2 ms·
The money spent on that long distance alternate transport can be better spent enhancing existing short distance transport. There is a finite pool of money that
by alephnerd 3y ago
The money spent on that long distance alternate transport can be better spent enhancing existing short distance transport.
There is a finite pool of money that can be spent on infrastructure.
Investing on enhancing and integrating the Capitol Corridor, ACE, Caltrains, BART, Muni, and VTA into a unified system has a better RoI than a 400-500mi rail line that will most likely have a train leaving on an hourly cadence.
It's a similar story for Los Angeles and San Diego.
Flights cost around $100-200 for a round trip and take around 3 hours even factoring in security and commute to and from the airport. It would be the same length of time commuting from a railway station to the other, the railway would take 2 additional hours, and the price would be roughly comparable.
- 1024core 3y ago> The money spent on that long distance alternate transport can be better spent enhancing existing short distance transport. > There is a finite pool of money that can be spent on infrastructure. Exactly. The metric should be passenger-miles, nothing else. That is the most useful metric. If spending $100B on SF to LA (400mi) impacts 1M passengers per year, then that's 400M passenger-miles, or 250 dollars per pax-mile. But if spending $5B on (say) SF to SJ (50mi) impacts 1M passengers per year, which is 50M passenger-miles, then it is 100 dollars per pax-mile, a much better tradeoff.
- alephnerd 3y ago> The metric should be passenger-miles, nothing else San Jose to SF (Caltrain) has a yearly ridership of 5.5 Million. Los Angeles to SF has a yearly ridership of 2.2 Million. I don't think you've ever been to California, or at least haven't had to commute recently.
- 1024core 3y ago> I don't think you've ever been to California, or at least haven't had to commute recently. I live in California, chief. You know what they say about making ASSumptions? And I was using round numbers to make the calculations easier and the point easier to understand.