My gut says this could be more effective. After all, the initial “phish” (the innocent looking email the manager receives) isn’t fishy at all, and unlikely to t

My gut says this could be more effective. After all, the initial “phish” (the innocent looking email the manager receives) isn’t fishy at all, and unlikely to trigger any concern. Once the stakes are raised and the scam is revealed, the email has already been granted some amount of legitimacy. Sure, it can easily fail (“did you really want me to wire money to Cyprus?”), just as any phishing email can. But by bypassing the initial phishing filters of the recipient’s awareness, I could see it having a higher success rate than a cold phish that leads immediately with the scam. No evidence or knowledge either way, just a hunch.