5 ms·
There isn't much overlap between 2/3 Wheeler EVs and EV cars in India. 3 Wheeler EVs are booming because the prices are very low and allow you start your own b
by alephnerd 3y ago
There isn't much overlap between 2/3 Wheeler EVs and EV cars in India.
3 Wheeler EVs are booming because the prices are very low and allow you start your own business by undercutting Auto Rickshaw unions. Your average auto rickshaw or e-rickshaw driver can make around $150-200/mo tax free and eligible for subsidies, making it more competitive than working at a factory ($250-300/mo but 5% income tax and not eligible for subsidies). This makes EV 3 wheelers attractive as it's an investment in a small business.
On the other hand, EV cars aren't as popular in India yet due to range anxiety. Price doesn't factor as much because the tax incentives are made to incentivize EV cars (50% tax on disel/gas cars bit 5% tax on EV) and EVs are fairly affordable (a starting model Tata Tiago EV is around $9-10k) but no one trusts EV charging infra in India, so people are delaying purchases in order to buy a premium diesel car (eg. Toyota Fortuner, Mahindra Thar), eat the tax and buy a $4-6k Renault or Maruti ICE car for $9-10k after tax, or just keeps driving their gas car. This will change in 10 years, but the future is looking Hybrid, especially because Toyota is looking at expanding in India and lobbied a drastic tax cut [0]
No one actually buys 2 wheeler EVs - you can save $1-2k more and buy a luxury 2 wheeler like a KTM Super Duke. Most electric 2 wheeler sales are driven by Ola (India's Uber/Doordash) subsidizing it's drivers and deliverers to buy an Ola manufactured 2 wheeler while working for Ola.
[0] - https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/toyota-lobbies-india-cut-hybrid-car-taxes-much-21-letter-2023-10-23/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/toyota...
- dilawar 3y ago> No one actually buys 2 wheeler EVs - you can save $1-2k more and buy a luxury 2 wheeler like a KTM Super Duke 2 wheeler EV is not a rare sight in Bangalore. Probably 1 in 200 two wheelers is EV in my neighborhood.
- alephnerd 3y agoBangalore =/= India. Most of Bangalore's case is because of Ola subsidizing it's drivers to buy an Ola Bike [0][1]. For people who don't know, Ola is India's indigenous Uber+Doordash competitor. If you're price sensitive, you can always buy a used Hero Honda for around $500-1k, so cheaper than a 2 wheeler EV. If you aren't price conscious, you can buy a luxury bike like a KTM or a car. [0] - https://m.economictimes.com/industry/renewables/electric-two-wheeler-sales-surge-by-33-3-in-2023-24-ola-tops-chart/articleshow/108960905.cms https://m.economictimes.com/industry/renewables/electric-two... [1] - https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-electric-two-wheelers-bike-taxis-ecommerce-deliveries-bhavish-aggarwal https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-electric-two-wheelers-bike...
- hunter2_ 3y agoI recently had to look up what constitutes "common" vs. "rare" and I found the typical threshold to be 5%. You're only at 10% of that so I'd call it very rare.
- lostlogin 3y ago> Your average auto rickshaw or e-rickshaw driver can make around $150-200/mo tax free and eligible for subsidies, making it more competitive than working at a factory ($250-300/mo but 5% income tax and not eligible for subsidies). It’s before my morning coffee, so I’m likely missing something. How is the factory worker earning less? Are subsidies huge?
- alephnerd 3y ago> Are subsidies huge Yep. If you earn less that $3k a year, 1. You pay no income tax 2. You get heavily subsidized groceries (what would cost $30/mo becomes $10/mo) 3. You can buy a heavily subsidized apartment (PMAY-U) 4. Depending on the state, you can get free electricity, water, etc. 5. If you are in a semi-rural area, you can get psudeo-UBI via the MGNREGA program With all of this, you can end up netting an additional $700-1.2k a year tax free. Fundamentally, China and Vietnam were able to succeed at pushing people into factory work because these kinds of subsidies didn't exist, forcing people to choose between working at a factory or starve. Also, factories in China and Vietnam would build dormitories, but in India that falls foul of labor laws. This is why most migrant workers in India are from the state of Bihar - the government in this state has been incompetent at running welfare programs, so rural poverty has not been alleviated.
- jtrip 3y ago>Fundamentally, China and Vietnam were able to succeed at pushing people into factory work because these kinds of subsidies didn't exist, forcing people to choose between working at a factory or starve. Also, factories in China and Vietnam would build dormitories, but in India that falls foul of labor laws. That's dubious thinking. The hurdles to establishment of a manufacturing base are not labor shortages. The biggest issue in India is the ease of doing business[0] and the bureaucratic red tape. India ranks 136 in 190 countries in starting new businesses, among many other accolades. [0] https://archive.doingbusiness.org/en/rankings https://archive.doingbusiness.org/en/rankings [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24106545 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24106545
- 3y ago
- xbmcuser 3y agoIt's just the start prices for batteries and evs will keep coming down. So will the electricity prices as solar prices are also falling. The space is moving too fast to hold any concrete opinions economics says electric will price out ice in the next 1p years for a lot of transport
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is a Western point of view. Already from a financial standpoint, an EV is much cheaper than a Gas Car in India (an entry level Tata EV costs $9-10k after tax, and an entry level ICE Maruti Suzuki costs around $9-11k after tax), but everyone is holding out on buying one until the charging infrastructure is actually built. The charging network in India just doesn't exist. At most there might be 2 charging ports at a gas station, and oftentimes the station attendants just don't maintain them leading to broken chargers. Infra enhancement is happening, but it will take 4-7 years to happen. This is why Hybrids are becoming popular - the taxes on them got dropped to the same amount as an EV, and you won't face range anxiety as you can switch back to gas.
