4 ms·
The premise here is that the AI is operating at the behest of someone else. Now suppose that it's open source and runs on your own device. "It will learn when
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
The premise here is that the AI is operating at the behest of someone else.
Now suppose that it's open source and runs on your own device. "It will learn when your ADHD medication typically starts wearing off and you're more prone to act impulsively" and then avoid presenting you with purchasing decisions at those times etc. It will digest both ad-laden blogspam and human psych research papers so it can present the information you want stripped of the manipulative context in which it was originally presented.
It has to be a user agent and not a corporate agent or we're all screwed.
- amlib 3y agoWe've been trying to push FOSS software into peoples lives for many decades now and they still mostly opt for stuff from the big tech. It is very likely that the same will happen again with AI unfortunately.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe most popular web browsers are open source. Android is open source and the extent that it isn't is the extent that they're running into anti-trust claims. A sizable chunk of the population uses ad blockers. "People don't care" is at best defeatism and at worst explicit propaganda designed to discourage people from making the attempt. Sometimes it works, sometimes it doesn't. It works more often when you try than when you don't.
- eesmith 3y agoThe most popular web browsers use open source, but none of Chrome, Edge, or Safari are open source web browsers. They are proprietary freeware.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe difference between Chrome and Chromium is that Chrome is marginally worse but largely identical. People mostly install Chrome instead of Chromium by accident because Google markets Chrome and they don't know that Chromium exists and the differences are things they don't strongly care about. But if Chrome ever started doing something they don't like and actually care about, anyone could instantly switch to Chromium and the only difference they'd notice is that it's not doing the thing they don't like anymore.
- eesmith 3y agoSure, but that statement, while true, does not make Chromium one of 'the most popular web browsers.'
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoDoesn't it? It's the same codebase as Chrome, and not in the sense that they used to be. They still are. Changes to one go into the other. And that code is open source, so anybody who doesn't like what Google is doing with it can create a fork, just like with any other open source project. Arguing that it isn't because the most popular distribution has some proprietary bits in it is like arguing that it isn't because the most popular operating system it runs on is Windows. It doesn't change the fact that if the browser defects against you, you can fork it.
- eesmith 3y agoAs you wrote, it is not the same code base. It "has some proprietary bits." People have forked it. Is ungoogled Chromium the same codebase as Chrome? What about the Vanadium? Brave? Edge? Opera? Darwin is (or "was" as it no longer really exists) not macOS either, even though changes in macOS went into Darwin.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe relevant distinction is, is it different enough to have to care? If Chrome suddenly adopts some offensive behavior, how much trouble is it to use Chromium instead? And it's easy. Whereas if you want to use Darwin instead of macOS, it will be missing some things you're immediately going to notice, like the macOS GUI.
- eesmith 3y agoNo, it is not. For those who want to avoid Google altogether, switching to Chromium does not solve those issues. From https://www.theregister.com/2020/06/09/open_source_unbranded/ https://www.theregister.com/2020/06/09/open_source_unbranded... "there are 50 or so Google services that have been integrated in the Chromium code base." "The services are free but have commercial value by providing data that can be used to inform advertising and marketing algorithms, or in some cases, such as Google Pay, have more obvious benefit to the provider."
- qrobit 3y agoWhile android base is open source(and I appreciate google for that), no major phone vendor uses exclusively open source components. They always adds own proprietary apps and services also most of the time google's. IMO no better than an iphone.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat's the anti-trust thing. If Google still wanted to "don't be evil" they'd switch to a license that requires OEMs to allow the user to install custom Android forks on the device.
- autoexec 3y ago> Now suppose that it's open source and runs on your own device. I agree that AI could be a massive asset to people and help improve our lives if it worked for us and our interests. Sadly that's not how things seem to work out. Every piece of technology on offer today seems to work for someone else. Our phones, our cars, our TVs, our computers, our appliances, even our medical devices. All of our tech works for other someone other than the person who paid for it and mostly so that companies can exploit us while delivering only a fraction of what those devices are capable of. Features are often locked or paywalled off to extract more money or encourage additional purchases or to prevent you from blocking ads or taking back control of your hardware and the software it runs. Our usage is monitored and data collected to be used against us later. Even now AI is largely controlled by private companies. Even as the hardware requirements to run AI locally go down, we'll never compete with companies like facebook, google, and microsoft in terms of the size of the datasets they have to train with. Worse I think we're starting to see efforts by corporations to push for laws that limit the ability for people to use AI. They'll say it's too dangerous to let regular people use AI, and that only they can be trusted with such power.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> Every piece of technology on offer today seems to work for someone else. You can buy a commodity PC and install Debian on it. Some people do. > Even as the hardware requirements to run AI locally go down, we'll never compete with companies like facebook, google, and microsoft in terms of the size of the datasets they have to train with. Most of these datasets are public. > Worse I think we're starting to see efforts by corporations to push for laws that limit the ability for people to use AI. They'll say it's too dangerous to let regular people use AI, and that only they can be trusted with such power. Of course they will. But the "AI is bad" rhetoric only feeds into that. What do you expect an "AI is bad" bill to look like? It will be the one that restricts access to only large institutions.
