3 ms·
> As humans, two or more of us can reason our way to a conclusion without domain knowledge That sounds like step-by-step thinking? > With an LLM I have to pro
by ben_w 3y ago
> As humans, two or more of us can reason our way to a conclusion without domain knowledge
That sounds like step-by-step thinking?
> With an LLM I have to prompt engineer to guide it.
I generally have to in humans, too. I mean, you and I are prompting each other, aren't we?
For me the difference between prompting a human and prompting an AI is that I can reset the AI, I can't make a human forget a previous analogy that had only confused them. (And likewise, I don't expect that I fully forget bad analogies which confuse me, though I do try).
> They work great as knowledge bases though.
IMO, that's their weakest part. We had knowledge bases before — where each claim can be easily localised within the model, corrected when it needs to be, verified in advance, and which give predictable output — LLMs are none of those things.
LLMs are much better at understanding the question (constant time for a fixed-length output, even when the query is phrased badly and relatively complex), and being able to synthesise things in the form of "${x} won't work, try ${y}".
- hackable_sand 3y agoHuh. Do you think integrating the Semantic Web metadata and ontologies in LLM training can help us bootstrap conceptual modeling using natural language?