3 ms·
> Within the prime working-age group, cancer and heart disease were the leading natural causes of death I have a lot of extended family and in-laws who live in
by Aurornis 3y ago
> Within the prime working-age group, cancer and heart disease were the leading natural causes of death
I have a lot of extended family and in-laws who live in rural locations.
The lifestyle differences between what I see in the city and what I see in their rural locations are stark. The norms around diet, exercise, drinking, and smoking are completely different.
Even norms around personal safety and protective gear are completely different. Most of my rural extended family will do things like casually spray pesticides or paint without a mask. I was mocked for pulling out safety glasses and hearing protection for power tools when we worked on a project together once.
The study classifies things like heart disease and cancer as “natural causes” and blames lack of healthcare, but my anecdotal experience is that the lifestyle differences could easily explain the difference in heart disease and probably a significant number of the cancer diagnoses as well.
Even when healthcare is available, many of them don’t trust it. Statins are still a common debate when I visit, with many of the people in mid-life telling me that they don’t work and it’s just a big pharma cash grab conspiracy (even though statins are dirt cheap now). Refusing to take doctor-directed medication is a point of pride for some, though they tend to reverse course in older life when they see their peers start dying young. Many refuse vaccines for themselves and children due to things they heard on podcasts or social media. And mental health? Don’t dare even suggest that one.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI can’t even get my parents to care about mold after their basement floods for the 10th time in 10 years. They will worry about superstitions about eclipses, but not any long term health consequence from any source that could be labeled “science”.
- hasty_pudding 3y ago[dead]
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt's a machismo built up around preventative behaviors that cost short-term money. If you're a farmer trying to compete in the last 50 years, your concern isn't with the possibility that you might get cancer in 20 years from the neonicotinoids you're spraying; it's making enough money to cover expenses now. But your friend who helps you do all sorts of farm chores, he wants to wear protection when he sprays. He's spent money on this protective gear, money that could have been put towards new machinery or the mortgage. He spends five minutes "dickin' 'round" putting it on. Five minutes that could be spent spraying. Since the span of five minutes is easier for the human mind to comprehend than the possibility of health problems months, years, or decades away, you choose to value the five minutes and tell him to get a move on. When he insists, you call him a wimp. He's now been shamed out of the preventative behavior.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jajko 3y agoYeah, but its still outright stupid behavior, no matter how you wrap it. And stupidity will always be punished eventually in this world (which is the only way to 'fight' it, since as we know its endless and unlimited in mankind). 'I saved 5 minutes (or half an hour, who cares) so I can die 30 years younger than I had to, yeeehaaa'. Lack of good education, or intelligence, or both.
- lenerdenator 3y ago> Lack of good education, or intelligence, or both. Is it? You can sum up most of a Wharton MBA with "gamble until it bites you in the ass". The only difference is, the guy with the Wharton MBA gets to pawn his mistakes off on the guy who's actually doing the work, thus evading your punishment for stupidity.
- jajko 3y agoIf you are an alcoholic, there is no gamble, you will ruin your life and lives of people around you and die early and most probably miserably, period. Same with say smoking cigarettes, still a popular addiction of poorer folks all around the world. It goes much deeper - children of drug abusers, be it legal or illegal, tend to very closely repeat their parent's mistakes also in this aspect, vicious circle that takes a strong personality and probably some luck to step out of. I consider it an utter failure as a parent, no nicer way around this.
- kube-system 3y agoI think a lot of these studies must either not be considering social factors, or maybe their authors aren't familiar with the worldview of rural America. I grew up in a place where some of those ideas are more popular, and the people around me regularly derided (what I now understand to be) healthy habits as things that 'sissy liberals' did. It was not socially acceptable to be on a diet, go to the gym, wear protective equipment, etc.
- shrubble 3y agoMy friend (urbanite) was offered statins but declined and instead went on a "P90x" home gym program. Six months later, his doctor agreed that statins weren't needed provided he stayed in shape. Of course, you have to actually do the exercise :)
- shiroiushi 3y agoI think a lot of medications like that are basically a substitute for a healthier lifestyle. Not everyone can pull off the healthier lifestyle, so the drugs are good for them, but for others, they wouldn't be getting prescribed these drugs if they lived healthier to begin with.
- datavirtue 3y agoThese same social norms exist in city areas as well. Get a job in a factory and try to get your hands on adequate personal protective gear. You will not last long. This brain dead machoism is rampant, half the population is promoting a know-nothing facsist pig for president so that they can hammer the last nail in their own coffin.
- giantg2 3y ago"Statins are still a common debate" Even among some doctors, researchers, and former users there is debate. Not debate about their effectiveness in general, but about which situations should warrant them. There are several common side effects that can significantly impact quality of life. It's understandable that some people are skeptical of statins based on the history of pharma and their current proposals. For example, I heard a year or two ago that they were looking into recommending statins for everyone over 70. The cholesterol level for when statins are recommended dropped about 50-100 points just a few years ago too. "The lifestyle differences between what I see in the city and what I see in their rural locations are stark." Are you comparing neighborhoods of similar socioeconomic characteristics? I've seen plenty of your types of example in urban and rural areas. The big difference is money. The more well-off people in either location tend to be more conscience - diet, exercise, PPE use - than the poorer people. Edit: why disagree?
- smileysteve 3y agoThere is debate, because while statins effectively lower cholesterol, the results don't correlate that people on statins live longer or better - though they often are less likely to die of heart disease. The effect on mobility, muscle health, and skin health are all downsides of statins.
- kube-system 3y ago> The big difference is money. The more well-off people in either location tend to be more conscience - diet, exercise, PPE use - than the poorer people. I don't think that's because of the money. I think their lifestyle choices, natural abilities, worldviews, and other personal factors are the cause of both their limited income, and their attitude towards the health choices they make.
- giantg2 3y agoI don't think I said it was causative, just that it's correlated. So comparing areas with different economic statuses is not really a fair comparison.
- downrightmike 3y agoIts is a conspiracy to keep them alive, so the live longer, and need more services as the age. Muahahahahah
- P_I_Staker 3y ago> Even when healthcare is available, many of them don’t trust it. Right, due to bad healthcare. The industry is riddled with bad actors, bad ideology, and patient hostile practices. From what I've seen of the system it doesn't surprise me that people die instead of getting medical treatment. There's a lot of propaganda and need for reforms.