- Hypocritelefty 3y ago[dead]
- hunter2_ 3y ago> At most there might be 2 charging ports at a gas station Unless these gas stations are also 30+ minute shopping/eating destinations, the chargers ought to be places that are.
- Karrot_Kream 3y agoIndian urban areas are built a lot denser than the US. 30+ minutes of driving between shopping/eating destinations isn't a concern for customers in the 3 wheeler market.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chrismorgan 3y ago> $250-300/mo but 5% income tax and not eligible for subsidies 300 USD per month means ₹3,00,000 per year; remember then to take into account the Section 87A rebate, which amounts to you paying no tax if your total income is less than ₹7,00,000 (5 lakh in previous years).
- ta_vf7xjd34cc 3y agoUnder the new tax regime, individual income up to ₹750,000 is tax free due to a combination of standard deduction and 87A. Given that many small businesses often accept UPI payments in multiple names (husband, wife, mother etc), a small family can actually manage ₹1,500,000-3,000,000 in (legitimate) tax free income. That is about $18-36,000. Which is a lot in India.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- digdugdirk 3y agoFor anyone who doesn't ride motorcycles - a KTM Super Duke is a lunatic hooligan bike (in the best way) that barely fits within the boundaries of safe operation on the open roads of the USA. I cannot comprehend riding one on the busy streets of an Indian city. It'd be fun while it lasted, at least.
- xenospn 3y agoRiding anything in India is an extreme sport. That country is absolute madness.
- mangamadaiyan 3y agoTry crossing the road as a pedestrian in Bangalore. It's even more of an extreme sport.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lazide 3y agoOne of my favorite memories was getting across the street to a restaurant with some noobs in front of one of the FAANG offices in Bangalore - high traffic times, so no way to do so on foot without a noob ending up dead. An auto rickshaw, 15 minutes, and two different bribes to the traffic police did the trick though.
- mangamadaiyan 3y agoWere the bribes needed because the rick was overloaded, or because the rick went the wrong way, or both?
- lazide 3y agoIt was the only way to do the turns necessary to get there in 15 minutes due to heavy traffic. The traffic police were blocking them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dzhiurgis 3y ago> no one trusts EV charging infra in India Sodium batteries is going to be a boom for India. 2x cheaper (albeit heavier), charges in 5-15 minutes.
- alephnerd 3y agoThat's why Toyota and Idemetsu Kosan announced that they should be mass producing Solid State Batteries ny 2027 at Narendra Modi's Vibrant Gujarat conference earlier this year [0] (also as a way to lobby their way into getting tax exemptions on Hybrid PEVs) [0] - https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/toyota-roll-out-solid-state-battery-evs-couple-years-india-executive-says-2024-01-11/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/toyota...
- dzhiurgis 3y agoSolid state batteries are something different. Both Lithium and Sodium can be used for them - Lithium has better density, but again Sodium is cheaper. Sodium ones are still being researched, but eventually can be 2-3x energy denser than current Lithium Ion.
- OJFord 3y agoI've noticed petrol autos marketing themselves as not CNG/LPG as an advantage, what's that about - refuelling time should it be needed? Or safety? Just curious where EVs sit in that regard because I don't remember noticing any the couple of times I've been to Delhi, and AIUI they'd have been the previous environmental step forward.
- alephnerd 3y agoProbably so the auto drivers don't get their skull cracked by a tire iron. Auto Rickshaw unions are VERY politically powerful. One former member has become Chief Minister (Eknath Shinde) and have played a major role in swinging elections in Delhi (INC to AAP), Karnataka (BJP to INC), and Telangana (BRS to INC). E-Rickshaws are excluded from these unions, as most e-rickshaw drivers tend to be migrant workers from poorer areas like Bihar or Eastern UP while Auto Rickshaw drivers tend to be locals of the state. By advertising as being petrol, that means they are part of the Auto Rickshaw unions, so you as an e-rickshaw driver or police officer know not to mess with them.
- saagarjha 3y agoI was just there last year and they’ve started to pop up, but only really as company-provided cars (Blu I think?)
- jes5199 3y agoI hear that “the future is hybrid” talking point a lot lately and I think that means Toyota is successfully controlling the narrative, but that’s not the “future”, it’s the present. Hybrids just don’t benefit enough from Wright’s law to stay cost-competitive for long. Charging infrastructure will catch up, because charging infrastructure is cheap
- alephnerd 3y agoThis is a conversation about India, not the US. The market and business environment in India is entirely different from the US. Charging infra will eventually get built in India, but it will take 4-7 years at least. At that point it makes sense to save a bit more money to buy a $12k Toyota or Maruti Suzuki hybrid instead of spending $9k on a Tata EV. The Toyota and Maruti Hybrid will have a longer range, and you don't need to worry about running out of battery in a random town in the middle of nowhere in India - a country where the law and order situation is not great.
