7 ms·
Alcohol Use and Mortality Among Couples in US: Individual and Partner Effects
- datascienced 3y agoWho doesn’t drink? Well definitely someone with stage 4 cancer, so… Edit: this was too snark, I meant: If someone has cancer they are less likely to drink. So more of those people end up in the non-drinking cohort. There may not be many of them, but they are outliers in terms of life expectancy, whether measured in age of death, or age from the survey date.
- leosanchez 3y agoThere are lot of people in my region that don't drink alcohol. It is considered taboo
- bartonfink 3y agohttps://news.gallup.com/poll/509501/six-americans-drink-alcohol.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/509501/six-americans-drink-alco... Nearly 40% of respondents to a Gallup poll don't. That seems high to me, but I would expect somewhere around 15% of people to abstain. But then again I'm not so full of myself to put "data science" in my name on here and say obviously incorrect stuff.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- datascienced 3y agoWhat I am saying is someone who is very ill will not drink, because they are very ill. So regardless of what alcohol does or doesn't do, your non drinking cohort includes all the people who are very ill and don't drink, which I assume is a larger effect than the people who are very ill and drink anyway (due to alcoholism or yolo). Let's say 40% don't drink, 60% do. If 1% of the population are terminally ill. Of those 90% don't drink, 10% do. Then for 1000 people: 10 are terminally ill. 9 don't drink 1 does. 1000 is the total pop. Of those: * 400 don't drink, and 9 of those are terminally ill. * 600 drink and 1 of those is terminally ill. Let's say terminally ill reduces life expectancy by 20 years. The life lost per person due to terminal illness in the non-drinking category is 20 * 9/400, which is 0.45 years. For drinkers it is 20 * 1/600 = 0.03 years.
- letharion 3y agoAlso it has been pointed out elsewhere, that previous alcoholics will likely show up as non-drinkers in a study like this, but will already have done significant damage to their health. The result being that not drinking looks worse than it is.
- nraynaud 3y agoI would add that even if they recovered, drinkers increase their risk for a few cancer, so you probably can't just assess their past health issues to correct the life expectancy.
- ben_w 3y agoI think it's forbidden for Muslims? (Theoretically at least: naturally there are people who take such taboos more or less seriously. Previous line manager was an Iranian with Zelda tattoos).
- 2Gkashmiri 3y agoI live in Kashmir, India (unfortunate) anyway, historically we have been pretty isolated from general mass market societal pressures plus strong religious affiliation means people as a society don't like alcohol. Until last year I think there used to be a single wine shop for like 8 million population. Since then governmental pressure brought more and more shops but natives still don't accept it. We have a huge tourist population who comes here and they are the customers + army. Natives have not consumed alcohol for centuries and there doesn't seem to be a cultural shift towards acceptance so I can say the problems associated with alcohol are just not here. No one gets diagnosed with alcohol liver disease or gets into drunk driving accidents or family abuse stuff. Not do people get into addiction (drugs have been forcefully introduced)
- leosanchez 3y agoAlcohol is not culturally normal in some other states of India too. Ofcourse not as much as Kashmiri. We do have wine shops / bars but there is still taboo around alcohol Thankfully
- datascienced 3y agoProbably, but I was too snark to get my point across. You are fighting for your life => You probably choose not to drink. This skews the non-drinking cohort, for reasons nothing to do with the positive* health effects of drink. * There are probably no positive health effects.
- ben_w 3y agoPerhaps; I don't know. My only data point is anecdotal: my dad had bowel cancer, didn't change his water consumption after the surgery, insisted he was drinking plenty even while the nurse was putting a drip in one arm to rehydrate him and the other arm to give meds because he'd almost destroyed his kidneys. Habits can be hard to change, and self-awareness slow. But an anecdote isn't data.
