2 ms·
> If you somehow made housing 50% cheaper people would just demand 50% larger housing. The incremental value of the first 1000 sq ft is nowhere near as much as
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> If you somehow made housing 50% cheaper people would just demand 50% larger housing.
The incremental value of the first 1000 sq ft is nowhere near as much as the next 1000 sq ft. In one case you're no longer living outdoors, in the other you have more space to put your junk.
If you somehow made housing 50% cheaper people might just demand 20% larger housing, but so what?
Also, even in your formulation the result would be that someone who can currently only afford a small apartment would then be able to afford a larger one and be able to start a family, which is good.
> In the US, the average household size has expanded by 1000 sq ft since the 70s
A major reason for this is that we effectively prohibited smaller ones. If zoning only allows you to build one housing unit on the lot, it will obviously be more profitable to make it a 2500 sq ft house than a 500 sq ft studio. Meanwhile you might have been inclined to make it a dozen 500 sq ft studios, but that's not allowed.
- kgwgk 3y ago> The incremental value of the first 1000 sq ft is nowhere near as much as the next 1000 sq ft Note that - intentionally or not - the parent comment said 50% larger and not 100% larger which is what they could buy for the same price if it was 50% cheaper.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThat depends on whether you take the "50% larger" as relative to the old size or the new size. 50% of a 2000 sq ft unit is 1000 sq ft, so a 2000 sq ft unit is 50% (of 2000 sq ft) larger than the 1000 sq ft unit. This is a less common usage but makes more sense in context, because having the size increase eat the entire cost reduction is a problem if you're trying to achieve affordability, whereas getting a 1500 sq ft unit for 3/4ths of the old price of a 1000 sq ft unit is hardly anything to complain about.
- kgwgk 3y ago> a 2000 sq ft unit is 50% larger than the 1000 sq ft unit Ok then.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoIt's a language issue, not a math issue. Context can change the meaning of a phrase.
- avar 3y ago> The incremental value of the > first 1000 sq ft is nowhere > near as much as the next 1000 > sq ft. Agreed, but not for the reasons you think, it's even higher than that, not lower! A 2000 sq ft house you can turn into a duplex is more valuable than a single family home. It's the government that's destroying that potential value by preventing that development. > people might just demand 20% > larger housing, but so what? If that's what they really want, sure, who am I to judge? What I'm pointing out is that you'll see articles and discussions lamenting increased housing costs, while ignoring the massive variable of shifting consumer preference. It would be like complaining about the rising costs of mobile phones, while implicitly insisting that you're only willing to purchase the latest top-of-the-line iPhone. > A major reason for this is > that we effectively prohibited > smaller ones. Yes, that's a factor, so reducing size to 1910 levels is somewhat of a chicken and egg problem. But there's a lot of optional consumer preference on top of that.
- AnthonyMouse 3y ago> A 2000 sq ft house you can turn into a duplex is more valuable than a single family home. But then it isn't a 2000 sq ft housing unit, it's two 1000 sq ft housing units. > It's the government that's destroying that potential value by forbidding that development. Correct. > It would be like complaining about the rising costs of mobile phones, while implicitly insisting that you're only willing to purchase the latest top-of-the-line iPhone. Except that people are also quite displeased with the high cost of even small units.
- massysett 3y agoI’ve never seen this issue discussed in the context of the much-reported shortage in housing units in the US. Houses are bigger while families are smaller. Thus, it might make sense for children to live at home longer. I’m people generations the kids get kicked out to make room, and also the kids were having kids of their own earlier. Maybe there is less political and market pressure to build affordable, smaller houses because the larger house size and smaller families simply reduce the true need for additional, cheaper, smaller units.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoExcept that they're not the same people. Suppose your parents live near Boston and you get a job in New York. What good is the extra room in their house?