6 ms·
'HR is not your friend': why frustrated workers are hiring reps of their own
- ponector 3y agoThe next article they publish will be 'Your managers is not your friend.' A story for genZ about how people lie and manipulate at work.
- type_Ben_struct 3y agoThis is not exclusive to the US and should be common sense. Except where legally required (e.g. government provided attorney) it should come as no surprise that people are loyal to whoever pays them. HR are paid by the company, and thus they will act in the interests of said company.
- hnlurker22 3y agoThat doesn't mean that this is common knowledge. Specially when HR acts like they're your friend. Many employees are deceived even though it's common sense to you
- sirspacey 3y agoDuring onboarding, many HR teams say they are the employee’s advocate on a variety of issues. They are most emphatically not. Most of the people working in HR that I’ve met (and I’ve met hundreds working in the industry) sincerely believe that valuing people and treating them well is the best way for a company to succeed financially. They are advocates within the organization for it, including on difficult issues like DEI and harassment/abuse. That makes this issue especially pernicious. Sincere, well-intentioned people are very effective gaslighters, especially when they are surprised themselves to find they have been “given orders” when a true crisis occurs.
- darth_avocado 3y agoI have dealt with HR and I've seen these "well-intentioned" people turn on you so quickly. Sociopathy is the personality trait I would use to describe them.
- Jach 3y agoClinical sociopathy probably goes too far for most of them, but the outcomes aren't all that different anyway. I'd encourage people who still doubt or think highly of their ability to deal with HR, but who haven't had it tested yet, to actually engage with them on some low-stakes thing and see how it goes. My own main experience was effectively a complaint about several parents randomly bringing their kids in to run amok around the office. Of course HR wants an in person meeting to discuss further and to try and come off as more friendly. When the HR person pointed out how carefully my email was worded and how they shared it around with the other members of the office HR group to see, I was thinking holy crap, these people... And realized that despite me already being in the "not your friend" camp I had still underestimated them and even me being most careful would probably not be enough in any serious conflict. Now I treat HR situations like a lot of other things: if you're in the situation and dealing with HR about something serious, it's already too late, your mistake was earlier. Optimize towards trying not to make the kinds of mistakes that lead to such situations in the first place, rather than how best to respond while in a bad situation. (Eventually there was a reminder sent out about bringing kids to work outside of any formal bring-them-to-work day being against office policy, as I expected, and for various good reasons some of which I had brought up too, and it stopped. So I got what I wanted out of the exercise, though I got a bit more too with how unsettling it was.)
- innocentoldguy 3y agoTrue! I'm autistic and when I hired on at Amazon, HR told me about all the support and programs Amazon provided for people with autism. When my boss started harassing me over it, though, HR did nothing. The HR representative couldn't even refrain from working on something else during a meeting between me, my boss, and HR. HR in all companies are crap, but Amazon and its HR department are a special kind of hell. I'm glad I'm out.
- darth_avocado 3y ago> That doesn't mean that this is common knowledge At this point, it really is. It's unfortunate too many people consider companies, their bosses and HR as their "friends". Only your friends are your "friends" and that too, not always.
- JohnFen 3y agoDo many really get deceived by this? That would be like thinking a company is being honest when they say "we're a big family here".
- tombert 3y agoI fell for it once a couple years ago, and its even more embarrassing since I had already been working in the industry for like nine years. I don't really want to go into too much detail, but I had to talk to an HR person because of some "concerns" they had about me. The concerns were actually perfectly fair, and the HR rep was very friendly, but when I explained some personal information to the HR person in response, and despite the fact that I told them it was something I wasn't terribly comfortable telling anyone, they felt it prudent to tell my direct manager, and his manager, and his manager's manager that day. I wasn't at the company much longer, but that wasn't even the reason why.
- jahsome 3y agoYes. Many, many people. Friendliness goes a long way towards quelling suspicion. I think it's rather safe to say unassuming kindness can disarm most anyone who isn't a cutthroat, Type A personality. I'm autistic as hell and I can still see how people would fall for it.
- JohnFen 3y agoOK, I can understand that. Perhaps I was surprised just because I'm older and have decades of experience working for various companies, so I've learned better.
- spencerflem 3y agoseems like something that could be provided through a union
- badwolf 3y agoPerhaps if there are multiple frustrated workers, they could get together and pool costs of their own reps... Then if more workers are frustrated they could also join. American Frustrated Workers™ are so close to discovering unions...
- andybak 3y agoThe article does mention unions twice but only obliquely. Definitely feels like a elephant in the room situation - and kind of odd for the Guardian of all places not to highlight.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- atmavatar 3y agoThis is very much a "'No Way To Prevent This' Says Only Nation Where This Regularly Happens" kinda situation. This is one of a long laundry list of problems to which the average American has been trained to abhor the most obvious solution.
- Apocryphon 3y agoBeen saying this for years > As I’ve mentioned before, software engineers will embrace unions once they accidentally reinvent the concept from first principles under a different name. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18992421 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18992421
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoThat plus inject a health dose of the tech buzzword du jour. Last year would have been crypto unions or metaverse unions.
