3 ms·
Have you ever seen how big the US is?!? Rail systems work in Europe because densities are extremely high. The closest city to the Bay Area is Sacramento which
by alephnerd 3y ago
Have you ever seen how big the US is?!? Rail systems work in Europe because densities are extremely high.
The closest city to the Bay Area is Sacramento which is 90mi/150km - which is the maximum distance that a commuter rail system can work between two metropolitan areas while still being cheaper than flying.
San Francisco to Los Angeles is 620-700km - so from Cologne to Prague.
Unlike that route, you'd need to be building through multiple mountain ranges in California AND there are very few cities in between to justify ridership.
- joshmaker 3y agoTokyo to Kyoto is 280mi/445km and it's an extremely fast and comfortable train ride.
- alephnerd 3y agoIn between Tokyo and Kyoto you have Nagoya Metropolitan Region, which has a population of 10 million. There is no similar sized city in between the Bay Area and LA MSA. This impacts the incentives to build in the US. Metropolitan Areas in the Western United States are VERY far from each other. And this isn't because of sprawl. Take a look at a satellite map of the Western US sometime.
- ilickpoolalgae 3y agoThe trip from Tokyo to Kyoto goes through several cities that have >200k people living in them, several of them being larger than Sacramento. Your point about Tokyo -> Kyoto doesn't change the previous issue of economics of trains due to lack of density. Stops (and Population) on Tokaido Shinkansen between Tokyo and Kyoto: Yokohama: 3mm+ Odawara: 200k+ Hamamatsu: 700k+ Shizuoka: 600k+ Nagoya: 2mm+
- NovemberWhiskey 3y ago... and let's not forget that if you ride that same train for another 50 miles you get to Osaka (~3M) and then Kobe (~1.5M).
- estebank 3y agoBrussels - Paris (~300km): train 1:30hs, €109 flight 1:00hs (+ check in time and baggage pick up), ~$300 driving 3:30hs https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Brussels,+Belgium/Paris,+France/@49.8464158,2.035581,8z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x47c3a4ed73c76867:0xc18b3a66787302a7!2m2!1d4.3571696!2d50.8476424!1m5!1m1!1s0x47e66e1f06e2b70f:0x40b82c3688c9460!2m2!1d2.3522219!2d48.856614!3e4?entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Brussels,+Belgium/Paris,+Fra... San Francisco - Sacramento (~85 miles): train: 2:30hs, $33 driving: 1:30hs
- alephnerd 3y agoSan Francisco-Sacramento has a railway line built already (Capitol Corridor), and it is very intermittent. Furthermore, the Capitol Corridor doesn't pick you up from SF. You need to commute to the Amtrak station in Richmond. Bay Area to Sacramento is the farthest distance that can be financial feasible in the Western United States. A better use of money would be better integrating all of the Bay Area and San Joaquin Valley into a single high frequency system (think ACE on steroids).
- dragonwriter 3y agoSo, San Francisco to Sacramento does not have a railway line already built (at least, not one with passenger service in use.) San Jose to Sacramento does, and there are some stations with other transit connections to SF, notably Richmond, but Richmond (like Oakland, or any of the other East Bay stops) is a different place than San Francisco. It is not so much generically “very intermittent” as optimized for Sacramento to East Bay commuting, with reduced traffic on the extended connection to San Jose, and in the counter-commute direction and off-commute times.
- alephnerd 3y agoExactly! And it's almost impossible to cross coordinate between BART, Caltrain, Capitol Corridor, VTA, ACE, and other myriad of public transit systems in NorCal. I've literally had to wait for Capitol Corridor trains for an hour because my Bart ride was delayed. This is why money is better spent integrating the systems at the subregional level instead.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Rail systems work in Europe because densities are extremely high. Rail systems work in Europe because European cities have decent local transit/walkability. Rail systems are challenging in the US because the US invested heavily in destroying local transit and walkability for a mixture of reasons (auto industry influence, deliberate attempts at de facto racial segregation, especially in the wake of pressures against de jure segregation, and some other reasons), so once you get somewhere by rail you can’t get anywhere else, unless the train station wastes a whole lot of space – and airports already do, but its less of a burden for them because airports need to be pretty sprawling to start with — having giant parking lots for round trip passengers and rental cars and for access to serve as giant road transport (bus, taxi, rideshare) hubs. Which is why you can’t just build long-range passenger rail in the US, you have to also build or significantly upgrade local transit networks at the termini and intermediate stops and also deal with the local development patterns in all those places (you don’t have to do it all at once, but if you don’t, you have to accept that you aren’t getting all the benefits until you do.) And you are going to be fought the whole way by forces that recognize the connections and oppose any part of it, for any of the reasons the status quo exists as it does.
- alephnerd 3y agoTake a look at a map sometime. When I travel from Brussels to Berlin (similar to SF to LA), I can pass through Cologne (pop 3.3m), Frankfurt (pop 770k), Hannover (pop 500k), and Hamburg (pop 5.5m). When I travel from the Bay Area to Greater Los Angeles, I can only pass through Fresno (pop 700k) and Bakersfield (pop 500k) This is the issue. There isn't enough population between metros in the Western United States to support the financial burden of managing such a system.
- dragonwriter 3y agoI don’t disagree that its an issue, but it is not, IMO, the issue, or even the most important one. Access between the station and the rest of the metro at the termini (and also at whatever stations might exist along the route) is more of an issue than the frequency and size of the intermediate cities along the route.