4 ms·
FCC to vote on restoring net neutrality
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Carr Opposes Biden Internet Control Plan https://www.fcc.gov/document/carr-opposes-biden-internet-control-plan https://www.fcc.gov/document/carr-opposes-biden-internet-con...
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoNote "net neutrality" described here as "Internet Control Plan" by FCC Commissioner
- kouru225 3y ago[flagged]
- axus 3y agoInternet Service Provider Control would be more accurate. Has any of the bad stuff come to pass since it was lost?
- jerkstate 3y agowell, we certainly have pervasive censorship online now
- wtallis 3y agoBy ISPs? Most of the censorship that I've seen people complain about is done by social media website operators, not ISPs.
- s4mw1se 3y agoI have not seen proof ISPs are censoring anything, i’ve also not seen proof they are not. Just because we “Don’t see it” does not mean we should assume it’s not happening. Just because Social Media is worse at censorship does not mean ISPs don’t contribute.
- nostromo 3y agoBecause of Google and Facebook - not your ISP.
- rockskon 3y agoIn some jurisdictions, yes. A number of other jurisdictions have legislated their own Net Neutrality rules though and the issue is still a relatively hot topic in internet policy circles. So ISPs are waiting for all controversy around it to die down before more aggressively abusing their position to favor their own services and cripple that of competitors and anyone who refuses to pay them extra $$$ beyond what they already pay.
- throw10920 3y agoI read some of the dissent document above. While Carr is obviously biased and uses inflammatory language, and makes some illogical arguments, his arguments on the "Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act"[1] are much better-reasoned and appear to come from solid legal standing. His opinion is that net neutrality isn't a problem. I think that's absolutely incorrect - but I do agree with his opinion that Title II isn't necessarily the right way to solve net neutrality. The linked dissent below is more worth reading. [1] https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-398477A3.pdf https://docs.fcc.gov/public/attachments/DOC-398477A3.pdf
- _justinfunk 3y agoNot again... "Net Neutrality", whether you are for or against the policy, is just a terrible name. It is too ambiguous.
- jjulius 3y agoThe ambiguity is the point, unfortunately.
- Sohcahtoa82 3y agoYup. Just like "immigration reform".
- kouru225 3y agoIf they change it you know how many conspiracy theories that’d open it up to?
- wtallis 3y agoIt's a very accurate label even if it is a bit imprecise since it doesn't convey anything about the nuances of the policy. You're probably not going to be able to come up with a better name that isn't much longer. Or did you mean that you'd prefer a policy without nuances?
- _justinfunk 3y agoWhat I mean is that last time there was an argument about "Net Neutrality" - you had people on this forum both arguing for "net neutrality" but on different sides of the nuanced policy. You could say that the "stupid wrong person" just doesn't understand the law - but that is my point - it's a bad name if both sides think it means what they want.
- kouru225 3y agoSo what are the betting odds?
- shmerl 3y agoLong overdue.
- dilap 3y agoHave you noticed any negative impacts from not having net neutrality? I haven't -- compare this to FOSTA-SESTA, which knocked craigslist personals and various other sites offline. I don't really see why people get so worked up about net neutrality.
- SkyPuncher 3y agoYes, I have. Some Mobile internet providers seduce stream quality unless you pay more. Despite advertising speeds and capacity, they still limit you.
- unclebucknasty 3y ago>I don't really see why people get so worked up about net neutrality. At the time, there were still remnants of the early ideas about the Internet being a democratizing force. For instance, that it would be possible for anyone to stand up a service and have an equal chance of competing.
- bisby 3y agoMultiple major ISPs used to throttle Netflix, so that customers would have a poor experience and switch to the ISP owned streaming service. That stopped the last time net neutrality came up (that was basically WHY it came up). Right now, if there are no immediately visible negative impacts, it's because ISPs are being cautious to not get regulated, not because they won't do it again. If companies are doing nothing wrong and are just doing exactly what we want anyway, they would have no issues supporting net neutrality: "That's what we're already doing, it's a good thing!" The fact that they are so adamantly against "don't throttle your competitors traffic" is a huge red flag screaming "thats exactly what they are trying to do". So I have seen negative impacts from not having net neutrality in the past (netflix throttling), yes.
