3 ms·
The EPA can only do what Congress says it can do. The law Congress wrote deliberately creates a distinction between existing uses and new uses. And the law deli
by rayiner 3y ago
The EPA can only do what Congress says it can do. The law Congress wrote deliberately creates a distinction between existing uses and new uses. And the law deliberately makes it harder to ban an existing use than a new one.
The environmental laws are full of those distinctions. For example, under the clean air act, the emissions control technology you need to use for new emitters is different than for existing emitters. Congress doesn’t like to disrupt industry because voters care vastly more about jobs than they do about the environment.
Why would it be “reasonable” for a court to leave an illegal agency order in place? That seems like the opposite of reasonable—that sounds like lawlessness.