4 ms·
A California 'Right to Disconnect'?
- andsoitis 3y agohttps://archive.is/L13FH https://archive.is/L13FH
- Terr_ 3y agoIf the WSJ editorial board really believes in the distributed free-market over government regulation, then shouldn't any on-call/responsiveness requirements be explicit in the private employment contract anyway? Also, doesn't that price-for-performance information need to be not merely explicit but public as well, so that the free-market can fulfill certain economists' promises about it optimally allocating resources using price signals for the good of all mankind, etc? As a liberal cynic (if it wasn't obvious already) I often feel there's a certain degree of hypocrisy in some of these appeals, where they claim to be motivated by "free market" principles while going against those principles to promote corporatism. The "flexibility" they want to preserve is the "flexibility" of employers to impose uncompensated demands of employees that are outside of the employment contract.
- roenxi 3y agoYes. And then the question becomes "isn't this already settled law?". It seems weird that legislation would be needed to point out that someone's working hours are set by their employment contract. I'm nowhere near California and the article is pay-walled, but my employment contract says 40 hours/week with reasonable overtime (and I'm not sure what "reasonable" means, but it certainly doesn't mean "routinely do >40 hours/wk", because we just agreed to 40). Do Californian employment contracts not work that way? These contracts are supposed to be about swapping employee hours for employment money. Do they not write down the hours and the money in the contract? That seems like important information.
- cmeacham98 3y agoSure, that might be what your employment contract says, but the vast majority of people in the US (probably including you) work at-will, where your employer can fire you for (almost) any reason. So although your employment contract might not say it, your employer can tell you "I need you to be available to take my calls 24/7 or you're fired".
- roenxi 3y agoAre they proposing to change that though? If you've already agreed with your employee that you're working a 40 hour week and they have the power to just change the deal mid way through, making the deal more explicit won't change the dynamics. They may as well have a law saying "your employment contract (still) outlines the conditions that you work under". Ie, they're not changing anything. There is already a piece of paper saying what your work hours are, and calling it a "right" instead of a "contractual obligation" doesn't impact the power balance here, at all. If an employee can't hold them to contract they can't hold them to any other law either. Having a contract that outlines a 40 hour work week is already about as strong as it gets that the deal here is a 40 hour work week. I don't see how to improve on that. Calling the contract something else doesn't seem like it has a lot of impact.
- Izkata 3y agoExempt salaried employees don't track hours though.
- Paul-Craft 3y agoYou're completely missing the point. You're obviously from somewhere civilized, where ordinary employees get actual, spelled out contracts that specify how many hours they're to work each week. US employees don't get that sort of thing. At best, we get a not-actually-a-contract "offer letter" that says something about here is the job you're being offered, the salary, and the job description (generally including the weasely phrase "other duties as assigned." Because we don't have binding contracts with our employers, we don't even have that baseline of "a contract that outlines a 40 hour work week."
- palmfacehn 3y agoWould the proposed regulation prohibit explicit clauses requiring employees to read that email? If not, there's no issue from the laissez-faire perspective. If it isn't in your contract then you don't need to perform the duty. Perhaps some might say, "Aha! But employees don't have an equal footing in this power dynamic, therefore exploitation!". Which would lead me to assume that contracts are worthless if they are unenforceable. So yes, whatever passes for a market in California should be able to handle it without further intervention from the state. Interestingly, laissez-faire is or was once considered "liberal", but here we are.
- Terr_ 3y ago> Would the proposed regulation prohibit explicit clauses requiring employees to read that email? If not, there's no issue from the laissez-faire perspective. Did some searching, and: > (b) An employer shall establish a workplace policy that provides employees the right to disconnect from communications from the employer during nonworking hours. > (c) Nonworking hours shall be established by written agreement between an employer and employee. > (d) An employer may contact an employee during nonworking hours for an emergency or for scheduling. So it looks like employer can't put a blanket "you agree to respond to anything at any time" thing in their contracts, at least not without also defining "working hours" as 24/7. https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB2751/id/2965645 https://legiscan.com/CA/text/AB2751/id/2965645
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago"Gary Tan, the outspoken CEO of startup accelerator Y Combinator took to X Tuesday to deride the proposal as a productivity killer and continue his long running criticism of Haney. "Legalize hard work," Tan wrote." https://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?d=4550814585281586&w=lm2y5QVsaw4VeOzjmTsABTUydt6W1OkW https://cc.bingj.com/cache.aspx?d=4550814585281586&w=lm2y5QV...
- kstrauser 3y agoGotta disagree strongly on that one, Tan. I've never, ever had a tech job that paid me extra to be on call. I happened to be working in a job right now where 24/7/365 call is implicit; if our site goes down, I'm not going to split hairs about who's supposed to handle it that day. I knew that going into it. It's part of the Staff Engineer role when you're in or adjacent to security or SRE. I've also been in jobs where there was no obvious connection between my job and being on call after working hours, and yet after I started I was informed that it was my turn to answer the phone. If you want to pay someone to be on call, rock on. If you're not going to pay them, why do you expect them to donate their nights and weekends to you?
