3 ms·
Good AI Should Be Invisible
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lenerdenator 3y agoMost humans are going to have a problem with an AI that gets ideas about what it should do and when without human intervention, at least until we can show why AI does deterministically.
- Avicebron 3y agoWhy use AI? Having something working in the background reliably that you don't want to have to mess around with...sounds like a traditional deterministic system would be better. Unless of course there's a log of explanation for every action generated to debug in case something goes wrong...but at that point it's not in the background
- skilled 3y agoThe author is on HN[0], but it's not him who submitted it. As far as I can tell, this is very much an ALPHA-stage product, and one of the issues it will struggle with is the security aspect. It does emphasize it, both in the docs[1] and on the homepage[2], but I personally would never take those kind of reassurances for granted. And for an average person, it won't make any sense to them (i.e. CASA). Maybe someone here on HN have suggestions for the author, because getting security right is probably the biggest thing for a project like this. I also couldn't find any open-source links (GitHub) anywhere. You probably don't need to publish all of your code, but you can earn developer trust in other ways also, starting with showcasing who you are. Then again, all of that might be taken care of in later versions of the product. [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39834617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39834617 [1]: https://doc.getgabrielai.com/security/ https://doc.getgabrielai.com/security/ [2]: https://getgabrielai.com/ https://getgabrielai.com/
- exsomet 3y agoReading this, I don’t get the sense that it’s exactly the interpretation that the author intended, but I don’t think AI should be invisible at all. One of the (missing) core ethical tenets of AI integrating with daily life is that the people it is operating on (hey, that’s you and me!) should be aware of what it’s doing and have the ability to participate with that system or not without having to go fully off the grid and live in a cabin somewhere if they don’t want what the latest bigcorp AI wants to do to them. Arguably this doesn’t mean people get a vote on what it’s doing, only that they can take it or leave it. The author makes reference to considerations for the humans running the system, but not the ones having it run on them. Until that’s figured out, nothing about it should be invisible.
- noduerme 3y agoIt shouldn't even be invisible in search results, because an LLM's information is inevitably compressed to a point of corruption. But yeah, when we need to start moving to cabins in the wilderness it's game over.
- b-side 3y agoA great example of invisible “AI” IMO is Apples image search it is a feature that works like magic, being able to find photos by searching for text or objects still amazes me every time I use it.