- Apocryphon 3y agoLeveraged Labor Modules
- 3y ago
- nine_zeros 3y agoTime for a union. Seriously, enough with this abuse.
- 1letterunixname 3y agoYes, absolutely. Worker-owned co-ops and unions, including and especially knowledge workers. There are scant few other viable mechanisms to ensure long-term stability in under-regulated democratic societies.
- tehjoker 3y agounions are your friend. simple.
- tombert 3y agoOne thing that I had to learn the hard way years ago is that there's no equivalent to "doctor-patient privilege" for HR people. They can and will use what you say against you, and they will likely relay what you say to other people. It's admittedly pretty cynical, but at this point I treat HR meetings more like police interrogations, and keep my answer short, minimal, and utilitarian, knowing what I say can and will be used against me. It's not fair to the HR people, most of them are perfectly nice, but they're in a position that's often inherently antagonistic towards workers, since they're generally only called when you're in trouble.
- JohnFen 3y agoThe cynicism is correct, though. HR represents the employer and the employer's interests, not the employee's.
- justinjlynn 3y agoIndeed, it's _you_ who are the human "resource" HR is managing.
- FireBeyond 3y agoPrecisely. I had HR literally acknowledge that my manager had objectively done NONE of the things they pledged to do, and that I had done EACH of them... ... and that they were standing by the manager's decision. (I didn't expect any different, to be honest. I'm not that naive. But it was straight up acknowledged that the manager had been dishonest with both me, and HR, but because of their larger investment in him, that was the way they were going to go.)
- tombert 3y agoI think by the time any complaint goes to HR the decisions have generally been made, or at least nearly so. HR is (I think) largely there to gather information they can use for disciplinary action and/or termination.
- cmcconomy 3y ago
- mrangle 3y agoThis is also true of any department within any institution that has a nominal crisis mediation role. Unequivocally, they are there solely to minimize legal exposure for the institution. Their decicisions will reflect that role. For example, take any office within academia that exists to investigate mistreatment. These offices operate only under the color of problem solving for victims.
- spacechild1 3y agoOf course, HR is not your friend. What you probably want is a works council (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_council https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Works_council). However, you'd also need the necessary legal power, as in Germany, for example.
- Aloha 3y agoHR is only on your side when your 'side' aligns with the broader company interest. They're not your enemy, but not automatically your friend either.
- HarryHirsch 3y agoHR are on your side when your interest and theirs are congruent and when they recognize that. You'd think that it would be in the company's best interest to avert lawsuits, but that doesn't mean that they act accordingly. My former employer paid ten millions in settlements in the last two years, several lawsuits are being litigated now, and even more suits are coming down the pike.
- elzbardico 3y agoHR is on your side, when you are an useful pawn to dethrone someone else the company or some political group wants to get rid of. Of course, gratitude is not a common virtue on the corporate world, and you're now marked for execution in a near future convenient time.
- Aloha 3y agoThat presumed a whole lot of cloak and mirrors stuff I have not experienced.
- apwell23 3y agoonce you go HR its game over. Never ever contact HR in any situation.
- JohnFen 3y agoI wouldn't go quite that far. Going to HR to work out glitches in things like your insurance and other benefits is fine, and often the only way to resolve such problems. Just don't forget who they work for.
- WesolyKubeczek 3y agoWhere I worked, immigration-related paperwork was handled by HR. So I had to contact them way more than anyone would like to, but can’t complain about the experience — I guess as long as you want to work for the company and the company wants to have you, you’re good.
- floydnoel 3y agosame rules as for cops. makes sense!
- alphabettsy 3y agoI know of a few people who’ve learned this the very hard way. Unfortunately it’s not more common knowledge. Unions seem to solve many of the issues that arise out of the inherent power imbalance of most employment.
- elzbardico 3y agoHR is not your union. They work for your employer, not for you.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoHR is not your friend, and several comments here say union, but unions go off the rails too. What avoids both kinds of problems? Simply different rules for how the union power structure is populated? Entire organization is a co-op instead of owner + employees? Or is it already the case that union problems are not inevitable and when they have gone bad it was pretty clear how & why, and so no problem?
- moribvndvs 3y agoMy experience with HR has changed significantly in the past 10-15 years for the worse at my previous two positions, and the behavior was consistent. They usually left me and reports to fend for ourselves during disputes, and when they did get involve they often made things worse, in some cases violated our own guidelines. They always side with management (which while unsurprising, makes their existence and our employee handbook superfluous) or a favored employee even when demonstrably wrong. They were obsessed with bad progress reports, even suggested I wasn’t doing a very good job as a manager if my progress report didn’t have any negatives, and had no interest in improvements or generally good performance. I’d have a report that was a strong performer, but I make one comment and it gets blown out of proportion and all the sudden they’re talking about PIPs, denied or reduced bonuses and pay increases, or push them up the list for reduction in force. I was stupid enough to believe them about things being told in confidence once or twice and they absolutely used it against me. Meanwhile, they spent a lot of time spamming and hustling employees into meetings to shovel shitty services and products to help offset payroll. They felt like secret police, and we avoided and mistrusted them accordingly.