3 ms·
There should be no other art, arguably. What is an "insider" in art? Someone who has a private telephone line to the god of true style?
by kazinator 3y ago
There should be no other art, arguably.
What is an "insider" in art? Someone who has a private telephone line to the god of true style?
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoThe article hints at that, it basically means he didn't have any formal education in art, little outside influence from established artists, did not get any feedback on his work, did not publish anything on his own; I'm not sure if he ever gave any interviews or context after the works were discovered.
- kazinator 3y agoThree-year-old's drawing posted on refrigerator: outsider art or not? It seems that "outsider art" only really makes sense as "work produced by someone not participating in a certain socio-economic structure that some people have erected in connection with their art-related interests", which is a remark that has no value. Someone doing "outsider art" is an outsider to something, but that something is not art itself. That socio-economic structure is not art itself. The "outsider art" designation doesn't say anything about the art itself, only the circumstances of one who made it; it is a form of ad hominem. There is no such thing as "outsider art" just like "logical proposition uttered by a known liar" is not actually a real category of logical propositions, like "true proposition". Art requires no membership in any club, or conformity to any shibboleths. Because art is a basic human expression; it doesn't require education, or discussion or anything else. "Insider art" is not any more valid than "outsider art", because art doesn't require any conformance to a code. It's not like "outsider residential wiring", where someone who is not a trained and licensed electrician can make a code-violating mess that is unsafe. Becoming part of some millieu in connection with doing art is entirely optional. The literal interpretation of "outsider art" is nonsensical, like this: "You may have produced a natural smell out of your anus, but since you have no formal education in it, don't follow influences of notable farters, and don't receive feedback on your work from connoiseurs of flatulence, it is 'outsider fart'."
- Applejinx 3y agoCommunity art. Think the Algonquin round table, or Cyberpunk, or Impressionism, etc etc. Very often when something begins to happen, people's social behaviors kick in and they get interested in what they all are doing, and that's where you get movements and styles across multiple artists. They're in a community.
- npteljes 3y agoVery simple, if you look at the definition of outsider art. "Insider" would be someone with training in arts, or an artist having art connections while doing their art. Most notable arts are done this way.
- kazinator 3y agoThat is a someone; but the term in question is "insider art". If that someone makes art, that gets labeled "insider art". Without knowing who made some art, in what circumstances, can we reliably test a work of art to tell whether it is insider art or outsider art?
- npteljes 3y agoArt is not just about the thing itself, it can be about the context of the creation, and the viewer too. "Outsider art" is about the context of the creation. So without knowing who made the art, it's impossible, or impractical to determine if it's outsider or not.