3 ms·
The Big Fund (Chinese subsidy) has ongoing graft and corruption issues [0] all the way to the very top [1][2], so most of that money was never actually deployed
by alephnerd 3y ago
The Big Fund (Chinese subsidy) has ongoing graft and corruption issues [0] all the way to the very top [1][2], so most of that money was never actually deployed competently. This is what lead to Tsinghua Unigroup's collapse, and a number of other corruption probes.
Furthermore, the Big Fund subsidy is an attempt to build a greenfield ecosystem, while CHIPS is basically reinvesting in a brownfield ecosystem.
[0] - https://www.ft.com/content/8358e81b-f4e7-4bad-bc08-19a77035e1b4 https://www.ft.com/content/8358e81b-f4e7-4bad-bc08-19a77035e...
[1] - http://m.ccdi.gov.cn/content/8f/24/93463.html http://m.ccdi.gov.cn/content/8f/24/93463.html
[2] - https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-watchdog-says-is-probing-head-chip-focused-big-fund-2022-08-01/ https://www.reuters.com/world/china/china-watchdog-says-is-p...
- nabla9 3y agoUS is only paying companies to locate. If you have to pay TSMC billions so that they build their factory in Arizona, US is not a competitive place. At least Chinese are paying for technology development.
- alephnerd 3y ago> paying for technology development The US is not paying for that because that is already done in the US ecosystem. For example, DUV and EUV lithography is US DoE IP that was licensed to ASML to prevent anti-trust abuse by Canon in the 2000s. There's a reason why I said "an attempt to build a greenfield ecosystem" Basically, TSMC:SMIC Micron:YTMC Hong Ha:Tower There isn't an Nvidia, AMD, etc equivalent yet in the Chinese ecosystem, and that's why the Big Fund is so big (well, also because of graft as I mentioned)
- nabla9 3y agoNvidia are AMD are fabless design companies. US has very limited edge there.
- alephnerd 3y agoThe Big Fund also funds Fabless design vendors like Biren [0], Ingenic [1], and Zhaoxin [2] in order to build a domestic Nvidia or AMD. The Big Fund funds HUNDREDS of companies, not just SMIC. In fact, SMIC is basically the last man standing, as almost everyone else collapsed (YMTC and Hong Ha were restructured last minute to save Tsinghua Unigroup and other players), which is what triggered Xi's graft probe and hundreds of executives and government officials getting the ax. [0] - https://www.birentech.com/ https://www.birentech.com/ [1] - http://www.ingenic.com.cn/ http://www.ingenic.com.cn/ [2] - http://zhaoxin.com/ http://zhaoxin.com/
- maxglute 3y ago> so most of that money was never actually deployed competently IMO that' doesn't follow. When 100s of billions are involved, graft limited to a few percentage points while rest is deployed correctly. Access money hardly stopped other PRC industrial policy from succeeding. Regardless, small % is still 100s of millions / billions meaning it will get CCDI attention. The issue was coordinating greenfield ecosystem and domestic demand to play nice together, which they couldn't when western options were available. Now PRC domestic semi looks to be integrating at rapid rate, partly because most of the money did their job and build up enough domestic players across the semi supply chain so they're not starting from zero.