6 ms·
Paying off people's medical debt has little impact on their lives, study finds
- bookofjoe 3y agohttps://archive.ph/NwjdU https://archive.ph/NwjdU
- dangle1 3y agoOne possible explanation is that concern about access to healthcare and fear of medical debt is an ongoing concern in the US. Having one accumulation of debt relieved provides little protection from the vagaries of life creating another insurmountable financial problem.
- tomoyoirl 3y agoParticularly if your medical experience also leaves you predisposed to have further medical complications in your life.
- nottorp 3y agoExactly. Having your current "medical debt" (US only term, I think) paid - if it's all paid, other posts indicate it is not - doesn't exempt you from accumulating more of it in the future. On the contrary, it may make you more likely to get more.
- bdcravens 3y agoI have a serious medical condition, and at different times have had significant medical debt. I've never once had an issue getting access to care, even with organizations that I had bills in collection with.
- buzzert 3y agoIt's illegal to deny care in an emergency setting. Patient abandonment is also illegal (breach of duty).
- rossjudson 3y agoI'd say that by the time the debt relief happens, the damage has already been done...and healing that damage takes a long time. I'd read that article in conjunction with https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/07/us/health-insurance-medical-bills.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/07/us/health-insurance-medic... ...which outlines exactly how insurance companies can just sort of decide...not to pay your medical bills, and leave patients with huge debt.
- rossjudson 3y agoItemized payments and fees for thousands of claims were made public in a lawsuit against Cigna after The Times petitioned the court. The insurer and MultiPlan opposed the release, calling the data “highly confidential.” "For providing outpatient substance abuse treatment, the facility received $134.13. (Fee for Cigna) For processing the claim, Cigna received $658.75, nearly five times as much as the treatment center. (Fee for MultiPlan) For recommending a payment amount, MultiPlan received $167.48, slightly more than the treatment center."
- picadores 3y agoIf you have been poor for 5 years, that is ingrained in your behaviour.
- yareal 3y agoI was homeless, then working below minimum wage for about that long. I now make 750k a year. Don't write off the poor as broken, help them achieve to their ability. Most poor folks aren't poor because of bad choices, they are poor because of systemic issues that make life harder and more expensive. If we lift these people out of that hell scape, they'd be able to do so much more. my bank, for instance, would reorganize my deposits and debits to maximize overdraft fees. I would put cash in, then go use my debit card later in the day, but the debit would process first. Then I would overdraft, then the cash would be applied, then the next purchase would overdraft. Despite the first operation being putting cash in the bank that would cover. My bank also had a 0% interest rate on my savings account because "we made a mistake".
- bdcravens 3y agoYou can be in the upper-middle class and have medical debt that you're unable to pay.
- dec0dedab0de 3y agoAnecdotally this makes sense. Everyone I know with medical debt has no intention of paying it, and would live their lives the same if it were payed off.
- onion2k 3y agoThat explains the mental health aspect, but how can removing a huge debt from someone have no impact on their credit score?
- jurassicfoxy 3y agoBut what value is credit score, really? Like, the most mundane thing credit score might affect is that you have to put a deposit down to get a fancy phone, or an internet service. No one's buying houses, no one needs to buy a car on credit, etc. Credit score is highly overrated, no?
- smeej 3y agoWhere do you live that no one is buying houses or taking out a car loan?
- jurassicfoxy 3y agoMany many people are never going to buy houses. I've never owned a house. Probably never will. I've never owned a new car, either, and I'm older than dirt. Some commenters had good counter examples, but those seemed to me like the main reasons to "need" a good credit score.
- smeej 3y agoI get individual people being like this, but enough for someone to assume it's the norm? That's what surprised me.
