4 ms·
I've not been advertised to by any AI so far. I've not had a product or service promoted to me by a chat answer, nor have I seen any advertising elements in an
by kazinator 3y ago
I've not been advertised to by any AI so far.
I've not had a product or service promoted to me by a chat answer, nor have I seen any advertising elements in an AI-generated image. The chat experience has been a lot better than, say, Google search, in terms of spam.
The claim would have to be that those promotional elements are there, but are subliminal, so as not to be consciously perceived, which is a stretch.
To be sure, there are likely developments coming which will bear out the concerns in the article.
Also, a lot of AI out there is paid. You get some limited free service, but must sign up and pay for a premium experience. That's the model, not ad support. Some of the sites are additionally ad supported, but in the regular way in that ads appear in the UI (easily blocked by a browser extension).
- nickpsecurity 3y agoI’ll note that Google itself originally started where it was mostly serving its users. Many social media sites were like that. The Xbox Home Screen used to be like that. They captured a huge market, figured out how to integrate ads, and then forced them on their users. AI made or used by ad companies might follow a similar path. I think they’ll mostly try to show you ads outside the AI itself, though. Maybe on the page or in the app where you interact with the AI. Or it stays as bait for their ad-driven services.
- kazinator 3y agoIt will be interesting to see how AI gets deliberately enshittified, and whether those strategies will work. I have a feeling (and I hope I'm right) that people will not tolerate bullshit AI interactions as much as they tolerated crap web search results. My reasoning is due to these differences. - Under web searching, the Ad results (sponsored links) are delineated. You can filter those out or skip them, and you know there is real search content after that. - In the reach search content, there is spam. But there is a rhetoric that at least used to be plausible that the spam is not the search engine's fault. The search engine indexing and ranking follow some algorithm that is not highly intelligent, and is being gamed by the SEO bad guys. Not only did people make that excuse, but they knew that if they sift through the long tail of the search result, they may be able to find what they are looking for; i.e. that it's there, just outranked. I suspect, people won't be willing to apologetic excuses on behalf of AI. If it's bullshitting them, they will end the conversation and go to another AI. Google built an advantage in the search space through massive infrastructure. In AI, it's possible to wield market power through hardware also. All else being equal, people will go for the free, highly available, fast AI, compared to slow, paid, downtime-riddled AI. There will probably be a battle among AIs for integration into applications and services. That's where a particular AI will be able to get a stranglehold on the users: AI integrated into apps for which there are no easy substitutes, and where you can't choose another AI.
- rstuart4133 3y ago> I've not been advertised to by any AI so far ... nor have I seen any advertising elements in an AI-generated image. You do know detecting AI generated anything is mostly an unsolved problem, right? If you can detect it you have super powers. Besides, in some ways I don't think it matters if it's AI generated or not. The goals are still set by humans and the goal has always been to shift product, not to reliably and honestly inform. Telling lies in ad's has been an art form for centuries, dating well back before the snake oil salesman of yore. Modern countries have been creating competitive markets by passing laws limiting the lies told, and so modern the marketing professional has become skilled at skating as close to the line created by those rules as possible. If everything else remained the same, AI ad's might skate a tiny bit closer. That's all. But everything has not remained the same. The internet has come along. It's had lots of effects. Delivering ads is now much cheaper, so we see more of them in any given hour of the day. They've become hidden, only appearing to certain demographics so the authorities don't see them, and they are often from foreign entities outside of the reach of your countries law. The net result has been an avalanche of poorly policed ads that are near total bullshit. Who believes a bunch of glowing Amazon reviews for a new product now? AI doesn't effect any of that, but it will effect the price of producing an ad. It will not so much drop as plummet. Before, spamming HN with subtly written unique ads required an enormous highly skilled workforce. We see now the output of state sponsored workforces in places like twitter where one comment will be shown to millions. It's twitter because such workforces cost a lot of money, so a lot of people have to see each post to make it worthwhile. AI will reduce the cost so much just about anyone will be able to pollute HN's comments. Now producing a video ad took many hours of a script writers time, paying actors, and editing. Very soon you will be able to do it for a few dollars. The hundred or thousand fold drop in price will be corresponding increase in the number of ads, and a similar decrease in societies ability to police them. In other words, you will be overwhelmed with AI generated ads that lie better than the humans. (They are so convincing when they hallucinate, aren't they?) In the short term, anyway. In the long term, I think perhaps our political masters will attempt make the infrastructure that delivers these ads take some responsibility for their quality, so maybe some sanity will be restored. I hope so anyway. But in the mean time if believing you can detect whether an AI is behind an ad or not brings you some comfort, go for it.
- 3y ago