6 ms·
How will you compete if GitHub talks to the Azure folks (who have the benefit of Azure scale) and gets better compute and network treatment for runners? Or is t
by toomuchtodo 3y ago
How will you compete if GitHub talks to the Azure folks (who have the benefit of Azure scale) and gets better compute and network treatment for runners? Or is the assumption GH running remains perpetually stunted as described (which is potentially a fair and legit assumption to make based on MS silos and enterprise inertia)?
To be clear, this is a genuine question, as compute (even when efficiently orchestrated and arbitraged) is a commodity. Your cache strategy is good (will be interested in testing to tease out where is S3 and where is Ceph), but not a moat and somewhat straightforward to replicate.
(again, questions from a place of curiosity, nothing more)
- jacobwg 3y agoYep, it's a good question! At the moment, my thoughts are roughly: GitHub's incentives and design constraints are different than ours. GitHub needs to offer something that covers a very large user-base, to cover the widest possible number of workflows, and they've done this by offering basic ephemeral VMs on-demand. CI and builds are also not GitHub's primary focus as an org. We're trying to be the absolute fastest place to build software, with a deep focus on achieving maximum performance and reducing build time as much as possible (even to 0 with caching). Software builds today are often wildly inefficient, and I personally believe there's an opportunity to do for build compute what has been done for application compute over the last 10 years. GitHub Actions workflows are more of an "input" for us then (similar to how container image builds have been), with the goal of adding more input types over time and applying the same core tech to all of them.
- mason55 3y agoThis is one of the best responses about market positioning that I've ever read. Best of luck to you!
- toomuchtodo 3y agoGood reply. It seems like you understand the market and where your product fits, which is half the battle. Wishing you much success.
- jacobwg 3y agoThank you!
- JohnMakin 3y agoThis is a really clever product and I'd love to learn more - good luck.
- playingalong 3y agoCorporate inertia might not be the only reason for excessive pricing. They might simply charge for everything working out of the box convenience. Or even for not being aware there are other options.
- crohr 3y agoI believe the solution is to decentralise, i.e. let the customer run the machines in their own AWS account (what I'm doing with RunsOn, link in bio if interested). It is very hard for a single player to get favourable treatment from Azure / AWS / GCP to handle many thousands of jobs every day / hour. I wish Depot all the luck, I think they've done good work wrt caching.
- coredog64 3y agoNot mentioned down-thread, but GitHub’s incentive is to sell you CI minutes, and slow runners are shooting fish in a barrel.