3 ms·
> I've never gotten a job by applying to it. It's always been referrals or someone reaching out to me. This is always a bewildering one, but I've heard similar
by ryandrake 3y ago
> I've never gotten a job by applying to it. It's always been referrals or someone reaching out to me.
This is always a bewildering one, but I've heard similar stories on HN, so I guess it does happen! I've never understood how this would work in practice, outside of 1. tiny companies who have no HR department and hire you by having the CEO shake your hand, OR 2. you're applying to be some big shot CxO/SVP guy and they have a special process for you.
Sure, I've had people reach out to me, like recruiters, former co-workers, and so on. They'll tell me about the role, find out if I'm interested, but at some point, inevitably will say, "OK Great! Go to this URL and fill in the application. Good luck!" How the f- do you skip that step? Do companies actually just mail you the job offer after a few chats, bypassing the application, phone screens, in-person interviews, coding challenges, take-home-tests, and so on??? What kind of a Captain Of Industry do you have to be to get this kind of special treatment? I've never seen it, and while I'm no John Carmack, I'm not a schmuck either.
- kelseyfrog 3y agoI've networked my way to every job except my first one. You make friends at work, have lunches where they bring their friends from other companies or keep in touch with folks after they move on. When you reach out, you'll hear a "Sure, we've got a spot open for <job>. Let me introduce you to the hiring manager," or "Send your resume to <mgmt-email> and tell them I sent you." A vouch is a powerful social tool.
- __rito__ 3y agoI have had three jobs so far, and I applied for none of them. It was just people reaching out to me via mail, or LinkedIn DM. I would be asked to take interview rounds. After those interview rounds, I would just receive the contract PDF via email. I would then start on a stipulated date. I of course failed one on the 4th rounds (of 5 total). One other job, I had done everything good, but they ghosted me anyway. There was one Engineering Manager reaching out to me from FAANG, which I did not take up, because I had multiple different things going on, and studying for FAANG interview takes time- no matter who you are. So, I said that I would be in touch after some of those things were over. But, then came the big layoffs... Then I reached out and they let me know that their team wasn’t hiring anymore, and encouraged me to apply to somewhere else. Which I was not again interested at that point. I regret that the most.
- codexb 3y agoI don't think he means he never had to fill out an official application for consideration. Hell, I have to do that just for inter-company transfers. I think he means in the true sense, in that he simply wasn't cold-calling around applying for jobs. The application didn't get him the job; the relationship did. I've found that to be mostly true as well. At least for the jobs I wanted.
- jxnlco 3y agomore like i've never gotten a job from an official application :( failed most interviews
- randomdata 3y agoI can relate. When I had little in the way of a professional network I applied to a job once, but that was no more than sending an email that was essentially "Hey, I think we should work together." And it turned out they agreed. From that I started making connections. > What kind of a Captain Of Industry do you have to be to get this kind of special treatment? Word on the street is that times have now changed, it might not work anymore, but there was a software heyday where companies were happy to find anyone willing to work for them. You didn't have to be anyone particularly special. You just had to be the only person to show up, which was easy because nobody else did. Still works in other industries, though. I just hired a customer on the spot in a non-tech businesses because they happened to mention that they had recently left their previous job in the same industry. I wasn't going to risk losing them over some silly application process.
- silverquiet 3y ago> Word on the street is that times have now changed I'm not that old, but back when I got into the IT world, it was not seen as a particularly desirable profession; I rather liked the idea of being the troll in the basement who didn't need to talk to people and just kept the machines running. I suppose I grew up a bit along with the industry, and that is a good thing, but once it became a bit more lucrative it started attracting a fair amount of attention that I'd rather it didn't have.
- Viliam1234 3y agoTwenty years ago, people joined IT because they loved computers. Many of them were on the autistic spectrum. Today, people join IT because they know that's where the money is. For the people who are on the autistic spectrum, this is a bad news, because now they are expected to become happily extraverted, work in noisy open spaces, get interrupted by meetings all day long (and then be on call during the night), keep networking, and get sufficiently good at office politics so that they don't get fired for understanding some corporate bullshit literally. Technical skills are still important, but secondary. tl;dr -- IT was gentrified by normies
- icedchai 3y ago
- sanderjd 3y agoI haven't gone to a link and filled out an application in a very long time. The way that has generally worked is that the internal contact puts your resume (or just a linkedin profile link) directly into the top of the "do a phone screen" funnel. This is indeed more common at smaller or earlier stage companies. My current job was an "internal contact" at a smallish ~20 person company, where that entailed the CEO still personally manning the "reach out if you're interested in working with us and tell us why!" email address. My "this is why I understand and would be excited to work at your company" message, along with my linkedin profile, was a close enough match for what they were looking for right that moment to make it into the phone screen funnel right away. But recruiters can do this as well. It's sort of the whole point... I think it would be weird for a recruiter to do a direct reach-out, and then say "ok here's the application link, good luck!". Like, what did they actually do there? Just making you aware of the application link? That's marketing, not recruiting... But I also haven't ever skipped past the phone screen(s) and interview(s) straight to a job offer. I agree with you that this can't be as widespread as people make it seem. I could see that happening if I'm applying to work directly with / for someone I've already worked with a bunch in the past. But even then, we would need to meet for coffee or a drink a time or two to discuss the opportunity, and ... that's an interview!
