5 ms·
Mr. Kahr, for one, makes no apologies. "If someone is riskier, he should be paying a higher rate,'' he said. "It's more economically sound. It's fairer for risk
by netcan 18y ago
Mr. Kahr, for one, makes no apologies. "If someone is riskier, he should be paying a higher rate,'' he said. "It's more economically sound. It's fairer for riskier people to pay a higher interest rate, higher fees, whatever it is, than less risky people.
Interesting. What he is really saying is 'what's fair got to do with it? Free markets dissolve the concept.
"If there was a demand for a credit card product that never changed its terms and rates and stuck with the customer no matter what, I'd be running around telling people 'Let's market this wonderful fairness card,'" he said.
"You know -- 'transparency card,' 'rock solid card' -- whatever it may be. I don't believe that that would succeed."
- randallsquared 18y ago"Free markets dissolve the concept [of fairness]." Some would say that free markets implement the concept of fairness. Of course, there are no free markets in the world today, to a first approximation, since all the prices and outcomes are distorted by external agencies, so whether free markets are fair is a bit academic.
- netcan 18y agoThat is irrelevant really. You may think that the result is fair, but fair is not the reason that is the result. The free market comes to a result based on a series of self interested decisions. At the core are the buy/sell decisions. I price in a way that maximises my profit, you buy in a way that maximises your utility. Fair (I admit an ambiguous term) represents something external to this.
- randallsquared 18y agoYou maximize your profit as a proxy for maximizing your utility (and some people choose less profit because "helping others" boosts their utility more). Since we're both maximizing our utility in a free market, it's arguable that the outcome of our transaction is maximum fairness, or at least a local maximum of fairness.
- sokoloff 18y ago"What he is really saying is 'what's fair got to do with it?" Huh? People who are "riskier" paying higher rates and fees IS fair. Would you lend your (presumably hypothetical) deadbeat, drug-addled uncle your entire $100,000 retirement nest egg at the same rate and terms that you'd lend the US government? Why the hell not?! He's family, and these big mean credit card companies are profit-seeking arms-length lenders, and you would expect them to act morally better (by your standard, not mine) than you would to family? (I would neither expect, nor as an investor, wish for them to do that.)
- iamelgringo 18y agoI'm sure that paying a premium to borrow money once you are a credit risk would be considered "fair" by many. But, the example that you've posed is a straw man. Of course you'd charge a drug addict higher interest than the the US government. The problem with credit card companies is that they loan the initial money at one price, and then adjust the price dependent on changing credit scores, insurance claims or whims. And, a large percentage of a credit card companies, profit isn't in the initial interest rate. The profit is made in late fees, over limit fees and credit rate increases. So, they have a vested interest in the customer defaulting, being late in their payments or in going over their limit. And, when those fees are assessed, the customer generally has little recourse.
- sokoloff 18y agoI agree with you vastly more than I disagree, but will observe that if you manage your debt reasonably, you have the ultimate recourse when your CC company changes your terms: Fire them. Pay that debt off, possibly by borrowing from another company willing to extend you terms more to your liking. I agree that people to whom no one will lend more money are at a great disadvantage. I don't see any way to fix that, as preventing CC companies from offering variable APR offers in the future will likely make things worse for marginal customers; it will just make the companies completely unwilling to extend them credit. Embargoing consumers who are already suffering doesn't help them in the short term.
- 18y ago