3 ms·
I love it. Stock pops after IPO, greedy bankers taking the company money. Stock doesn't pop, overhyped failure. I wonder what a successful IPO would look like.
by tedunangst 15y ago
I love it. Stock pops after IPO, greedy bankers taking the company money. Stock doesn't pop, overhyped failure. I wonder what a successful IPO would look like. Price doesn't change, no trading volume?
- newbie12 15y agoNo doubt. This is a huge win for Facebook, as the article sort of mentions. There's no money left on the table, Facebook got full value for their stock.
- larrys 15y agoShort term yes. But it's a little like a concert that is able to extract the maximum amount of seat sales revenue but has a bunch of non-filled seats which don't look to good for people attending and writing about the concert. Or a half empty restaurant on Saturday night. The story is that the price had to be supported. I'm not sure that is the message that will be good long-er term with a thing that is sold on psychology as opposed to fundamentals. After all there is no way people getting in on the IPO bought the stock at $38 thinking it wasn't going to go up the same day.
- davidw 15y agoTo me it all seems like part of the same problem: some banker pulls a number out of his ass as "the price". There should be an auction or market of some other kind to determine the price, because... well, markets are a pretty good mechanism for determining prices, usually much better than any one individual or small group.
- tedunangst 15y agoThere's a bit of a feedback mechanism, since the only price that really matters is the one you can get. If you had an auction (the stock market is already an auction that's always ongoing, btw) as soon as its revealed that Warren Buffet bid X, you'll see people bid X+1, even if 30 seconds earlier they had scoffed that X was totally unrealistic. You could have a silent auction, but the facts come out eventually, and then you'll see the same eruption of trading. That's almost what the bankers are doing behind the scenes, holding a private silent auction.
- nikcub 15y agothat is what happens during the roadshow, which led to the price going up in the last few days and more shares being issues because of demand funny that Google tried the auction, ended up getting wall st against them and colluding to lower the price. Facebook co-opts all the big name banks as underwriters and gets a near-perfect opening price.
- jerf 15y ago"gets a near-perfect opening price." If Morgan-Stanley was propping the stock up, then that's strong evidence it wasn't a near-perfect opening price, but that it was too high.
- alttag 15y agoWhich makes it near-perfect for Facebook (more capital from the sale), but less-so for shareholders, particularly those looking to make a buck on a quick flip.