- guerby 3y agoWhat is the price of electricity vs petrol for vehicules in India?
- jes5199 3y agookay but what about $6k on an EV. There’s a point where you have to say, okay, I’ll figure out charging
- alephnerd 3y agoThe cheapest EV is the BYD Seagull at $9,700 [0], so roughly the same price as the Tata Tiago EV after tax. [0] - https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/chinas-byd-lowers-starting-price-its-lowest-priced-ev-model-seagull-by-54-2024-03-06/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/chinas...
- jes5199 3y ago
- throwrv 3y agoI highly doubt your claims. "Ola subsidizes that's why people are buying 2wheelers" That's whats happened in USA, EU, China or anywhere else for that matter. "No ev charging stations" Reliance already got into the charging station business and most importantly there are startups convincing third-parties to turn their homes into charging stations which I believe is the right solution
- alephnerd 3y ago> That's whats happened in USA, EU, China or anywhere else for that matter Ola has explicitly stated that they will make Ola drivers start using Ola Electric e-bikes [0], and the overwhelming majority of 2 wheeler EV sales are Ola Electric bikes. > Reliance already got into the charging station business and most importantly there are startups convincing third-parties to turn their homes into charging stations which I believe is the right solution Most of the Jio gas stations (like the ones in my ancestral village) only add 1 or at most 2 charging stations for EV cars, and Reliance corporate doesn't provide maintenance support. Those same startups trying to convince people make homes into charging stations simply won't succeed outside of urban areas because of the trust deficit that exists. The future of the Indian EV sector is in Tier 3-4 metros and small towns. That is where the majority of Indian urbanization is happening, and even where most of the sale for e-rickshaws are happening. Charging stations will eventually get built, but it's a 4-7 year process. [0] - https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-electric-two-wheelers-bike-taxis-ecommerce-deliveries-bhavish-aggarwal https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-electric-two-wheelers-bike... [1] - https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-to-deploy-two-wheeler-evs https://yourstory.com/2024/01/ola-to-deploy-two-wheeler-evs
- mukundmr 3y ago2 Wheeler EV penetration is increasing in India. "2W EVs form the majority of EV sales today, accounting for 85%–90% of all EV units sold in India, followed by 4W EVs (7%–9% of sales) and 3W EVs (5%–7% of sales)." Source: https://www.bain.com/insights/india-electric-vehicle-report-2023/ https://www.bain.com/insights/india-electric-vehicle-report-.... EVs have crossed the 6% threshold of volume of all vehicles sold in India. India's EV migration will start from 2 wheeler and 3 wheeler EVs. Public transport is already migrating to EV based. City buses have already migrated to EVs in cities like Pune and other cities are catching up. Cars and long distance transport trucks will be last. You can read up on the EV statistics here - https://www.autocarpro.in/analysis-sales/over-34-million-evs-on-indian-roads-maharashtra-leads-in-2ws-pvs-and-buses-up-in-3ws--118891 https://www.autocarpro.in/analysis-sales/over-34-million-evs...
- rob74 3y agoI've never been to India, but I have seen (and heard, and smelled) the multitude of two-stroke-engine-powered vehicles in Southern European cities, so I can imagine having them replaced by electric versions would be a blessing...
- Gibbon1 3y agoCalifornia long ago banned 2 cycle golf carts. I used to until recently owned one. If you said they were a 100 times more polluting than a car with a catalytic converter I'd believe it. For a developing country better air quality, less noise and not needing to import oil seem like a win win win.
- gopalv 3y ago> the multitude of two-stroke-engine-powered vehicles in Southern European cities, so I can imagine having them replaced by electric versions In India, the 4-stroke came in big right around the time when leaded fuel got banned. The anti-knock stuff only really worked properly on a 4-stroke, so you'll notice that it took somewhere between 2000 and 2005 to really kill the new vehicle market for 2S. However, the sound, that is what is completely different about these - you can actually talk on your phone sitting in the electric versions, while the petrol ones need you to shout over it when it goes up a hill. The most interesting intersection for me was the mobile app and the EV charger combo the drivers use. In my last visit to Kerala there were plug points under some street lights which could charge these 3-wheelers at 240v at 15amps off the pole. These guys would just be parked right under one of those, with their mobile apps open & they'll unplug only once they get a pickup location, keeping their batteries perpetually topped up when idle.
- rldjbpin 3y ago2 wheelers do have their place and are well positioned imo. they have easy-to-remove batteries that counter reliance on charging infrastructure. this with enough range for an average middle class commuter in small to large towns. the last mile transport rental market was quite ripe to complement the gig economy guys pre-pandemic but i wonder if it will recover for regular commuters in major cities to the same level.
- zardo 3y agoYou don't mean the Duke? The Super Duke is 21k USD, surely the cheap electric motorbikes are coming in below that.