3 ms·
Because PGP keys are used for more than just encrypting email. I mostly only use mine to sign release tags for software I publish. Having that key uploaded to
by kelnos 3y ago
Because PGP keys are used for more than just encrypting email.
I mostly only use mine to sign release tags for software I publish. Having that key uploaded to a public keyserver is a useful thing to do in that case.
But maybe I wanted to use it for other things... perhaps I just want to sign my email, and not encrypt what I send, and allow others to verify the signature. Having the key out on a public keyserver is essential for that.
Honestly I don't know why acting so rudely about this, to the point of pretentiously quoting a famous author/journalist. Not to mention the fact that you haven't thought through all the various reasons why someone might have a key published. Maybe step back from the keyboard and breathe a bit?
- Freak_NL 3y agoExactly. My key is on there because we have a shared password-store synched in a private git repo encrypted with the keys of select number of colleagues for some work credentials and keys. It is useful to be able to find each other's keys automatically based on the key fingerprint. I can probably read e-mail encrypted with it just fine as long as I use Thunderbird with my Fastmail inbox (which is most of the time), but not when using K9 Mail on a smartphone or the web UI of Fastmail.
- soraminazuki 3y agoThat's not what public keyservers are for. You're free to use it any other way, but it's unreasonable to shame people who used the keys you advertised in a way that matches general expectations. Besides, it doesn't make sense to upload keys only meant to be shared among a small number of people to a public keyserver. In your case, the keys better belong in the git repo.
- caddy 3y agoI feel like that defeats the purpose of the validation. If you're storing the keys in the same place as the code, it would be very easy if someone gained malicious access to the repo to change the key and sign it with the new key.
- soraminazuki 3y agoI thought the commenter was using the repo for a password store, not executable code? The only consequence of not validating that would be them entering invalid credentials. Even if they’re dealing with code, watching out for new commits that change keys is enough. That’s something that people should be doing when using keyservers too. Anyway, the point is public keyservers aren’t a good match for the described use case. If the key is meant to be kept private, it should be shared privately.
- soraminazuki 3y agoSigning keys and encryption keys are separate things in PGP. If you don't want people to use your encryption key, don't encourage everyone to use it by uploading it to a keyserver. > Honestly I don't know why acting so rudely about this, to the point of pretentiously quoting a famous author/journalist. Not to mention the fact that you haven't thought through all the various reasons why someone might have a key published. Maybe step back from the keyboard and breathe a bit? Yes please, practice what you preach.
- kelnos 3y ago> Signing keys and encryption keys are separate things in PGP. If you don't want people to use your encryption key, don't encourage everyone to use it by uploading it to a keyserver. I think most people don't know that, and/or don't know how to separate the two. At any rate, it's not particularly convenient. Most people will just generate one set of keys to use, regardless of the intended purpose(s). Regardless, let's again realize that PGP keys can be used for more than just encrypting email. Maybe I'm using it to encrypt, but not for email. > Yes please, practice what you preach. Not sure what you mean. Attempting to equate the tone and words of my comment with that of the toplevel commenter seems a bit in bad faith.
- soraminazuki 3y agoNo, my comment was made in good faith. So, the point about rudeness. PGP keyservers exist for the sole purpose of letting you advertise your keys. Shaming people who used keyservers for what they were designed for is what's rude here. Actually, more than rude. It's a trap. Next, about actually thinking about all the reasons for uploading keys to a keyserver. Can you actually name a use case that you consider legitimate for discovering encryption keys through a public keyserver? Because your point seems to be that people upload them unwillingly. You shouldn't be quick to accuse people of rudeness and bad faith in those with different perspectives.
- soraminazuki 3y agoAlso, > I think most people don't know that, and/or don't know how to separate the two. I'm sure people will understand what "sign only" means when GPG prompts the user to choose what kind of keys to create.