5 ms·
FCC chair rejects call to impose Universal Service fees on broadband
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoI'm totally onboard with universal service fees if the companies finally start being regulated like utilities and be mandated to provide service to everyone. They want the benefit without the responsibilities.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoUniversal Service Fees should go into a fund for muni and coop internet providers. No for profit subsides. Or pay out of the general fund as Nifty3929 mentions. This is foundational developed world infra, and should be treated like roads, schools, libraries, etc. Once the fiber is in the ground (raceway, conduit, direct burial, whatever), it is citizen fiber forever.
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoYes! I am all about having muni fiber. It's one of my major 'wants' for my next relocation.
- anuptalwalkar 3y agoUniversal fees for cause always start with specific cause, and then after a few years some bill sneaks in to repurpose those funds to something else.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoI would agree democracy and governance is work, the schlep is never ending. Government is accountable to its citizens, citizens are accountable to keep government on task and honest. Government is us, hence the inherit nature of this all being a system held together in tension. There is always hope, with my apologies to Banksy.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- karma_pharmer 3y agoExactly. Dark fiber in the Right-of-Way should be a regulated monopoly prohibited from vertically integrating with the rest of the value chain. Just like water pipes, sewer pipes, and power lines. Electrical utilities aren't allowed to venture into the data-center business, for example. Or the aluminum-smelting business. Why is this so difficult?
- dehrmann 3y ago> provide service to everyone They can't or don't want to. Too much of the US is too rural for cost-effective near-universal wire/fiber broadband access.
- Nifty3929 3y agoGood - we should not use fees and fines to pay for government services we wish to provide. It creates a situation where gov't agencies begin to exist for their own sake, and to levy such fees/fines to fund themselves, past the point at which they are serving their desired purpose. If we want to provide "programs such as Lifeline discounts and Rural Digital Opportunity Fund deployment grants for ISPs," then we should just do that right out of the general fund. And as long as that cost sits there on the books we can continue to evaluate if we want to grow, shrink, or let it alone.
- wing-_-nuts 3y ago>It creates a situation where gov't agencies begin to exist for their own sake, and to levy such fees/fines to fund themselves, past the point at which they are serving their desired purpose. Would you have examples of this in the US?
- adolph 3y agoCivil forfeiture is a related example that comes to mind. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Civil_forfeiture_in_the_United...
- Nifty3929 3y agoThere are so, so many. Even traffic tickets are in this category. If we think it's a good idea to enforce speed laws, we should be willing to pay for that (the officers) directly as part of the police budget paid exclusively from the gov't general budget. If a fine is a good enforcement mechanism, okay - but then just refund that directly to taxpayers. Or use a difference enforcement mechanism like holding the driver by the side of the road for an inconvenient period of time.
- adolph 3y agoMy first guess is that the penalty box wouldn't pass constitutional muster but that it might be a nice method. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penalty_box https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penalty_box
- adolph 3y agoWhy should "broadband" get an exemption? Why does POTS get a USF but not the pipes for VoIP? Imposing similar assessments on broadband could increase the Universal Service Fund's size and/or reduce the charges on phone service, spreading the burden more evenly across different types of telecommunications services.
- ensignavenger 3y agoBecause we want to promote affordable broadband access, not add charges on top of it. I think there is room for a continuing conversation on this matter, but I am glad they aren't rushing into it.
- reaperman 3y agoTl;dr would be "It's always been exempt because the USF was created for telephones before home broadband existed and no law was ever written to apply the fee to broadband. Lobbyists against net neutrality have been throwing around the idea that classifying broadband until Title II would force the USF fee to suddenly apply to broadband, but the FCC says there's no validity to that legal theory." Best background on it is probably the Wikipedia article[0], which is surprisingly thorough on this. Currently broadband is already exempt from USF fees because it's never been a "telecommunications service" in a way that's truly equivalent to how telephone lines are classified as a "telecommunications service". Everything around broadband regulation feels very piecemeal and disjointed because US politics/legislation in general has been largely piecemeal ever since broadband came out (except for the Patriot Act and ACA). When telephone was gaining popularity in the 1930's, Congress was in the habit of undertaking and enacting much bolder/unified/populist packages - Glass-Steagal/FDIC, Rural Electrification Act, the New Deal, etc and they wrote a big framework for telephony regulation with the Communications Act of 1934. The Telecommunications Act of 1996 built on the 1934 act to establish the "Universal Service Fund"; but broadband was never formally that type of "telecommunications service". This statement from the FCC announcing their intention to exempt broadband from USF is politically expedient for designating broadband to be regulated as a common carrier under Title II. That reason alone would likely be sufficient to drive this decision. I doubt that it's the entire rationale, but it is enough. Net neutrality is the biggest issue that the current FCC leadership is looking at and the only issue where large amounts of money and power is potentially at stake. Net neutrality has a complex technical narrative that's difficult to communicate effectively to constituents. If corporate lobbying campaigns can push the message that the FCC's drive for net neutrality is the direct cause of a new fee, it could result in the public viewing net neutrality very negatively. In more detail, it's not clear that regulating broadband under Title II of the Communications Act of 1934 would actually require it to be subject to the Universal Service Fund (Telecommunications Act of 1996). That started as and remains just a talking point of lobbyists who are paid to argue against net neutrality. The FCC says they won't be forced to and there's not much in the way of super-detailed legal argument around the issue that I can find - if the FCC was wrong about that I'd expect someone would have published something which clearly walks through the issue and shows why they're wrong. The current leadership of the FCC is generally focused on benefitting the consumer. Their current focuses could be called "populist" but it seems like the current FCC leadership really does want everyone to win and genuinely doesn't appear to be overtly/reactively/dogmatically hostile to corporate interests on the whole. The main two things I've seen this FCC taking on are moving broadband to Title II common-carrier status, and taking a look at Xfinity charging customers $50 if they go over a 1.2TB/month data cap[1]. However, one commissioner shared more about what he's focused on here on HN[2]. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Universal_Service_Fund 1: Consumers can violate Xfinity's data cap by using the offered 1Gbps download speed for just 3 hours per month (or 6 minutes per day) and the "meter" is not something that can be inspected or calibrated by states' Weights & Measures divisions. 2: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37392676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37392676
- ethbr1 3y agoAs noted in the article, the FCC is currently fighting to reimpose net neutrality on broadband providers, and the USF would muddy the waters of an already contentious debate. Imho, net neutrality >> USF
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: FCC to vote on restoring net neutrality https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39923231 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39923231
- tomohawk 3y agoVouchers instead of service fees would be better. Having finally achieved fiber broadband in a rural area, the main obstacle to build out is the provider being able to cover the initial cost. Our new provider is a municipal broadband company. If the people in an area all had a voucher to cover the connect, they would have built into our area years prior. Instead, they had apply and wait for grants. Vouchers would incentivize companies to build, as the more they build, the more vouchers they could collect on. It would encourage competition for the service. Service fees result in this top down grant system that encourages no build out unless a grant is received, delaying build out. The large telco in many rural areas is Frontier. They are terribly run and I think they have been in chapter 11 for years. In our area, you can see their lines are unmaintained with trees leaning on the lines for years now. The only time they do anything is when they get some competition in an area, in which case they'll do the minimum to make it unprofitable for the other company in that area.
- m463 3y ago> trees leaning on the lines I've wondered about this. As opposed to electrical service, I think an ISP can put up wires in a hugely redundant fashion with multiple routes to each house. If maintaining can be done at their leisure this way, say trimming back the trees every few years, can't costs be lower? I'm thinking in an engineering sense. You probably know your ISP and they are probably maximizing profit, not cutting your costs.