- tstrimple 3y ago> This is indeed more common at smaller or earlier stage companies. This is anecdotal of course, but the last three companies that I’ve worked for that employ over 100k employees followed the exact same process. Strong internal referrals are little more than basic due diligence and welcome aboard if they hit during hiring season. There are some other interviews, but unless you’re seriously bad at conversations they are mostly a formality.
- sanderjd 3y agoWhich ones? There aren't that many software companies of that size. I worked for one of them (Google) until a couple years ago, and I never knew of any ICs, at least up to the "Staff" level, who skipped the interview gauntlet on the back of an internal referral. It was a good way to get an interview though (which was already a big advantage). Maybe it was different for managers though. Is this different at Meta/Amazon/Microsoft? That has not been my impression, but I don't have personal experience with those companies.
- nonameiguess 3y agoPossibly an artifact of the enormous number of startups that appeared in the past 15 years. I've been a 3rd and 10th employee of two, and both times there was no application. There isn't even an HR department. You meet a few people and that's it. They're too busy doing their actual jobs to specialize in hiring and make this any kind of a real process you're familiar with from longer standing larger companies. And, for what it's worth, I was in the Army before I got into software and you don't apply to jobs in the Army, either. You certainly go through a long, drawn-out, highly formal structured process, but it isn't filling out a job history and sitting through rounds of interviews.
- lowken10 3y ago[dead]
- throwaway22032 3y ago#1 describes essentially every company I've ever worked for beyond basic retail stuff. I hate the impersonal feel once you get above 50 or so. If I'm not on first name terms with the boss, at least the local one, I'm not interested.
- jemmyw 3y agoI've only taken 1 job where I applied and interviewed through a normal pipeline, which was when I moved country. Now, I have been through the whole application and interview process quite a few times, getting either rejected or an offer, but for one reason or another I've never accepted the offer. So for every other job I've had I've either been approached or I mentioned I was looking, and by doing so I got to skip some or all of the process. Once the process being "I still have to interview you though" "ok..." "That was your interview, did you enjoy it?" I didn't aim for this though. I'm not a networking type person. I'm very shy. I've been active on various local or niche tech forums and chat servers, been to tech meetups where I've mostly been quiet.
- ebiester 3y agoIf I am a former coworker, and I reach out to you, and give you a URL, it's a unique URL that ties back to me as an internal referral. You are then given higher priority over the general stack: you have just cut through the automated tracking system. On the other side, we will have 200 people apply in a day for some jobs. 190 of them will be people we wouldn't even consider for the job, and it's entirely possible that a blind submission that is good will get swept up with the bad. This just doesn't happen with internal submissions. Now, the days of "any referral of X is an auto-hire" is gone for any company under 20 people, at this point, because there are many ways that can go wrong legally. However, that doesn't mean it's useless: you have a significant advantage with an internal submission.
- atoav 3y agoFor me it also was a lot like that. During my freelance time I not once had to search for a client and they all came via referral. I was above average good and fast at what I did while being extremely clear in my communication. That alone meant people recommended me when someone had a problem or a project revolving about what I am good at. Nearly all of that happened during my studies, with some of it being direct contacts from university.
- robocat 3y agohttps://ludic.mataroa.blog/blog/my-wild-experience-interviewing-with-real-engineers/ https://ludic.mataroa.blog/blog/my-wild-experience-interview...
- icedchai 3y agoI've seen it happen at small companies (under 30 or so.) You get the white glove treatment during the interview. They'll skip the leet-code because you have a strong internal referral and they're desperate to fill a role fast.
- decafninja 3y agoThe recruiter reaches out, we have a chat, and if things align well enough, they put me in the pipeline for a phone screen. If the recruiter has you filling out the formal application, then that’s probably them soft-rejecting you and your application will join the majority of the hundreds or thousands of other cold-appliers in the ether of digital oblivion. Having said that, every job I’ve gotten in my career has been through a recruiter reaching out first. Any attempt to cold apply via online application has been met with automated rejection or ghosting. Any attempt to reach out to a recruiter first has them directing me to the online application form that leads straight to oblivion. There are people out there that can leverage their networks to easily land jobs. However the catch here seems to be that you can’t be picky about where you end up. Unless you’re lucky enough that most of your friends and ex-colleagues are in influential positions at highly desirable organizations. Heck, I could probably leverage my network to land a job pretty quickly. It’s just highly unlikely it will be at a company I’d want to work for unless I’m desperate.