3 ms·
I wouldn't. Black refers to a specific ethnicity: the diaspora of African people brought forcibly to the Americas, stripped of their original cultural heritage,
by tptacek 3y ago
I wouldn't. Black refers to a specific ethnicity: the diaspora of African people brought forcibly to the Americas, stripped of their original cultural heritage, and intermixed with other similarly situated people. It's capitalized for the same reason you'd capitalize "Irish".
(I also probably just wouldn't refer to British people as "black", for whatever that's worth).
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> probably just wouldn't refer to British people as "black" Not all, but many have African heritage. They're both black and British. I understand why we capitalise Black and also why some people object to it. I simply found it humorous to notice that it's an America-centric vision of ethnicity; why a black African gets a lower-case b while a Black Chicagoan gets a full-blown B seems to have escaped at least me until now.
- tptacek 3y agoIt's not so much an American-centric vision of ethnicity so much as it is an American ethnicity.
- dctoedt 3y agoInteresting: By that definition (which is very appealing, especially the "Irish" analogy), a Nigerian-born American would not count as "Black" but as "black"?
- tptacek 3y agoIn theory yes? In practice I'd imagine all African folks in America would be called "Black" --- in the same sense that we're not at all careful about whether we call me "Irish" (which I half am) or "Slovak". But yeah: what you're trying to recognize with the capital is the distinct, uniquely American constructed ethnic identity, the ethnicity of the blues, of the Harlem Renaissance, of the AME church, of cornbread and grits (a great example, because you only get it by mixing African influences with Native American influences).