- 3y ago
- dantheman 3y ago[flagged]
- bluish29 3y agoI think people argue that without net neutrality, we didn't see much negative impact. Except that it is not always about what is happening, but what could happen. This can be useful if at some point the internet providers started to collude or think about changing the status quo. It is one thing to rely on the status quo to be the same by the good well (maybe market forces, but they often fail to protect customers) of the providers but another if they are required to do.
- nateglims 3y agoYeah, I don't buy the noblesse oblige view. We are watching tech companies freely throwing away trust of employees and consumers for financial gains.
- wtallis 3y agoIt's also about what did happen in the past. ISPs explicitly targeted P2P protocols like BitTorrent instead of identifying and fixing the underlying network problems (bufferbloat) that were first exposed by p2p but eventually became problematic for many other use cases. ISPs extorted streaming video providers that competed against their own bundled services. Cellular providers implemented various zero-rating schemes to explicitly privilege access to certain partner services. All of these are real, documented harms that were inflicted on the public and can be prevented and punished by reasonable net neutrality regulation without interfering with the ability of an ISP to compete in the market by trying to be a better ISP.
- Cody-99 3y ago> All of these are real, documented harms that were inflicted on the public and can be prevented and punished by reasonable net neutrality regulation without interfering with the ability of an ISP to compete in the market by trying to be a better ISP. Exactly. We just watched this exact situation play out when twitch left Korea due to ISP greed [1]. ISPs double dipped by charging both twitch and their users. It is frustrating so many commenters here are acting like there is zero benefit from having net neutrality when the examples are so obvious. [1] https://restofworld.org/2024/south-korea-twitch-exit-problems-stream/ https://restofworld.org/2024/south-korea-twitch-exit-problem...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bigtex 3y agoPeople in rural Texas can get gigabit fiber internet for 80/month, why do I need Net Neutrality again?
- wtallis 3y agoNet neutrality isn't about the raw speeds and prices; it's about discrimination for or against certain ways of using the service.
- Cody-99 3y agoHaving gigabit fiber for $80 a month has nothing to do with net neutrality. Not sure why you would think having fiber means net neutrality isn't needed or desirable. You seem a little confused about what net neutrality means!
- salawat 3y agoWhere? I was lucky to see something else other than HughesNet.
- acdha 3y agoThat’s uncommon in most of the country but it also misses the point: it’s about access. Comcast and Verizon tried to double-charge Netflix for access to their customers and that instinct needs to be blocked because otherwise every MBA looking to juice their quarterly numbers is going to look for opportunities to do it. There’s also a privacy angle: ISPs used to mine search data and even inject tracking cookies into HTTP traffic. That’s less of an issue now with HTTPS so widely used but they still mine TLS host names and would no doubt do anything else which advertisers will pay for as long as it’s legal.
- gnicholas 3y agoAmazing; when will this come to Silicon Valley? There are parts of Menlo that have fiber service, but the rest of us are stuck in a Comcast monopoly (where $80/mo gets you 75/20 service).
- leotravis10 3y agoEven if/when it's voted on, I don't see it actually implemented anytime soon due to the inevitable Big Telecom lawsuits [1] and not to mention that it may be significanly weaker than the 2015 rules. [2] [1] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/04/fcc-democrats-schedule-net-neutrality-vote-making-cable-lobbyists-sad-again/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2024/04/fcc-democrats-sc... [2] https://www.techdirt.com/2024/04/04/fcc-prepares-to-restore-net-neutrality-but-the-new-rules-might-be-weaker-than-the-ones-discarded-by-trump/ https://www.techdirt.com/2024/04/04/fcc-prepares-to-restore-... My point still stands that the US Supreme Court is going to have to step in and decide net neutrality's future one way or another because I can't see Congress pass a law to codify it.