4 ms·
> If this tool allows a market to be a bit collude-y, it may add a bit to rents, and it's worth suing them to see what comes out. When I buy stocks, the price
by WalterBright 3y ago
> If this tool allows a market to be a bit collude-y, it may add a bit to rents, and it's worth suing them to see what comes out.
When I buy stocks, the price is set across the country, anyone can get a quote and see what it is at the moment. Is that collusion?
- davidw 3y agoHousing is more limited geographically and while it's very far from a monopoly, larger providers might have some pull in the market. IDK, we'll see what comes out of the lawsuit, I guess. If more housing gets built, prices fall though, like in Austin.
- renewiltord 3y agoCertainly not. But consider an actual hypothetical cartel that is explicitly defacto and dejure price fixing. Suppose the members of this cartel instead create a new LLC. Suppose that new LLC now performs the role of price-fixing with the condition that not conforming will lead to expulsion from the price feed system. Has this transformation taken a cartel that is explicitly colluding and made it into one that is not colluding? If so, we now have a mechanism to turn every cartel into a non-cartel via the umbrella LLC. And the latter costs $300 to set up in Delaware. So the anti-cartel law has a $300 bypass. Reasonable, I suppose if you believe that that law has reached the end of its utility.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe trouble with colluding is that if everyone agrees to set the price at $300, another seller can undercut them with a price of $290 and take their business away. Or one of the members of the cartel can agree to sell at $300, and then offer a kickback under the table to get the business, or offer some other cash equivalent incentive. Cartels only work if the government is used to make it illegal to cheat on the cartel.
- text0404 3y agoexcept this isn't the case. there have been many examples of cartels and collusion in the past.
- WalterBright 3y agoAs many examples of failed cartels and collusion, too. That's why they always seek the government to force cooperation. This is how unions operate, for example. Taxis and the AMA are other examples.
- text0404 3y ago> That's why they always seek the government to force cooperation. you're talking about labor cartels, but the article (and op) are talking about real estate cartels. one operates with government involvement, the other does not. edit: my original point was that simply the threat of someone undercutting a cartel is not enough to be able to state that cartels cannot exist without government involvement/coercion.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe real estate cartel has no means of enforcement, so its ability to hold the line on prices fails the moment one of its members decides it is in their personal best interest to lower the price to undercut the competition.
- renewiltord 3y agoI see. Your position is that cartels only exist because governments ensure they exist. I think that is a tautology (in that everything exists because governments ensure they exist since governments enforce law so things exist in society depending on whether they enforce or don't) or wrong, so we have a fundamental disagreement here and unifying will take so long that there's probably no point discussing further.
- 3y ago
- onjectic 3y agoThats called a monopoly, and monopolizing intentionally is illegal for the same reasons.
- renewiltord 3y agoThe LLC owns no product to sell. It's merely a price feed service. You are welcome to use other price feed services. In fact, for the fee of a few hundred dollars, unaffiliated people will happily set up other price feed services.
- digitaltrees 3y agoIs one central company telling every bank to hold shares and only release them in specific amounts to achieve optimal price? That’s what’s happening with real page, the supply side is being curated across the whole industry so there is no real competition and thus no real price seeking function. Free markets don’t work with that type of collusion.
- WalterBright 3y agoThere are millions of owners. Do you really believe they'll all stick to the cartel price?
- text0404 3y agoenough do to make enough of a problem that we're discussing it now.
- davidw 3y agoSo how come the landlords in Houston are losing out on so much money when they could be charging San Francisco prices?
- digitaltrees 3y agoThose are decoupled markets. Employers pay more in SF, so landlords can extract more. The problem is that landlords in both markets are colluding to extract more than pure market forces would otherwise support. Now if employers then have to raise wages further, that distortion could result in higher inflation. Capitalism doesn’t work when monopolies and cartels gain sufficient power to eliminate the price setting function of competition.
- WalterBright 3y agoCartels don't work without coercion of its members. Remember the no-poaching cartel among tech companies in Silicon Valley? and the companies were cheating on their cartel agreement? and the infamous email Steve Jobs sent complaining about the cheating? A landlord has no power.
- katbyte 3y agohomes should not be an investment. no one needs stocks everyone needs a home.
- davidw 3y agoTrue! But show up at a hearing like me and you will hear angry people - who most definitely vote - talk about how those apartments may lower the value of their homes.
- medvezhenok 3y agoThe problem in the U.S. (independently of everything else) is that value serves as a filtering mechanism. Value of properties in a neighborhood correlates to the crime rate in that neighborhood - and that’s true nationwide, and because of certain political protections there’s no way to “divorce” the two - which presents a thorny problem.
- objektif 3y agoHorrible, horrible, horrible analogy. There is so much to say about this but the bottom line is that stocks do not follow price fixing it is more a market equilibrium. This on the other hand is pure price fixing.
- WalterBright 3y agoIt's just a suggested price. There's no coercion.
- unclebucknasty 3y ago>It's just a suggested price. There's no coercion I think you may be misunderstanding the definition of price fixing.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhat's the coercion here?
- unclebucknasty 3y agoPrice fixing is the result of collusion/collaboration, not of coercion.
- WalterBright 3y agoPrice fixing doesn't work without coercion. Let's say you and I agree to sell cars at the same price. How would that be enforced? What's to stop you from cutting your price to grab some business from me?
- onjectic 3y ago> Price fixing doesn’t work without coercion. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Price_fixing
- mydogcanpurr 3y agoStocks are fungible. Housing is not.
- WalterBright 3y agoHousing is fungible. You can turn money into a house, and house into money. You can borrow against a house. You can borrow and put it into a house. You can rent out a house.
- mydogcanpurr 3y agoLook up fungible in a dictionary. Housing is not fungible because not all units of housing are interchangeable. Being able to sell something does not make it fungible.
- WalterBright 3y agoThere are enough dwellings in any city to make them interchangeable.
- mydogcanpurr 3y agoReally? All real estate is worth the exact same? That's news to me.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhen people trade things that have different values, money is also exchanged to make up for the difference. For example, when you trade your old car for a new car, you pay the difference in value.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chongli 3y agoYour definition of "fungible" applies to literally everything on the planet. Everything can be exchanged for money and back again. That's not what fungible means. Here's another example to help you differentiate: * Gold is fungible. Any bar of pure gold (of identical mass) is exactly interchangeable and has an identical value with any other bar of gold. * Diamonds are not fungible. Every individual stone is unique and must be properly graded by a licensed jeweller. Two stones of the same mass are highly unlikely to have the same value.