3 ms·
> Why not allow forgiveness for the only debt in the entire US that legally cannot be discharged through bankruptcy? Well for starters they signed on the line
by koolba 3y ago
> Why not allow forgiveness for the only debt in the entire US that legally cannot be discharged through bankruptcy?
Well for starters they signed on the line that is dotted. Their peers who went to trade school or got a job at McDonald's didn't co-sign their loans.
Plus, the interest rates on debt with no collateral that could be discharged in bankruptcy would be significantly higher. There's nothing special about tuition payments not being dischargeable in bankruptcy, it's student loans specifically. If you pay your tuition or buy books on a credit card then you could declare bankruptcy and it'd be treated like all your other obligations.
> If you're anti-loan-forgiveness then you need to allow people to discharge these things in bankruptcy.
No you don't. Bailing out people for bad decisions like attending overly expensive schools or acquiring useless degrees is a bad idea. It just incentivizes more bad behavior.
King for a day, I'd remove the government out of the student loan business entirely. That'd have a massive drop in college pricing. Let all loans be private and let them be dischargeable in bankruptcy. But changing the rules in an existing system on already made agreements is a bad idea.
- tzs 3y ago> King for a day, I'd remove the government out of the student loan business entirely. That'd have a massive drop in college pricing. Why do you think it would do that? I once tried to take a look at college pricing over the last century but wasn't able to find much data. For the few schools where I did find data I found a general trend of college prices going up at something like 2ish times the inflation rate. That trend didn't show any obvious change when the government got into the student loan business. Prices continued to go up at about the same rate I'd expect based on how they had gone up before. That suggests government loans aren't a major factor in price increases, and so it seems doubtful that taking them away would make much pricing difference.