3 ms·
The trouble with colluding is that if everyone agrees to set the price at $300, another seller can undercut them with a price of $290 and take their business aw
by WalterBright 3y ago
The trouble with colluding is that if everyone agrees to set the price at $300, another seller can undercut them with a price of $290 and take their business away.
Or one of the members of the cartel can agree to sell at $300, and then offer a kickback under the table to get the business, or offer some other cash equivalent incentive.
Cartels only work if the government is used to make it illegal to cheat on the cartel.
- text0404 3y agoexcept this isn't the case. there have been many examples of cartels and collusion in the past.
- WalterBright 3y agoAs many examples of failed cartels and collusion, too. That's why they always seek the government to force cooperation. This is how unions operate, for example. Taxis and the AMA are other examples.
- text0404 3y ago> That's why they always seek the government to force cooperation. you're talking about labor cartels, but the article (and op) are talking about real estate cartels. one operates with government involvement, the other does not. edit: my original point was that simply the threat of someone undercutting a cartel is not enough to be able to state that cartels cannot exist without government involvement/coercion.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe real estate cartel has no means of enforcement, so its ability to hold the line on prices fails the moment one of its members decides it is in their personal best interest to lower the price to undercut the competition.
- renewiltord 3y agoI see. Your position is that cartels only exist because governments ensure they exist. I think that is a tautology (in that everything exists because governments ensure they exist since governments enforce law so things exist in society depending on whether they enforce or don't) or wrong, so we have a fundamental disagreement here and unifying will take so long that there's probably no point discussing further.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Your position is that cartels only exist because governments ensure they exist Not exactly. Cartels based on voluntary cooperation are unstable and tend to not last very long. Stable cartels are based on coercion of some sort - some mechanism to keep the members in line. The law is the usual means to achieve that.