3 ms·
I'm always a bit worried about giving to humanitarian charities in Africa, just because it gives warlords a way to turn refugees into a lootable resource[1]. A
by Symmetry 15y ago
I'm always a bit worried about giving to humanitarian charities in Africa, just because it gives warlords a way to turn refugees into a lootable resource[1]. Aid organizations want to help refugees, and are generally willing to give warlords money in order to be allowed access to those refugees.
This was a big factor in the start of the Congolese Civil War. In Rwanada after the the genocide the perpetrators fled into Congo and many Hutus, fearing that the Tutsi forces would want revenge, fled with them. In the Congo the genocidaires were able to confiscate and resell part of the aid, and charge rent to aid agencies, and use the money buy weapons to arm the people there in the hopes of retaking the country. The new Tutsi Rwandan government, not willing to let this happen, decided to invade. And since Mobutu of Zaire had been harboring insurgents from all the other neighboring countries, they all decided to help. Thus began the Congo Civil War. However, rereading the section in Wikipedia on the refugee crisis it seems that Médecins Sans Frontières and most of the other independant aid organizations were smart enough to realize what was happening and leave so they couldn't be used - and it was the mostly UN that was still contributing money and supplies when the fighting started[2]. So maybe you should give money to aid organization after all.
[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse
[2]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes_refugee_crisis http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Lakes_refugee_crisis
- lincolnq 15y agoI'm glad you know so much about this, but don't let your knowledge prevent you from doing the right thing. All I know is that Givewell seems extremely thorough, and holistic in their thoroughness. If there were a major effect such as the one you describe (warlords looting villages for bed nets), I expect that Givewell would recognize it and incorporate it into their estimates of cost-effectiveness for charities. Givewell is really very good. (If you want evidence for this, read some of their in-depth charity analyses and see how many factors they consider.) And if the effect of warlords looting villages for their bed nets is not large enough to make a significant negative impact on the charity's effectiveness, then it still seems like one of the best possible uses of money to do good in the world.