3 ms·
> That wouldn't be pointless, because you would have a predictable expense instead of an unpredictable expense. What you're describing is actually the ideal sce
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> That wouldn't be pointless, because you would have a predictable expense instead of an unpredictable expense. What you're describing is actually the ideal scenario for both individuals and companies
No, if the expense were that predictable, the best case would be dispense with insurance entirely, since it effects the cost not at all and imposes overhead, especially insurance where the rates are accurately computed over short periods.
Without uncertainty, there is no point in insurance.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoIf you can manage your finances well, then sure. Many people would see that pile of cash in their savings and spend it. Paying a monthly amount to a third-party is safer in many ways, even if you have some % of overhead.
- mb7733 3y agoI don't care how well you manage your expenses, it doesn't make sense to keep enough cash on hand to rebuild your house if it burns to the ground. (Not to mention that is completely impossible for almost everyone.)
- bartonfink 3y agoso in your world, it's irresponsible to own anything unless you also put its replacement cost in escrow. house burned down two weeks after closing? fuck you, take the loss and enjoy being broke or homeless. that's asinine. think more before posting in the future.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoI'm open to having my mind changed, but when you post with this attitude it achieves no purpose. You assumed my views without asking. My comment only referred to there still being a benefit in choosing to have insurance even with perfect information about risk and expected benefits. At no point did I even imply that I thought "it's irresponsible to own anything".
- dragonwriter 3y agoIf insurance can predict when losses will occur accurately and price accordingly, even this arguable temporal-cost-spreading benefit is lost.
- mb7733 3y agoIf you dispense with insurance entirely, how do you deal with catastrophic expenses? The key things I think you are not considering are: 1. If you choose not to take out an insurance policy, and instead save the money yourself, you will not have the lump sum immediately available to cover catastrophe. Whereas as soon as you start paying insurance premiums you are covered. 2. The payout you receive when you make an insurance claim does not just come from the premiums you have personally paid. In fact, for a rare event, the size of the payout likely exceed the total cost of all premiums you could pay over your entire lifetime. This is because the risk is pooled over all customers, and not all customers will make claims. Neither of the above 2 points become any less relevant as the insurance premiums become more and more accurately priced.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> If you dispense with insurance entirely, how do you deal with catastrophic expenses? If insurance can accurately predict losses that will occur and price accordingly, you are paying exactly the same amount plus overhead, on a similar schedule for insurance as directly paying for losses yourself without insurance. The cost spreading effect (both over time and over individuals) is a direct consequence of the inability to accurately predict losses and the resulting inability to price accurately.
- mb7733 3y ago> If insurance can accurately predict losses that will occur and price accordingly, you are paying exactly the same amount plus overhead, on a similar schedule for insurance as directly paying for losses yourself without insurance. The hypothetical that I'm working with is that the insurer can perfectly price insurance by perfectly estimating the _risk_ or _expected loss_ for each individual customer. They can then pool this risk, take a profit, and everyone wins. This is what I assumed you meant by "perfectly priced insurance". But I've realized you're talking about the case where insurer has perfect knowledge of the future losses each individual will take. I agree in this case insurance will not make sense. Insurance would be free for most individuals and impossibly expensive for those doomed to catastrophe. (The latter group would be screwed, even if they shared perfect knowledge of the future with the insurer.)