4 ms·
System/360 – CHM Revolution
- Paul-Craft 3y agoFor those of you interested in these ancient machines, the CHM has an IBM 1401 and a PDP/1 that they actually will run as demos from time to time. The 1401 runs twice a week, and the PDP/1 runs twice a month. https://computerhistory.org/exhibits/ https://computerhistory.org/exhibits/
- anyfoo 3y agoDo note though that they are both very different from s/360. Complexity-wise, 1401 and PDP/1 are a bit closer to home computers of the 80s, in that they usually just execute code in a single thread and context and without any protection. They represent an earlier and simpler era of computing. The s/360 lineage, on the other hand, is an ancestor of our modern computing environment with virtual memory, privilege separation, virtual machines, dynamic linking, and so on. It’s really quite striking how much of our “modern” computing concepts IBM already did at the time with the s/360 and successors, up to the still alive IBM z. That does not diminish from the awesomeness of the 1401 and PDP-1 exhibits at all, I highly recommend them!
- dboreham 3y agoThe only working "big iron" I'm aware of in a museum is the LCM's PDP-10. The museum is still closed, unfortunately.
- GeorgeTirebiter 3y agoI think of it more as a continuum. At MIT under Jack Dennis, a pdp-1 was converted to timesharing. https://www.computerhistory.org/pdp-1/timesharing/ https://www.computerhistory.org/pdp-1/timesharing/ John McCarthy discusses his memories of early timesharing systems, mentioning the pdp-1 https://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/history/timesharing/timesharing.html https://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/history/timesharing/time... https://web.mit.edu/Saltzer/www/publications/protection/State.html https://web.mit.edu/Saltzer/www/publications/protection/Stat... discusses protection hardware -- and how the 360 actually mostly used it on main memory, not on IO channels (even though there was protection available to IO channels). I'm mainly saying that there were many 'experiments' tried in the olden days, and those plus "the market" give us what we have today. Recall, in the days of the IBM 1401 and DEC pdp-1, the notion of 'byte' as an 8-bit quantity did not exist. ASCII did not exist. The IBM 1401 was a Decimal / Character machine, and could add/sub/mul/div numbers of arbitrary length, in hardware (!). The pdp-1 used one's complement arithmetic. On and On...
- retrac 3y agoSome of that did not really materialize during the System/360 era. A custom version of the model 65 was the only one with virtual memory, for example. And while OS/360 was an architectural marvel on paper see the comments elsewhere in this thread about "The Mythical Man-Month" and how implementing it actually went. The most common System/360 machine as you would see in the 1960s, was the model 30 with 16 to 64 KB of RAM, a couple disks, and a card reader and printer. It would have been mostly programmed in assembly under DOS (the full OS didn't fit), and mostly batch processing. The virtual machine behemoths came with System/370 a bit later, the compatible successor series. With that said, System/360 did innovate quite a lot. Right down to setting the 8/16/32/64 bit pattern for byte and word size, or just the idea of a compatible series of machines running the same software, over the range of 10,000 to 1,000,000+ instructions per second, and from like 8 KB to 8 MB of RAM.
- anyfoo 3y agoYou’re right, so I was careful to say “s/360 lineage”! However, I thought a lot of the advanced concepts already were in some s/360s. Maybe not virtual machines, but that’s more the cherry on top (and pretty wild to me that s/370, which is the next step in the s/360 lineage, already had it).
- reidacdc 3y agoLovely. "The Mythical Man Month" was a recommended supplementary text when I was in undergrad computer science, and it was well worth the read, especially for me -- I have a tendency to get hung up on the cool tools and fun methods in programming, which is OK in hobby environments, but if the purpose of the software is to solve a problem, you need to keep an eye on the problem. The book extends this insight to managerial methods, famously, and to me feels akin to Goodhart's law, about how once a metric becomes a target, it ceases to be a useful metric. There's a great interview with Frederick Brooks on Youtube, not specifically about the System/360, but the guy was amazingly self-aware: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul0dbgs8Mdk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ul0dbgs8Mdk
- kwhitefoot 3y agoIt should be compulsory reading not only for CS students but for devs and managers. People should read it and apply it over and over.
- shrubble 3y agoThe Hercules emulator allows you to run various OS/360 and later systems in emulation under Windows, Mac, Linux and most other Unixes also, in case you wanted to try it out yourself.
- rbanffy 3y agoYou can try your hand with one of my Docker images. docker run -it -p 3270:3270 rbanffy/vm370 Then connect your 3270 client(s) to port 3270 on localhost and play like it’s the 1970’s. Disclaimer: that image has a 370, the successor of the 360. For this image, user CMSUSER has password CMSUSER, user MAINT (has more privileges) has password CPCMS. I now forgot the password for OPERATOR. I’ll post it here when I remember what it was. This image is built on the Sixpack distribution of VM/370. Google for it and you’ll find lots of information.
- usr1106 3y agoVM/370 is something like a hypervisor, CMS is a single user operating system mostly for development tasks. In production other operating systems were used, maybe MVS? Not sure whether it worked already like this in the 360 area.
- p_l 3y agoCMS was used not so much for development as for setups that really focused on interactive time sharing approaches, vs "extra special batch job" of TSO under MVS
- usr1106 3y agoI was a trainee in an IBM lab nearly 40 years ago. All developers including myself worked using VM/CMS. That I remember for sure. With production workloads I had nothing to do, so I am not sure what was the most commonly used OS. Pretty sure no bank clerk, airline counter or similar ran CMS.
- 3y ago
- fghorow 3y agoA blast from the past. UCLA had an S/360 model 91 that was "the campus computer" when I learned to program on it in 1975. I still have a JCL book from that era somewhere in a box... //GO.SYSIN DD * DOO DAH DOO DAH (Edited: formatting)
- mjcohen 3y agoI did a lot of stuff on that machine. One was an interactive processor so users could write their own simple programs to do whatever they wanted. It had numeric and string accumulators and numeric and string operators. One program I wrote for it could take text and convert it to pig latin. IIRC, the processor was about 12,000 lines of 360 assembly language.
- williamDafoe 3y agoTLDR; System/360 was the first true family of architectures that spanned 1000x performance speedup, the smallest models were modest and heavily microcoded. The Amdahl System/470 was dependent on IBM-compatible disk drives and IBM lost an anti-trust lawsuit in the late 1960s when they tried to deny cpu support contracts to customers using 3rd party disk drives. Apple today is doing something quite similar by trying to deny repairs by 3rd party companies. IBM broke the law explicitly (tying) through verbal contracts whereas Apple is breaking the law implicitly using needless hardware crypto contracts ... Thats why Steve Cook should lose the anti trust battle. Just watch.
- dessimus 3y ago> Steve Cook I thought his name was Tim Apple!?
- williamDafoe 3y agoOops you're right its Tim Cook ...
- aj7 3y agoHere’s the manual. I remember being in awe of this stuff when I was 19. http://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/pdf/ibm/360/princOps/A22-6821-0_360PrincOps.pdf http://bitsavers.trailing-edge.com/pdf/ibm/360/princOps/A22-...
- Koshkin 3y ago‘moshix’ has many excellent videos on Youtube about the IBM mainframes and their operating systems - including how to run them on an emulator, for example, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl8qG9KilJg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Wl8qG9KilJg.
- ngcc_hk 3y agoJust like usual there are no mention of woman but at least and sadly that is sort of expected for this kind of history. But I wonder Amdahl role in all these. We heard all about Brooks when we were young. And Amdahl was …