- autoexec 3y ago> You can buy a commodity PC and install Debian on it. But your motherboard will still be full of chips that are closed and proprietary and some of them will have their own OS with network/wireless access that you'll have no control over. You'll just have to trust that the Intel Management Engine backdoor and radio chipsets you have no access to aren't taking advantage of you. > Most of these datasets are public. Most of everything Google has indexed and cached is "public". Libraries are filled with the same books Google has already scanned. Good luck using the entire internet and your local library to train your own personal AI though. Microsoft has access to an incredible amount of non-public data including the emails of corporations using outlook and the files on people's hard drive. If they were to fully leverage their access to train AI you'd have a hard time keeping up. Facebook has every post and "private" message ever sent on the platform including ones that were deleted years ago. We can't expect a few publicly released datasets to compare to what they're capable of getting. Even if we had that kind of access to raw data, could we realistically process it? https://fortune.com/2024/04/04/ai-training-costs-how-much-is-too-much-openai-gpt-anthropic-microsoft/?taid=660ed6f0ab6464000175d1ad https://fortune.com/2024/04/04/ai-training-costs-how-much-is... > But the "AI is bad" rhetoric only feeds into that. What do you expect an "AI is bad" bill to look like? It will be the one that restricts access to only large institutions. There are a lot of different versions of "AI is bad". One is "AI is bad when it's only controlled by corporations", but that's not what the laws will be about. They're more likely to say that "AI is bad" because of terrorists and spammers and pedos or whatever other boogeymen they can summon up to scare the ignorant and provide some justification for keeping that power out of the public's hands.
- nickpsecurity 3y agoMost open models of useful size will be trained on lots of free data scraped from the Internet. Whatever patterns repeat the most show up in AI’s behavior. That includes advertising, political indoctrination, and trendy topics. Many open models are also trained by advertising companies. Most then have moral alignment built into them that reflects their creator’s values, not usually ours. So, I think what you said can help. It’s definitely not the whole solution, though, since the pre-training and fine-tuning often have similar problems. We’ll need people curating the datasets to remove these problems. The open-source components are just a start.
- tivert 3y ago> The premise here is that the AI is operating at the behest of someone else. > Now suppose that it's open source and runs on your own device. Not gonna happen. The trend is to have less and less control over the devices you own. My TV's OS show me ads, not because I wanted them, but because the manufacturer wants to make more money. There are no open source TVs. As soon as any consumer device gets an internet connection, it starts working against its users (for a recent example, see cars, which are increasingly "connected" and allow the manufactures to sell driving data to 3rd parties for embarrassingly small amounts of money).
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> The trend is to have less and less control over the devices you own. Markets are two-sided. Stop patronizing companies that abuse you. If you can't find a viable alternative, instead cause problems for them on purpose. Contact support and waste their time hearing your complaints. Buy the device from the retailer where they get the highest margins so you can leave a bad review, then return it and buy a used one instead. Figure out how to root it and publish your work. Don't be afraid to behave adversarially towards your adversary. > There are no open source TVs. There are still dumb TVs that don't connect to the internet. These often cost more, because the adversarial advertising subsidizes the price of the "smart" TVs. But the "smart" TVs still have an HDMI port that you can plug whatever you want into, so the typical move is to buy the smart TV and then use an external device to display video and never connect the TV to the internet. > As soon as any consumer device gets an internet connection, it starts working against its users So don't give it an internet connection, and if it doesn't operate in that condition then return it. Don't be a doormat.
- tivert 3y ago>> The trend is to have less and less control over the devices you own. > Markets are two-sided. Stop patronizing companies that abuse you. The market can't fix this. That's a fantasy. The manufactures all have an incentive to do this, and a combination of asymmetric information and users being like frogs in a pot mean they'll suffer little to no blowback. The market converges on devices that turn against their users. > If you can't find a viable alternative, instead cause problems for them on purpose. Contact support and waste their time hearing your complaints. Buy the device from the retailer where they get the highest margins so you can leave a bad review, then return it and buy a used one instead. Those are totally impractical suggestions. The weirdos willing to tilt at windmills over this can have no noticeable effect. > Figure out how to root it and publish your work. Rooting a device takes a lot of work, if it's even possible at all. Volunteers just don't have the combination of skills and dedicated man-hours to make that a practical alternative across the consumer device space, except maybe in some unusual cases.