7 ms·
NASA, Lockheed Martin Working to Resolve Artemis II Orion Issues
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Cybergenik 3y agorelated: Destin from SmarterEveryDay called out some other issues related to the Artemis mission: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoJsPvmFixU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoJsPvmFixU Curious if this is related to the issues that they're now experiencing.
- sabareesh 3y agoDestin's video was shortsighted but I believe his new video is better on understanding it is not about just flags any more.
- minetest2048 3y agoDo you have a link?
- throwawaymaths 3y agoHe was pretty much trashing lunar starship (which makes sense for the first landings) but seemed to be very much cheerleading SLS. It's boggling to me that no one (not even destin) is talking about scooting a lander + engine module up with F9H and rendezvousing with crew brought up with a normal F9.... After all F9H is even slated to bring up the lunar space station. This would be relatively easy and doable basically "today" plus or minus a year or three of capsule design Edit: clarified to say "lunar starship", added details on F9H
- sabareesh 3y agoCan you please explain why trashing starship makes sense.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- consumer451 3y agoWell, he wasn't entirely fair, but, rapid full-reuse of Starship feels like a distant thing at this point. Rapid full-reuse is required for HLS as according to NASA, around 15 launches of the tanker version will be necessary. Those launches will need to happen in relatively short order. That means either 15 full stacks (Booster + Tanker) ready to go, or a few with full-reuse and very fast turnaround. I can't believe I'm saying this, but there is a chance that Blue Moon lands first.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dotnet00 3y agoCurrent Blue Moon is also a Starship style lander, just instead of Superheavy, it'll launch on New Glenn. It's also a refueling heavy, orbital depot focused lander. Only major difference being that it's hydrogen fueled, and one of their project goals is to solve boil-off free storage of cryogenic hydrogren in orbit, which also seems like a tall order. Kind of hard to believe you think it'll land before Starship when New Glenn itself hasn't even had a flight test yet.
- consumer451 3y ago> Kind of hard to believe you think it'll land before Starship when New Glenn itself hasn't even had a flight test yet. Please put down your pitchfork. I said "I can't believe I'm saying this, but there is a chance." A neutral reading of this would be that I believe Starship will land first.
- dotnet00 3y agoYeah that's fair, sorry if I came off as aggressive
- 3y ago
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago(Talk starts around 20 minutes in.)
- ginkgotree 3y agoI live on the Space Coast (also work in the industry, and thus, have access to well - rumors). The SLS (Senate Launch System as we call it here) was pretty cool to watch in person for the uncrewed mission. Nevertheless, as Destin pointed out, it has some massive challenges and headwinds NASA and contractors are cemented in and must accept the SLS is the selected system we are going with. Rumor (please take it for what that is worth - rumors) are, many here are very suspect of even a 2025 crewed flight.
- disillusioned 3y agoAt what point do we seriously consider the idea that Starship will lap SLS in capabilities and timing, and cancel SLS altogether? I feel like everyone's thinking this, but there's too much pork pressure and sunk cost fallacy to finally just ditch what's turning out to be a misguided approach, nearly 20 years in. It's a platform built of new stock but very old SSMEs, still using hydrogen and all the problems that brings with it, on a non-reusable basis, with apparently varying quality even amongst identically specced but different vendored mission critical parts. The litany of issues they're outlining here are all varying stages of terrifying, and things that shouldn't be getting caught in this validation phase of a rocket that's actually already had a successful-ish launch demonstration. Meanwhile, Starship keeps iterating like crazy, the way SpaceX does, and with significantly reduced relative complexity, on a vertically integrated platform that they have much more control over. I'm no Elon fanboy, but Starship is going to win this race, right?
- pfdietz 3y agoSLS can't even beat F9/FH, never mind Starship. It has already lost.
- ginkgotree 3y agoThe SLS delivered a crew capable Space Vehicle to Lunar orbit, and the space vehicle returned a crew capable capsule back the Earth. The lift capacity of FH is not capable of that. This is all about SWaP: Size, Weight, and Power.
- MR4D 3y agoNASA needs to get out of the launch business. They have proven that they cannot do it anymore. Sell off the ISS as well. Get back to deep space research, communications research, telescopes, and regulations/launch licenses. There are a TON of really smart people at NASA (a good friend of mine being one of them). But they are hampered by politics and bureaucracy. This bureaucracy is not built to launch, it’s built to please a set of senators & Congressmen. And that’s sad.
- ginkgotree 3y agoAgreed. They make a better Customer that draft requirements and RFPs. Exception: JPLs robots.
- MR4D 3y agoJPL is managed by Caltech even though funding comes from NASA. But yes, their robots are truly amazing.
- ginkgotree 3y agoI worked a NASA grant with a few others, combined, we had about 75 years of experience in our fields between the 3 of us. We demonstrated onboard computer vision labeling of geographic features of Jovian ice moons using an emulated BAE RAD750, and a very minimal neural network trained on existing Gallileo imaging data. We were very close to getting into talks to be a Tech Demo on Europa Clipper. Then, a random NASA program manager shut it all down because "I just know, you cant run a CNN labeling on a RAD750," despite the fact that we had easily reproducible hard evidence that it was possible. That was the day I lost a lot of faith in NASA, they are not the organization they used to be.
- simonh 3y agoGetting rid of the ISS would leave Falcon/Dragon, and for some missions Starship nowhere to go. Like it or not, for the moment SpaceX is tied to existing NASA projects. Hopefully that will change as the economics of spaceflight rewrite the rules of what is possible and worth doing, but we're not there yet.