- serf 3y agoa credit score locks people out of an entire tier of purchases that could reasonably be paid off over time if they weren't entirely opt-ed out by credit, it isn't just fancy phones and internet services. i've known home-owners that can't get financed for things like air conditioners because of medical debt -- and they were home owners -- and large appliances like that constitute large purchases espescially for those on fixed incomes; this essentially means there is a group of people that own homes, , likely retired so they're working on a fixed income and could surely use the flexibility of finance options, need to finance the repairs, and can't because of unrelated medical debt.
- bluish29 3y agoI assume that a lot of people who have medical dept know that they will never pay that. Some even will choose that without eveb try. So regardless of the details, morality and problems in healthcare system. I would like if someone can explain what are the consequences or non payment. How is that different from not paying credit card balance?.
- devin 3y agoThe consequences are not the same as a credit card. Medical debt in the US does not show up like credit card debt and does not have bearing on your credit score. People with massive medical debt can arrange with the health system to pay $50 per month on a $50,000 medical bill, and it has no material impact on their credit.
- adamc 3y agoI didn't know that. I have to say, this is a crazy system. Why not just have a single payer rather than saddle people with debts that they cannot (and will not) pay off? It's got to cause a lot of stress.
- rjbwork 3y agoBecause then insurance companies wouldn't be able to skim ~20% off the top of the system. A lot of people who own stock in those insurance companies would be very upset.
- School-Cotton 3y ago> Why not just The US can't "just" do anything because the political system is completely deadlocked. It's not really like well-functioning democracies where a coalition can win an election with a particular set of proposals for reform and then get those implemented.
- adamc 3y agoYeah, but this pre-dates that gridlock. Not disagreeing. Actually, the Republican party these days is capable of gridlocking itself. I've never seen such a high level of dysfunction -- enough so that I suspect we are living in some transition period, although what we are transitioning to I am uncertain. I don't think the current Republican party is stable.
- russnewcomer 3y agoI wonder if part of this has to do with the more complex, piecemeal nature of medical debt and these buybacks. How I understand several of these groups (I'm not certain of the one in the article) do these debt purchases is that they purchase debt that has already been bundled together and resold. So when a person owes medical debt to a hospital, a doctor, a surgeon's practice, a pharmacy, etc, they may owe 15k in total, and these buybacks only cover one resold debt, they may have their hospital debt forgiven, for example, but still own 10k in total to the 3 or 4 other creditors. Contrast that to a mortgage debt, for example, where paying off the mortgage relieves all anxiety around that debt, and I can see how the difference in complex, multi-creditor debt versus simpler, singular-creditor debt could help address the findings of this study.
- slfnflctd 3y agoPaying off your mortgage virtually eliminates your chances of ending up homeless, and absolutely drastically reduces those odds in the near term. This is at the foundational layer of Maslov's hierarchy of needs. I'd expect the impact on one's daily sense of well being to be massive. Paying off your medical debt might improve your credit score over a long period of time, assuming you have other things going for you in that area. People who are worried about becoming homeless generally do not give a single shit about their credit scores. Having good credit one day is an aspirational thing for probably the majority of humans, closer to the 'optional' upper layer of Maslov's model.
- Avicebron 3y agoI like how a foundational layer of maslov's hierarchy of needs is just something we shrug off as unattainable to many, but god forbid we discourage people from chasing profits at the expense of all else
- bparsons 3y agoBy the time a non-profit has paid off your medical debt, your financial life has already been destroyed by these companies. It is a band-aid.
- zikduruqe 3y agoOur family filed for bankruptcy due to medical debt. Within two years, our lives were back to normal. I financed a car at a cheap interest rate, and bought a house (and my current interest rate is 2.5%). Anytime a financial institution asked why we filed for bankruptcy, we told them it was due to medical bills and they would laugh and say that they see it all the time. It really wasn't a big deal. And businesses get to do this all the time for bad business ventures. Why can't people do it because of no fault of their own? Sometimes bad things happen to good people.
- yareal 3y agoWhat if you have a chronic medical issue?
