3 ms·
It is absolutely absolutely packed with unlicensed, copyrighted data. Books3 is the most notable example - nearly 200,000 pirated ebooks - but a lot of the res
by simonw 3y ago
It is absolutely absolutely packed with unlicensed, copyrighted data.
Books3 is the most notable example - nearly 200,000 pirated ebooks - but a lot of the rest of it is (unlicensed) scraped web data.
The legal questions over whether this is a problem are currently still unresolved. Many people are also bothered by the ethical implications, which is a separate issue from the legal questions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 23B1 3y agoIronic that even our everyday governance has little 'Alignment' between ethics and law.
- jacobn 3y agoEthics are a lot more nuanced and change a lot faster than laws. Heck, a large fraction of ethics seem to be so fickle that they’re subject to potential revision by every generation. In fact, I’d argue that those revisions are a significant portion of how one generation distinguishes itself from their parents. Yet strangely every generation feels like they have arrived at a set of “universal laws” in their ethics.
- KarlKemp 3y agoIn this case, both ethics and the law are murky. Pretty excellent alignment, for once?
- ben_w 3y agoWe wouldn't need lawyers if all the rules could be expressed as "be ethical".
- 23B1 3y agoThe lawyers certainly agree with you on that!