- hackable_sand 3y agoIt would be like calling in one of your day-shift security guards to investigate an alarm at the bank. It just doesn't make sense.
- kstrauser 3y agoExactly! Call the CSO at home. That’s their job. If you want the guard to pick up their phone, budget for it.
- janosdebugs 3y agoIt also doesn't make much sense from a productivity standpoint. Whenever I did on-call, it would obviously disrupt my sleep schedule and my work performance the next day would be... suboptimal. Follow the sun makes much more sense.
- Gustomaximus 3y agoDidn't they do this in Germany? Where emails couldn't send push notifications after hours. Anyone know how that worked? In my experience it's fine to stop push notifications for email/chat messages after hours and "call me" if it's an emergency. I often get 'urgent' emails and chats that aren't really urgent, but people rarely want to call you unless it's something truely important. Nor should people send email for urgent generally, I think that's expect a reply within 24hrs channel type environment. I feel for society we need stinger rules to balance work/life. A great one would be something like like for employees under $200k it's the employers responsibility to ensure they are working their 40hrs or pay overtime plus right to claim bad extra hours on leaving a job. Add to that some serious overtime rate minimums like 2x or 3x for weekend and out of hours. Ultimately we should aim build a society for good living and a productive economy is part of that, but not more important.
- asyx 3y agoI think Volkswagen introduced this a while ago but it's already rare in Germany to have access to emails outside of the company network. You might find it in startups and technical staff that is on call but that's it. At least for the average worker. But labor laws are pretty strong here. I don't think my boss would dare criticizing me for not responding on slack after a certain time.
- constantcrying 3y agoCertainly it is neither legally mandated nor very common. As the other commenter pointed out Volkswagen does this. But to be honest if I am not at work my work phone is off/silent and away from my reach anyway, so I don't know if such a rule really would have any impact on me. But this is also because of the surrounding labor laws, which e.g. has mandated and enforced maximum work hours per day, etc.
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y agoIf I'm paid 24/7 I'm happy to attend to work 24/7, otherwise fuck off. Even then I wouldn't take the deal. What I do and where I am after hours is none of anyone's business but my own.
- wildrhythms 3y agoIndeed, and I'm always tickled to see so-called 'hackers' eager to work above and beyond for The Man.
- hackable_sand 3y agoThis seems like it should be unspoken. It's a shame we have to legislate it. Some of the worst abuse comes from service work where you can be called in on your day off. This is the white collar reflection.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoUS productivity gains comes from normalized worker exploitation. It’ll only be fixed with legislation and organizing. It is a shame the people exist who take advantage, and as long as they exist, a box must be put around them with policy to protect the rest of us from them. But so long as democracy works, that should be possible, simply due to math.
- hackable_sand 3y agoYou would have to expand on the math part but I think I agree. Like any system, economic systems have the potential to collapse to a vacuum state (which is big bad in this context). The practical solution is an alignment of incentives and goals. How do we work towards an economy and social structures that are fault-tolerant at an abstract level? Can failing economic systems achieve stability by merging with upstream principles of provable market dynamics? This paper is interesting: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5051728/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5051728/ Although I think it needs much more research in economic theory. People take advantage, commit violence, organize at a high level to constrain market dynamics. The free market is largely a myth to begin with. Can we open gateways to participation by liquidating or distributing assets in a non-violent way? Maybe we can invest in non-tangible assets such as life-expectancy or a happiness index. Maybe we can steer existing markets towards longevity and away from short-term profit extraction. The potential is huge, but risks destabilization and unknown reformation. Unions seem like a great solution in the US economic system. We're in for an exciting few decades.
- anotherhue 3y agoI believe Ireland was the first to 'market' with this https://www.gov.ie/en/press-release/6b64a-tanaiste-signs-code-of-practice-on-right-to-disconnect/ https://www.gov.ie/en/press-release/6b64a-tanaiste-signs-cod... Edit: nevermind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_disconnect https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_to_disconnect
- Animats 3y agoThe way this works in the unionized part of the movie industry is that there's a minimum of 4 hours of pay if you're called to do something outside of normal working hours.
- defrost 3y agoPresumeably with the no-fault no-repercussion option of refusing to attend?
- Terr_ 3y ago> Has he been to Silicon Valley, where 9 to 5 working hours are far from the norm for tech bros? Aside, and from a west-coast-but-not-SV perspective... isn't this a mis-labeling? I thought "tech bros" were the folks who actually work in marketing synergy or become entrepreneurs or whatever--"tech" just delineates the industry they landed in. Their hours are based on schmoozing and start early enough to call people on the east coast. That's not the same as the folks rolling in at lunch because they binge-coded from 8PM-2AM.