3 ms·
This takes me back. Before Google, meta search tools increased your odds of finding a decent answer between the spammy results from Alta Vista, Hotbot, Lycos, e
by xnx 3y ago
This takes me back. Before Google, meta search tools increased your odds of finding a decent answer between the spammy results from Alta Vista, Hotbot, Lycos, etc.
- 8ig8 3y agoDogpile was another.
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- nickburns 3y agomemories. and now it's come back around some decades later in the name of digital privacy.
- rockskon 3y agoHow are they private though? Unless they relay your search it is the exact opposite of private.
- notpushkin 3y agoThey do indeed relay your query. How else would they work?
- yayr 3y agoI would assume that the relaying can strip the request from identifying information such as IP, cookies and other tracking mechanisms that you get when visiting e.g. google.com.
- sneela 3y agoIf you host your own instance: > SearXNG protects the privacy of its users in multiple ways regardless of the type of the instance (private, public). Removal of private data from search requests comes in three forms: > 1. removal of private data from requests going to search services > 2. not forwarding anything from a third party services through search services (e.g. advertisement) > 3. removal of private data from requests going to the result pages From: https://docs.searxng.org/own-instance.html#how-does-searxng-protect-privacy https://docs.searxng.org/own-instance.html#how-does-searxng-... The docs mention a caveat below at "What are the consequences of using public instances?": > If someone uses a public instance, they have to trust the administrator of that instance. This means that the user of the public instance does not know whether their requests are logged, aggregated and sent or sold to a third party.
- gtirloni 3y agoAll of that is fine but by simply having your IP, Google can continue to profile you in countless ways with data they collect in other ways and it wouldn't be expensive for them at all.
- panki27 3y agoSearX acts as a proxy, you are not submitting your IP to Google.
- nickburns 3y agoi think since 'IP address' has become something of a baseline non-technical understanding of one of the critical components of networking, it becomes increasingly difficult for non-netpeeps to fully grasp the many uses and non-uses of addressing. a proxy (or proxies) and how they can shield but one or many of ' your' IP addresses throughout an egress packet's many hops (and from who or what destination it or those addresses can be shielded) is a pretty advanced concept when you think about it. not to mention that, at this point, bare source IP address is a pretty dilute tracker compared to other current methods of identity profiling or traffic fingerprinting. nice succint correction on your part regardless.
- gtirloni 3y agoWe're talking about self hosting, right? The proxy is using the same IP.
- nickburns 3y agoif self-hosting, that may very well be correct. a few examples of a self-hosted design that would not, include policy-based routing over a VPN with one or multiple tunneled hops, or through another external proxy. (and then there's also that 'onion' routing 'protocol' there—but i'm not clear if/how that integrates with clearnet destinations like publicly-accessible search engines if at all.)
- nickburns 3y agoprivacy is achieved through the proxy and therefore aggregation of disparate requests/queries. some anonymity is therefore achieved, at least from the perspective of source search engine operators, by blending into 'the crowd.' but the idea is not necessarily anonymity so much as privacy by foiling the creation of any even somewhat accurate marketing/data profile derived from 'your search.'
- marban 3y agoNorthern Light was nice though.
- giantrobot 3y agoNot just avoiding spam but some meta search engines (Dogpile IIRC) could also search specialist search engines like White Pages and Yellow Pages (long before Yelp etc existed). You'd be able to find business listings and contact info that wasn't normally found on web search engines. They could also include FTP search results which was useful as public anonymous FTPs had yet to fall from use.
- chefandy 3y agoI liked Copernic: it was a native Windows 9x Meta search tool.
- sheepscreek 3y agoWow. I came here to the comments to write about Copernic! It was a super valuable tool in the pre-Google era, heck even in the early 2000s.
- jszymborski 3y agoThis brought a smile to my face... I worked at a company started by Copernic alums (Coveo).