- ljf 3y agoThis is similar to a friend of mine that read that those who play golf socially, live on average 10 years longer than those who don't. He's very unfit, drinks a lot and doesn't eat well - but gets a round of golf in 2 or 3 times a month. Now I agree 'the cohort of people that regularly play golf' likely do live longer than people who don't play golf - BUT that is not caused by the golf itself. Those who can play golf a) already can get out and do some light exercise b) have the funds to play so putting them in the top 20 to 10 percent of household incomes, c) have a family set up that allows them time away to play golf d) have jobs that leave them with free time and energy to play golf I could go on, but I'd argue strongly that it is not the GOLF that gives them the longevity of life. Same here with the drinking - what are all the others things that go with people being ABLE to socially drink (in moderation)? I'd argue the drink does not cause them...
- robocat 3y ago> If someone has cancer they are less likely to drink Citation? Anecdotally, I know people with cancer that keep drinking heavily (assuming they were drinkers before getting diagnosed). Then again I live in New Zealand which is definitely a drinking culture.
- caeril 3y agoIn my personal experience, this is generally untrue, especially if the cancer is terminal. There is a human tendency to adopt a "fuck it" attitude when confronted with death, and any recreational substance that doesn't interfere with treatment is fully on the menu.
- FabHK 3y agoA) Is the following then the appropriate conclusion? Drink moderately, and find a spouse that drinks approximately as much as you. B) I wonder whether the following set of hypotheses makes sense, and how one could test it: - Social life is good for health - Alcohol is bad for health, and the more, the worse (ie, a monotonous relationship) - At lower levels of alcohol consumption, it brings improvements in social life whose health benefits outweigh the health costs of consumption - At higher levels, this reverses. Thus explaining the U-shaped effect (quadratic, as the study terms it).
- samename 3y agoThat’s how I understood it, too. From what I’ve come to learn, social health is most correlated with longevity. Despite alcohol’s negative physical effects, it appears to have net positive effects overall in terms of longevity when consumed at moderate/low doses.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoThis finding keeps coming up in social science research: being connected to people seems to increase longevity. Which begs the follow up question: what is the underlying mechanism(s) that causes this effect? Does social comparison promote self maintenance? Does the sharing of ideas lead to better cognitive hygiene? Does sharing power tools lead to less household accidents? Do we need to sniff other people's pheramones? On a sceptical note, do extraverts, the sort of people who consent to be studied, continually arrive at conclusions that justify extraversion, missing the huge cohort of introverts who are quite content with minimal social contact?
- swores 3y ago> This finding keeps coming up in social science research: being connected to people seems to increase longevity. Has a causal relationship in that direction actually been shown in research, or just correlation? Because it seems very likely (well, certain for at least some people based on anecdotal experience) it goes in the other direction as well, i.e. someone who has serious health issues which cause them pain or low energy levels or whatever, would likely have less of a social life than if they were completely healthy even if they were the most social person imaginable before their health issues. If for example I were diagnosed with cancer tomorrow and died of it in ten years time, I suspect it would significantly reduce the energy I have for social activity in the next ten years, but a study done just before I die finding correlation between my not having a good social life and my impending death wouldn't change the cause of death from cancer to lack of social contact. (FYI I'm not arguing that social activity doesn't have any positive impact on physical health / length of life, in fact I'm sure that it can - I just don't know to what extent research has or hasn't shown how much it's one way or the other.)
- efwdwedewf 3y ago[flagged]
- trosi 3y agoTo some extent, I imagine that moderate alcohol consumption is an almost necessary consequence of having an active social life. If a couple tells you that they both drink, it's likely that they do so together and with friends, which is a good thing. There are myriads of exceptions, I am sure.
- 317070 3y agoThe caveat is that this is cultural, and so we can change this consequence if we want to. Me and my friends rarely drink when we meet.
- rpastuszak 3y agoI’m not sure why this is downvoted. In most Muslim countries you’ll find people having great time drinking mint tea/ playing backgammon/chatting. It goes to show how tightly alcohol consumption is coupled with the cultural upbringing.
