2 ms·
The weather isn’t magic either. It’s produced by physical mechanisms. But everyone would probably agree that a model simulating some rough aggregate of those me
by pavlov 3y ago
The weather isn’t magic either. It’s produced by physical mechanisms. But everyone would probably agree that a model simulating some rough aggregate of those mechanisms isn’t “weather” itself.
On the other hand. Take that weather model and render its output into a stereoscopic 3D world with photorealistic particle systems and whatever. To someone wearing a Vision Pro or similar high-def VR headset, the model is now “the weather” in the system their senses occupy. It’s missing a lot of actual sensory cues — the rain isn’t wet, the wind won’t chill your skin, and so on. But it’s close enough for some convincing applications. A caveman with no experience with technology would undoubtedly believe himself transported into a different world with real weather.
LLMs are a bit like that now. Their simulation abilities took such a sudden leap, we’re like cavemen wearing headsets.
- ben_w 3y agoThe only way I can model what you're trying to say, is if I assume you think "the mind" is a separate kind of substance, and not merely information processing that just happens to be implemented on biological electrochemistry in our skulls. A (philosophical) dualist can easily say that no computation is ever intelligent. I don't think this can ever be said by a (philosophical) materialist.