3 ms·
> prominent anti-intellectual movements Parts of India did. Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, India's two poorest states today used to have relatively decent British b
by alephnerd 3y ago
> prominent anti-intellectual movements
Parts of India did.
Uttar Pradesh and Bihar, India's two poorest states today used to have relatively decent British built universities (Lucknow University, Allahabad University, Patna University) that stood toe-to-tow with top universities like Delhi University, Calcutta University, Osmania University, Panjab University etc.
But in the 1960s-70s, Ram Manohar Lohia [0] lead an anti-intellectual, pro-Hindi and anti-English [1],and anti-rich movement in Eastern Uttar Pradesh and Bihar that lead to the rise of Lalu Prasad Yadav (Bihar) and Mulayam Singh Yadav (UP), both of whom were directly influenced and in some cases mentored by Lohia.
It was under those two CMs that Uttar Pradesh and Bihar began falling behind the rest of India in the 1980s-2000s period.
With Korea, I guess we can point to Juche but then again I said South Korea, and not North, though university purges were very common during the democracy movement of the 70s and 80s leading to events like the Gwangju Uprising.
> It would be fair to characterise the region that way going back to the Bronze Age
I mean you can characterize any region like that. For example, arguing that China was basically in a century long civil war from 1850-1950, along with the multiple other chaotic periods in between dynasties. For example, China didn't even catch up to Iraq's developmental indicators until the 2000s
> The article seems to go out of its way to restrict its arguments to the Arabic world, not Islam in general.
Fair enough.
[0] - https://theprint.in/opinion/great-speeches/when-ram-manohar-lohia-blasted-pseudo-intellectuals-for-175-page-five-year-plan-document/1986321/ https://theprint.in/opinion/great-speeches/when-ram-manohar-...
[1] - https://www.epw.in/journal/2009/48/discussion/lohia-and-language.html https://www.epw.in/journal/2009/48/discussion/lohia-and-lang...
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Parts of India did Parts of everywhere have fundamentalist nutters. What happened in the Arab world is distinct from what happened in Korea, India or China, and I don't think we can dismiss what happened to it as being analogous to their experience. > you can characterize any region like that. For example, arguing that China was basically in a century long civil war from 1850-1950 Come on, the Levant has probably seen the highest frequency of violent redrawings of boundaries and governments per square mile in human history. (Baghdad would have probably won had we not ruined its soil.) I think Western and Ottoman colonisation are valid explanations for why the Arab world looks the way it does today. I don't think it's an adequate explanation for why it fell from being the centre of the world in its heyday.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Parts of everywhere have fundamentalist nutters Well, in Lohia's case it was proto-Maoism. And I think it matters in the sense it's a good example of how we can't really generalize a "culture" or "civilization" because such grand visions are basically marketing for all intents and purposes. Like during the Islamic Golden Age, was there truly a difference between Byzantine Damascus or Arab Damascus? Can't you argue that al-Khwarizmi is actually a descendent of Persian High Culture, as he was from Khiva in Central Asia before it was Turkified. If it's based on Arabic as a language, then you can argue that most of Indian civilization in the 1st millennium was actually Persian due to Farsi-Dari being the lingua Franca of the educated (eg. My great-grandfather and grandfather both learned Farsi-Dari at the village school). > Come on, the Levant has probably seen the highest frequency of violent redrawings of boundaries and governments per square mile in human history I can say the same about Punjab, with the multiple Afghan, Turkic, Maratha, British, and indigenous invasions. Or Southern China which was only pacified in the 1700s before collapsing into clan wars, a messianic revolution, and then the collapse of the Qing empire so around 150-200 years of war. All history was bloody and brutal, and the Levant was fairly stable under Ottoman rule, which was around 500 years in those regions. Compared to the multiple Warring States periods in China and India, that's pretty stable. Also, why are you getting downvoted?!? Nothing you said deserves a downvote.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> you can argue that most of Indian civilization in the 1st millennium was actually Persian I'd say that's valid, particularly if you're tracing specific intellectual or cultural traditions. (Agree in not keeping culture/civilisational scorecards.) > can say the same about Punjab, with the multiple Afghan, Turkic, Maratha, British, and indigenous invasions Fair enough. It's another patch of fertile land, at a crossroads between birth sites of human civilisation. That does advance the point, however, that managed chaos is not necessarily inimical to intellectual traditions being preserved. > why are you getting downvoted?!? Nothing you said deserves a downvote. I sort of assume in these discussions everyone gets downvoted and we try to find folks who will change our mind :).
- sn41 3y agoYour response is not entirely correct. Lucknow university was not toe-to-toe with anything. But you are right, Allahabad university had people like Meghnad Saha and C. V. Raman working there at some point. Also, Mulayam Singh did not come into power until the 1990s. The deterioration of universities all over India (not just UP and Bihar) started soon after Independence, with the nascent government looking for leapfrogs through the establishment of IITs, RECs and medical colleges, diverting money away from full-fledged universities. This policy has had some success, but the universities were left in shambles. India has still not done course-correction on that.
- alephnerd 3y ago> Lucknow university was not toe-to-toe with anything Back when my Nanu was helping with all this post-independence "mandirs of science" stuff in the 60s-70s period Lucknow University was fairly competitive in Electronics, Mechanical Engineering, and Aerospace because of Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd - their secondary R&D and production center was Lucknow as it was close enough to Delhi for government oversight yet far enough that it wouldn't be impacted by a India-Pakistan War. > universities were left in shambles Yet Osmania, Panjab, Visevarya, Anna, etc continued to perform (and in some cases still do) in STEM. They never truly declined in the 1960s-2000s period, while Bihar and UP's GDPs both crashed under Lalu and Mulayam, and largely because of de-industrialization in Eastern UP and Bihar due to their warped version of Lohiaism (which Lohia would have hated)