6 ms·
When a black hole and a neutron star merge
- hulahoof 3y agoThis was a refreshingly good press release about the event
- pfdietz 3y agoI'm assuming there was no gamma ray burst detected at that time, or else the press release would have mentioned it.
- changoplatanero 3y agoI bet it’s much harder to detect the gamma ray burst if you don’t know what direction to look since only one of the gravitational wave detectors was running
- pfdietz 3y agoShort GRBs are detected by omnidirectional detectors; they're so short there's no time to alter detector orientation.
- peter_d_sherman 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLWNqkQfjTE&t=384s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eLWNqkQfjTE&t=384s Les Grossman in Tropic of Thunder: "Speedman is a dying star... a white dwarf heading for a black hole. That's physics... it's inevitable..." (Sorry, I couldn't resist! <g> :-) <g>)
- theposey 3y agoa comedic triumph. what a film
- hinkley 3y agoWouldn’t a neutron star orbiting a black hole be an aberration though? Isn’t it more likely that a normal neutron star trapped in orbit of a black hole would sweep up the substantial accretion disk, than that a heretofore theoretical massed neutron star fell into the orbit of a black hole?
- dmbche 3y ago"GW230529 was formed by the merger of a compact object with 1.3 to 2.1 times the mass of our Sun with another compact object with 2.6 to 4.7 times the solar mass. Whether these compact objects are neutron stars or black holes cannot be determined with certainty from gravitational-wave analysis alone. However, based on all the known properties of the binary, astronomers believe that the lighter object is a neutron star and the heavier is a black hole." I believe what is interesting about this is that the supposed black hole is lighter than is expected - it's in the gap they mention, not the neutron star!
- manquer 3y agoNo, the size of the accretion disk depends on the mass of the black hole but it not that large compared to stellar orbits. The disk well defined inner radius of 3rg (Schwarzschild radius), the outer radius is blurred, but usually even in super massive black-holes does not extend all that much beyond 0.1ly. A star rarely orbits another star (black-holes) that close in a stable orbit. For normal blackholes the disk it is going to very small.
- andrewflnr 3y agoWhy are you assuming there was a substantial accretion disk?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- hn72774 3y agoIf a neutron star, black hole, and regular star can all exist in the 3 solar mass range, do they have a different curve in spacetime? I always imagined the example of a ball on cellophane for a gravity well caused by massive objects. If they have similar masses, how does the black hole bend "deep" enough into space to the point where not even light can escape? What if it's some other class of object that we have yet to identify? Why black hole if not neutron star? This is not a criticism of the article, these are curiosities. It's a really good read. Fascinating science.
- cgriswald 3y agoEach mass creates a “dimple” on the cellophane but because they have different density, the shape of that dimple is different. The less dense object has a shallower cone. The infinitely dense object has a steeper one. If you’re five feet from the surface of the sun you’re hundreds of thousands of miles away from its center of mass. If you’re five feet away from the “surface” of a solar mass black hole you’re just a couple of miles away from the center of mass.
- lemonfever 3y agoExactly. Also, if you are hundreds of thousands of miles from the center of mass of the sun, you'd feel the same force from gravity as if you were the same distance from the center of mass of a black hole (with the same mass). Far away, the curvature of spacetime is the same, it's just that with black holes you can get waaaay closer to the center of mass whilst still being outside of it.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoExcept this is not entirely true. The shape of gravitational field only differs within the body. The shape outside of the perfectly spherical body will be exactly the same regardless of how the mass is distributed (whether it is all on the surface or all in the middle of it). Or in other words, if you are on the surface of the sun, you will feel exactly the same acceleration as if entire mass of the sun was concentrated in its center. The only time you feel the difference is if you dip into the sun. As you go deeper and deeper, the pull from all the mass that is further from the center than you are will perfectly nullify each other. As you go deeper and deeper into the sun you will feel less acceleration.
- captainkrtek 3y agoAs an FYI, LIGO in Eastern Washington offers full tours of the facility inside and out for free. Was a memorable trip and included a lecture before hand. Highly recommend checking it out!
- darknavi 3y agoThe Hanford nuclear site is also nearby and also does day tours. Such a cool piece of history.
- Anon4Now 3y agoThe Goldendale Observatory is a couple hours away, as well. https://www.goldendaleobservatory.com/visit.html https://www.goldendaleobservatory.com/visit.html
- dguest 3y agoA lot of publicly funded projects give free tours. For science experiments and infrastructure this makes a lot of sense: we need to tell tax payers why we're taking their money. I'm a bit sad that it's not more widespread for a lot of critical infrastructure e.g. ferries, power plants, factories, etc: it's a great way to get people interested in engineering and big cool public projects. It's often worth asking, the reactions can vary a lot. For example taking a ferry, I like to poke around and see how everything works: - In Long Island Sound, even without going through any doors I got someone asking why I'm interested and essentially telling me there's no way in hell I could e.g. see the engine. He seemed to be 5 seconds away from calling the police. - In Stockholm the engine mechanic noticed me looking around, invited me to climb down the ladder into the engine room, and showed me how everything worked. It was one of the highlights of that trip.
- nkrisc 3y ago> In Long Island Sound, even without going through any doors I got someone asking why I'm interested and essentially telling me there's no way in hell I could e.g. see the engine. He seemed to be 5 seconds away from calling the police. Might have had better luck pre-9/11. > I'm a bit sad that it's not more widespread for a lot of critical infrastructure e.g. ferries, power plants, factories, etc The rationale is clear (you may debate the necessity or effectiveness): the concern is that terrorists would scout critical infrastructure before an attack.
- Razengan 3y agoWhat happens if a black hole gobbles a strangelet?