- conductr 3y agoAs a WASPy dude in ‘merica, not drinking is something people still struggle to grasp. I’m middle aged now, and I still have regular social outings where someone is like flabbergasted “so, you never drink? But, why? Did you ever?” Sometimes I can tell they just are doing mental calculus and just determine I most be a recovering alcoholic and they suddenly apologize for their questioning. There’s some humor in it, but just not enjoying it enough or feeling a thirst for it is the only way I can explain it. I like how it taste ok, I just never really want to consume it. I usually say something like “do you like whole milk? When was the last time you drank a glass of it?” This makes the point 9/10 times, because a lot of people like milk but just never drink it. I’m the same with alcohol.
- rpastuszak 3y agoHehe, I like that approach. I hate milk, so I'll try to come up with a lactose-free metaphor though. One of the funny things about alcohol as a drug is that if you tell people you don't drink, they automatically assume you have a problem. I grew up and lived in countries with strong drinking cultures (incl. PL, UK, AT, PT) and I don't mind a drink myself. Having said that, the "cultural programming" (lazy expression, but I'm in a rush, sorry) is so hard to shake off. This stood out to me especially in the UK, where I felt bad for my muslim friends not being able to participate in many social events because they don't drink.
- ysris 3y agoI would be very interested, if somebody can access the full paper, to know what amount of alcohol is "light drinking" for them. 2 glasses a day ? a week ? a month ? with people ? during dinner ?
- femto 3y ago"less than 2 drinks a day". They draw the definition from Muscari et al. (2015).
- ysris 3y agoThanks. Interesting. In France, where I am, awareness campaigns recommend sticking to a maximum of 2 glasses per day, for men, 1.5 for women. and not every day. And these values only take into account protection against serious health problems, such as stroke, not the problems of moderate daily alcohol consumption, such as for example the fact that alcohol being a depressant, consumption will have a impact on their general well-being. To be honest, I'm even more confused on what to think about this paper.
- reducesuffering 3y agoThe J-curve charts I've seen indicated lowest all-cause mortality at 3 drinks / week for men and 2 drinks / week for women. So even if you believe there's something healthy to alcohol (and it's not just the unhealthy people -> have to drink 0), it probably won't be any healthier going past 3 or 2 / week. Portion size is 12oz 5% beer, 5 oz 12% wine, 1.5oz 40% liquor.
- ysris 3y agoAgreed. From what I know, the positive points of certain alcohols such as wine which would protect against heart problems have either been denied, or the same advantages have been found in everyday non-alcoholic products (green tea if I remember well).
- genman 3y ago
- nraynaud 3y agoDid the non-drinking couples get regressed out of the confounders? I would guess a lot of people stop drinking after a health scare, so you'd have to remove the effect of the underlying medical issue to compare them with the moderately drinking people.
- worstspotgain 3y agoThis is a classic example of selection bias in an observational (= non-randomized) study. There is no mention in the abstract of whether other health variables were statistically controlled for. And since it's a longitudinal study over a long time span, you can pretty much bet that it'd be insufficient anyways. You would also expect to see exactly this pattern in the data, with light drinking correlating strongly with otherwise-good health and non-drinking correlating mildly with otherwise-bad health. Parenthetically, the same effect turns up with elective Covid vaccinations. At-risk populations are much more likely to opt in, so vaccinated groups often have worse hospitalization and death rates than unvaccinated ones. Disingenuous observational studies are then used to justify anti-vax nonsense.
- ak_111 3y agoHas their been a large scale alcohol effect study that exploits the fact that some religions (particularly Islam, Judaism) don't tend to consume alcohol? It will probably need to be delicately applied since religion correlates with many other socioeconomic/genetic conditions, but I think showing that certain cancers are not as common in for example Indonesia and Turkey as compared to Australia and Greece would be an interesting hypothesis concerning the impact of alcohol.
- viciousvoxel 3y agofyi, Judaism does not prohibit the consumption of alcohol. Sometimes it's even required for religious purposes -- notably you need to drink four "cups" (at least the volume of an olive, IIRC) during the upcoming Passover seder. Of course there still may be differences in consumption patterns though.
- ak_111 3y agoTrue, I should have said something like Mormonoism.
- swed420 3y agoAlcohol is considered to be a known carcinogen fwiw https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/alcohol/alcohol-fact-sheet https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/a...