4 ms·
I'm sure it will cut down on some of this, but the most notorious of offenders probably won't change their ways. And I doubt many employees will report on thei
by kelnos 3y ago
I'm sure it will cut down on some of this, but the most notorious of offenders probably won't change their ways. And I doubt many employees will report on their bosses for fear of getting fired, or retaliated against in more subtle ways. Regardless of any anti-retaliation provisions.
I do agree with the quote in the article about how it could reduce flexibility. If employers have to develop a company-wide policy defining work hours, that means employees can't really shift their schedules earlier or later. (Well, they can, but employers might be uncomfortable with a situation where an employee is working from noon until 8pm, but they're not allowed to contact them after 5pm.)
Or companies will just say "our work hours are 7am to 10pm, take it or leave it", with it understood that employees will generally only be working for 8 (or whatever) hours of that, but bosses can contact workers anywhere in that time range.
- xcv123 3y ago> I doubt many employees will report on their bosses for fear of getting fired Employees can simply ignore their bosses emails/calls after hours. No need to report anyone.
- BenFranklin100 3y agoExactly.
- kelnos 3y agoSure, and bosses can promote and give better raises to the employees who do answer messages after hours, while letting the careers of the ignorers languish. That's true today, of course, but unfortunately I don't think laws can really fix that.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoSome bosses will do that, but others will refrain fearing the possible legal consequences.
- xcv123 3y agoOf course there will always be sociopaths in management and it will never be perfect. But the law is better than nothing. The employer would be forced to make the after hours policy explicit in the contract. If the employer violates the contract then they risk being sued. If there is any form of retribution (skipped promotion) then they could be sued. The bosses own boss would probably tell him to comply with the policy and stop fucking around. Not worth the risk. But there will always be some criminal managers who ignore the risk.
- ohmyiv 3y agoAt my current position, company policy says we're not supposed to answer work calls after hours. We also have flexible schedules, but we have to notify supervisors of the hours, preferably ahead of time. They use those hours to decide whether or not to contact us. They make it clear that if we are off work, we don't have to answer any calls or respond to texts. Luckily, my supervisors are all about the policy and don't contact us during non-working hours.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoThe legislation runs off of what the employee's normal hours are. It doesn't forbid schedule shifting at the employee's discretion, and declaring 7am-10pm hours would not be recognized as legitimate unless the employee actually normally performs work during those entire hours. If this passes and California aggressively enforces it (and they normally do), employers will not be able to weasel out of it by using blatant bad faith rectus. Some will try at first and regret it when CA hangs them out to make an example of.
- chmod775 3y ago> And I doubt many employees will report on their bosses for fear of getting fired, or retaliated against in more subtle ways. Regardless of any anti-retaliation provisions. Precisely. The people this would (but doesn't) protect are those who don't have a strong position or one would describe as meek. Most often it is the latter or both. Those in a strong position, who had no problem ignoring work messages when it wasn't convenient or telling their manager to shove it if necessary didn't have the problem this tries to solve. The only time these employers really change their behavior is when they are so afraid of the legal repercussions, they make it a point to adhere to the regulations and then some. It doesn't help that this is fighting culture (weak separation of work and life).
- gumby 3y ago> And I doubt many employees will report on their bosses for fear of getting fired, or retaliated against in more subtle ways. The point is that when you quit you cite this as a reason and they pay severance.
- kelnos 3y agoWhy would they do that? I've only read the article, and not the bill itself, but I don't see anywhere where this law would mandate that sort of arrangement.
- gumby 3y agoTo keep you from discussing it publicly. I don’t know of any law that requires severance, afaik it’s always in exchange for your silence.