- zikduruqe 3y agoI'm not a medical expert, but I would guess that the initial diagnosis and treatment of a serious medical issue is more expensive, than the maintenance of a chronic condition that is already diagnosed and defined. Regardless, the US medical system sucks. If any other industry was run like our current medical system, it would be torn down in a heartbeat by Congress. But there is too much money moving around and those in charge love them some money.
- yareal 3y ago> I'm not a medical expert, but I would guess that the initial diagnosis and treatment of a serious medical issue is more expensive, than the maintenance of a chronic condition that is already diagnosed and defined Unfortunately, as someone who works with the disabled community, that's not always the case. Plenty of folks need constant medication, live in care, support devices that wear out, or other high cost consumables. Agree though, our health care system is terrible.
- thiago_fm 3y ago[flagged]
- lenerdenator 3y agoThe US had real hardship in the Great Depression. There were a lot of social programs, regulations, and other progressive achievements made during that time. Then we were on the winning side in WWII, and happened to be the only place where most of the factories weren't in ruins. We also had a bunch of men trained in the art of war coming back and didn't want them pissed off, so companies were in a place to offer good pay and benefits. This caused a rollback of progressive policies over the next 75 years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lenerdenator 3y agoBy the time people have accrued medical debt, the thing that was going to change their lives in relation to that debt - the procedure itself - has already occurred. And like others in here are saying, many are just willing to tell hospitals "You can't squeeze blood from a stone" in relation to paying off the debt, so paying it just removes some debt they didn't intend on paying anyways. Where the problem comes from is that people put off procedures that are necessary because they are afraid of the debt. Those people never get the debt that has to be paid off to begin with, so they wouldn't be a focus of the study. That being said, they're at the very least more miserable because they're not going to the doctor to get treated. They could also be less productive, develop more expensive conditions, or die.
- serf 3y ago>Where the problem comes from is that people put off procedures that are necessary because they are afraid of the debt. there isn't a singular problem in a country where your credit score can dictate the quality of your future. Yes, you should put out the medical fires first, but to pretend that it's smooth sailing afterwards is to be blind to half of the issue.
- drcongo 3y agoThere should be no such thing as "medical debt" - the social contract is entirely broken in any country where there is. I simply don't understand why people aren't marching in the streets with pitchforks over the issue.
- wan23 3y agoThe most common alternative system is one in which you simply can't get medical care unless you can pay up front.
- TehCorwiz 3y agoWhich countries have that? The most common system I know of is where the government heavily subsidizes medical costs and controls prices to prevent price gouging. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_universal_health_care https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_with_univers...
- drcongo 3y agoI've never come across such a system so I'm very surprised to hear that that is the most common.
- HumblyTossed 3y agoPure propaganda.
- alistairSH 3y agoAre there any moderately wealthy nations that use this system? Certainly, among OECD nations, that's not used.
- DonnyV 3y agoA lot of people in here think that you don't have to pay your medical bills with no consequences. That's absolutely false! Medical debt can destroy your credit and keep you from being able to purchase a car, renting and purchasing a home. It can also increase your car and home insurance rates.
- bdcravens 3y agoIt doesn't have zero effect, but medical debt has been increasingly deemphasized in many credit scoring models over time. Generally speaking, the only medical debt that should show up is anything over $500 that is at least one year in collections.
- xyst 3y ago> Since 2014, R.I.P. Medical Debt estimates that it has eliminated more than $11 billion of debt … Is this before or after it has been sold to collection agencies? If it’s before, that’s kind of amazing. But if it’s after then the hospital billing departments often sell this debt to collection agencies for cents on the dollar. Paying off $11B in the past 10 years is more of a transfer of wealth to the collection agencies. I’m honestly not surprised paying off the medical debt doesn’t help.
- wincy 3y agoI believe RIP Medical Debt ARE the “collection agency”. They buy the medical debt for cents on the dollar from the hospital, then cancel it out.
