4 ms·
I think we should ban PFAS. But it’s important to understand that Inhance is also relying on a rule that was deliberately incorporated into the law we have, dec
by rayiner 3y ago
I think we should ban PFAS. But it’s important to understand that Inhance is also relying on a rule that was deliberately incorporated into the law we have, decades ago, for good reasons.
The law makes a distinction between new uses, which require certain notice to the EPA, and existing uses. The idea is that the EPA can be more aggressive with a new thing that isn’t being used yet, than an existing thing that people are relying on. That balance was written into the law.
The environmental laws are full of these frameworks that force the EPA to make different trade offs. They’re not loopholes for industry, they’re the reality of balancing costs and benefits in a country where voters will throw you out of office if gas goes above $4/gallon. You’ll never get a law that says “EPA can ban anything it wants, costs be damned.”
Inhance has been using this same fluorination process for 40 years. The EPA itself has repeatedly told companies doing flourination they’re not covered by PFA orders. The EPA changed its mind based on new science, for probably reasonable reasons. But it’s entirely fair to make it go through the processes in the law for banning a longstanding use, instead of trying to use its authority over new uses to get at the same thing.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoCan the government also pursue Inhance for the cost of damages incurred by the continued use of PFAS based on new science? Or do we all have to collectively eat the cost of harm because of the “it’s not fair to Inhance to immediately ban it” legal process? Certainly, the EPA should have to work its process from a due process perspective, but private industry should not be permitted to harm based on new science without a cost burden. Make them put a bond up, calculated by the estimated cost of the harm burden between now and when a final decision is made.
- overstay8930 3y ago> Can the government also pursue Inhance for the cost of damages incurred by the continued use of PFAS based on new science? That's up to a judge, and if necessary, the supreme court. Lotta people don't give enough credit to a system that has been around longer than most others in the world. There's a reason why everyone bets on the USA, there are contingencies for contingencies for contingencies. If it's important enough it will get done. On the flip side, imagine if a crony in the EPA could arbitrarily ban products from companies that didn't donate enough to a certain political party.
- mandmandam 3y agoSpicy take. The Supreme Court is clearly unhinged and monstrously outdated. Checks and balances? Lol. And the fish rots from the head. The abuses of lower courts and basically every regulatory body are well documented, and the accountability for corrupt judges is near-zero. Any institution which actually functions to protect people gets defunded. > There's a reason why everyone bets on the USA Because a dying empire is liable to do just about anything to get what it wants. Genocide, mass murder, arming your enemies, blackmail on a global scale, sanctions that murder millions, wrecking the climate, criminalizing abortion - nothing is off the table. Among many other reasons, that's why the world has viewed America as the number 1 threat to democracy, world peace, and stability every single year since 2003. "Everyone bets on the USA" to fuck shit up. That's not an exaggeration, though American's never believe it. It's not close either. We're number 1. Very few people trust American regulation; whether on food, chemicals, privacy or anything else. We are a global laughing stock; a stark example of why unregulated capitalism is so dangerous. There's a reason why America's water quality is among the worst in the developed world. There's a reason why we're mocked world-wide. There's a reason why our Presidential 'options' are the two most unpopular politicians in the country for three elections running, and it's not cause our system is working so well.
- ajross 3y ago> On the flip side, imagine if a crony in the EPA could arbitrarily ban products from companies that didn't donate enough to a certain political party. That's a silly strawman. In that case you'd sue for inappropriate regulation and win, just like this case, but better because you'd be right. The EPA's charter doesn't allow for political fundraising, it would be a trivial case to win. The complaint here isn't that courts shouldn't have the ability to oversee government agencies to make sure they're doing it right. The complaint here is that the fifth circuit is deliberately interfering with the operation of a government agency doing what it is supposed to do.
- everforward 3y agoInhance's yearly revenue is $31M, at least from what I can find. Even if the government goes after them, they'll be worthless. They specialize in fluoridated products, I bet PFAS is most of what they make. So the stock will be worthless. Their physical holdings are likely to be... Primarily fluoridating equipment, which won't be worth much if we're banning those processes anyways. There won't be anything worth anything to seize, it'll be the government's mess to clean up. > On the flip side, imagine if a crony in the EPA could arbitrarily ban products from companies that didn't donate enough to a certain political party. That company would presumably sue under the argument that the EPA is only authorized to regulate chemicals harmful to the environment? It is a dramatically easier solution than "have Congress deal with it", which historically has meant "do nothing about it". Also, your "solution" just pushes that problem up a tier. What if Congress decides to target a political party? That one is much harder to fight in court too.
- everforward 3y agoLet me make sure I understand this correctly, because you're saying this is a good thing, and I'm thinking we need to track down whoever wrote this regulation and put them in an assisted living facility because I don't think they should be trusted to dress themselves. The EPA has wide unilateral authority to ban new uses, for which we have little to no usage data for. But if we start executing those uses and get actual usage data that a substance is harmful, the EPA is toothless? And that's a good thing why exactly? > You’ll never get a law that says “EPA can ban anything it wants, costs be damned.” Yet we do, they apparently can only do it based on wild guesses though. Data and informed decisions be damned; well just let them keep making PFAS, and have the citizens pay for the externalities through health insurance premiums, the true blue American way. > Inhance has been using this same fluorination process for 40 years. The EPA itself has repeatedly told companies doing flourination they’re not covered by PFA orders. The EPA changed its mind based on new science, for probably reasonable reasons. But it’s entirely fair to make it go through the processes in the law for banning a longstanding use, instead of trying to use its authority over new uses to get at the same thing. Quick, someone tell the tobacco lobby, they're gonna love this! Something something long standing usage something something loss of jobs something something market cap something something, you can't regulate cigarettes!
- NickM 3y agoyou're saying this is a good thing I don't think the parent comment said that. They just said that the rules were set this way deliberately, and that it's not just a loophole, which is an interesting and informative thing to point out. I don't like the outcome, nor do I like the system that enabled it, but it's useful to have a deeper understanding of why things are the way they are.
- everforward 3y ago> But it’s important to understand that Inhance is also relying on a rule that was deliberately incorporated into the law we have, decades ago, for good reasons. It's like right at the top of that post. And > But it’s entirely fair to make it go through the processes in the law for banning a longstanding use, instead of trying to use its authority over new uses to get at the same thing. At the bottom. It's capped on both ends with calling it a good thing. > I don't like the outcome, nor do I like the system that enabled it, but it's useful to have a deeper understanding of why things are the way they are. Sure, but questions about whether the rule is deliberate or not are answering "how", not "why". In fact, it's mostly trying to distract from the "why" to answer "how".
- mc32 3y agoAs they say, wishing things to be so, don't make them so. Shoehorning old laws and statutes to cover new things, is probably not the best way to go about regulation -though it happens. It's preferable that they establish new laws to address current issues. I prefer the courts to not be activist and for them to make the legislators actually do the work they are supposed to be doing rather than being timid for fear of upsetting voters or donors. It's their job to act on behalf of their citizenry.
- BobaFloutist 3y ago>if gas goes above $4/gallon.
- mrguyorama 3y agoThat's always been the weirdest thing to me: If gas going up a few tens of cents a gallon causes you such "economic anxiety" that you vote for a literal chronic failed businessman to set the tone of your country, maybe you weren't doing very well to start with, and you should consider blaming the people who have been in power 90% of the past 50 years Then again, these are the same people who think Biden somehow has direct control over gas prices, and not, you know, the Saudis who run OPEC and have very strong ties to that same failed businessman and political party so I guess they don't have a great grasp on reality. Or the ability to recognize pattern, since the gas price regularly goes up before elections for some reason