agoMaybe I'm dumb, but couldn't they just use an umbrella instead of a separate sattelite?
- frederikvs 3y agoMany observations of the sun's corona just use a disk attached to the telescope, as you're suggesting [0]. However, for Proba-3 they want the disk to be over 100m away from the telescope, which isn't practical. Also, one of the goals of Proba-3 is to develop formation flying technology, because it will be useful for many other missions in the future. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coronagraph