- xyst 3y agoOh wow then the $11B is not really representative of what was paid then. Seems more like $100M paid to hospitals in exchange for writing off $11B. $100M over a 10 year period doesn’t make the headlines though :(
- toast0 3y agoFrom the paper describing this experiment, they did one trial with buying fresh debt, for 5.5 cents per dollar, direct from the healthcare provider. But, the second experiment and most of RIP's operations buy older debt that's going for one cent or less per dollar. I imagine RIP reports in face value of the debt purchased. It sounds better.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- iancmceachern 3y agoThis isn't the question why need to ask. The question we need to ask is what would have been their mental and physical health if we never had saddled them with it to begin with.
- hooande 3y agoMedical debt is different. The legal system frowns on people running up credit card debt to pay for PS5s or nice vacations with no intention of ever paying it back. That's tantamount to theft. Most medical debt is involuntary and necessary to survive. It doesn't make sense for it to have the same penalties as other forms of credit. In general in the US, life saving or emergency medical care is administered without regard for the patient's ability to pay. Hospitals are already subsidized or compensated in various ways for this. The real issue is preventative or precautionary care. If Americans had that for free, like with the NHS, there would be fewer $XXX,XXX debts later in life.
- geor9e 3y agoThat's because these charities wait until you default on the debt, go to collections, collections finds it so hopeless that they'll collect that they sell it to another collection agency, on and on, until it's bundled as the absolute cheapest debt you can buy, at less than a penny on the dollar. The only folks buying these junk debt bundles are hoping maybe 1 out of 100 of the debts are worth going after. Then the charity takes a look at buying up the cheapest bundle and forgiving it. $11 billion of bundles could have cost the charity $11 million total. There is a floor to the consequences on the customer, which is pretty much hit the moment it goes to collections (unless you have enough assets to make a lawsuit worthwhile). After that it's so far in the rearview mirror they probably don't even discover it happened. I wouldn't be surprised if collections agencies are the main supporters of debt forgiveness charities. Just another income stream for them.
- bastard_op 3y agoMore than 20 years ago, I had my first bs claim from a hospital, where at a hospital that was covered by insurance, my doctor they provided happened to be out-of-area because he was a substitute or something unbeknownst to me and became a several thousand dollar surprise charge. How this was somehow my fault or problem was ridiculous, so I simply didn't pay the bill. They turned it to collections, I started getting calls, but I never across years pick up calls from random people on my cell anyways. They eventually sell off to other vultures that try, and get the same. Then at some point they just stop bothering. What impact did this have on my credit? Absolutely none perceptibly. Since then I make a habit of not paying these when they arise, and let them bounce off a combination of call screening and my ignoring phone calls anyways. If I'm part of the problem, they're the perpetrators of the problem to begin with, and still get rich regardless, so why feed the beast? The whole medical industry and bottom feeders that surround it like collections are just fuct in the US. The industry and governments do nothing to fix it, so why play the game fair.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWorks where archive.ph is blocked: https://web.archive.org/web/20240408130708if_/https://www.nytimes.com/2024/04/08/science/rip-medical-debt.html https://web.archive.org/web/20240408130708if_/https://www.ny...
- rekabis 3y ago> And those whose bills had been paid were just as likely to forgo medical care as those whose bills were left unpaid. This is an utterly irrational statement. If you don’t have medical insurance, you are just as unlikely to seek out medical care with medical debt as you are without it. This statement is just as rational as saying, “those who cannot drive but who had their car loan paid off were just as likely to still not drive as those who could not drive and had no car loan in the first place.”
- nhhjeek 3y agoIt was almost impossible getting my school grade to 4.50 from ridiculous 3.40 after failing a 3 unit International Relation. it was heartbreaking for me as i never could imagine lagging behind spiderwebhack dot co at gmail dot com
- nhhjeek 3y agoIt was almost impossible getting my school grade to 4.50 from ridiculous 3.40 after failing a 3 unit International Relation. it was heartbreaking for me as i never could imagine lagging behind spiderwebhack dot co at gmail dot com helped me in a space of 48hrs which i considered an excellent job