- johndunne 3y agoA strange star is still matter so that matter would just fall into the black hole as any other matter would. Tidal forces prior to the merger could result in some of the stranglet material being spewed out into space. AFAIK strange stars are an unconfirmed theory at present and the 'super stable' nature of strange matter, I'm unsure of what would happen. It'd be interesting to know this for sure. For anyone interested in what this 'Strange matter' is see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_matter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_matter
- jari_mustonen 3y agoAre there any astronomers willing to answer this: How likely is it that a neutron star "crashes" with a black hole? Why do not they just fly past each other or just rotate like Earth and the sun?
- readyplayernull 3y agoNot an astronomer, but I can imagine a crashing window as a thin straight pipe that is bended by spacetime's gravitational waves, magnetic waves and BH ejection material.
- mastazi 3y agoIf you look at the animation linked in the article, you can see that they did orbit each other, not only that but if you look at the time scale in the lower part of the screen, you can see that they were doing that at a crazy frequency (about 8 full revolutions in the last 30 milliseconds) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PKsBwH_bJE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3PKsBwH_bJE
- gosub100 3y agoIANAA, but black holes often have an accretion disc orbiting them. Anything that would cross this plane would get impacted by the orbiting particles, which would slowly cause the object to begin to orbit. Neutron stars also have enormous gravitational and magnetic fields which could steal mass from the accretion disc. If you (the neutron star) gain mass near the gravitational field, it pulls you in closer.
- raattgift 3y ago> If you (the neutron star) gain mass near the gravitational field, it pulls you in closer. This conflicts with the Strong Equivalence Principle (SEP) in its universality of free fall form, or more colloquially a rule that the trajectory of a self-gravitating object depends only on its initial position and velocity and not on its internal composition (including the evolution of its mass). There is a good test of the SEP in a system involving the millisecond pulsar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_J0337%2B1715 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PSR_J0337%2B1715 which is in a hard binary with a white dwarf; a second white dwarf orbits the inner binary. Here is a trace of the orbits https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDgfqq_W_uM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDgfqq_W_uM -- I recommend reading the video description. Reference 2 (Archibald et al.) at the wikipedia page is an excellent paper. There are a couple of good astrobites aimed at (advanced, or possibly final-year) astrophysics undergrads at https://astrobites.org/2014/01/14/timing-is-everything-a-pulsar-in-orbit/ https://astrobites.org/2014/01/14/timing-is-everything-a-pul... (2014) and https://astrobites.org/2019/03/25/testing-einsteins-equivalence-principle-by-timing-a-pulsar-in-a-stellar-triple-system/ https://astrobites.org/2019/03/25/testing-einsteins-equivale... (2019) You're right that the flow of mass in a complex system might be relevant to the merging binary, but in general a stellar black hole's circumstellar accretion structure isn't going to do much to a close-in neutron star except create a lot of (relatively small) nuclear explosions on the latter's surface. There just isn't going to enough material in the accretion structure in comparison to the bigger bodies, which will have masses greater than our sun. Accretion structures are more relevant for softer (that is more widely separated) binaries, which are a long time before final merger. Circumstellar accretion discs can be in association with a circumbinary disc (CBD; outside the binary), with a flow of matter between them (one would expect the CBD to be the origin of the circumstellar discs, but jet outflows make that expectation complicated). CBDs tend to circularize wide binary orbits, for example. They also provide mechanisms to harden binaries that might seem so soft that a merger could be avoided. You're right that some neutron stars may have very strong magnetic fields that may affect its accretion disc or the (randomly aligned) accretion disc of its black hole binary partner, but again the flows of mass near the binary must be much less than the masses of the relativistic stars (the NS and the BH), as the each of the stars are very very strongly bound self-gravitation. Your idea bout mass flow is interesting -- it takes my mind to how much of the accretion disc might be blown into ~polar jets, and how complicated the alignment of spin axes are to the orbital plane can be late in the merger. The accretion structures are I guess likely to be blown into a CBD (or out of the system entirely) well before final merger. Either way, the masses involved likely won't change the inspiral significantly. If the NS shreds (as opposed to being swallowed whole, which is the more likely outcome, and the apparent outcome in this detection) the additional matter in an accretion structure (including any accretion material blown out of the system via jetting) could be relevant in the r-process and s-process heavy element formation processes. Realistically though that's the sort of question more relevant to binary neutron star mergers. (As a sort of self-bookmarking and because it's probably interesting to other readers here, Maria Massi's 2020 "Accretion" teaching slides at https://www3.mpifr-bonn.mpg.de/staff/mmassi/lezione2WEdd.pdf https://www3.mpifr-bonn.mpg.de/staff/mmassi/lezione2WEdd.pdf are awesome, and takes one to some work on x-ray binary circumstellar discs and even circumbinary accretion. More recent review on the latter <https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.00028 https://arxiv.org/abs/2211.00028>, and figure 1 is probably helpful for a couple of my paragraphs above).
- bell-cot 3y ago...the "Generally Safe Distance" is measured in kiloparsecs.
- meowface 3y agoFor anyone else curious: that's 3,260 light years.
- bell-cot 3y agoTrue...but all sentient beings should be aware that counterfeit, cut-rate, or old "Singularity Merger Glasses" do NOT suddenly become "good enough" at 1.0 kpc. Doesn't matter if you've previously looked at mere Typo O stars with your unprotected photoreceptors, or your spaceship's viewports have a Gamma Protection Factor that's over 50, or ...
- belter 3y agoShould the intricacies of the universe fill you with awe, consider the gold in your possession. Touch it. You have on your hands, the product from the fusion at the core of two colliding neutron stars.