4 ms·
I don't even know why shell companies and companies with secret ownership are even allowed. Well, I mean we all know the real reason: because it benefits rich p
by ryandrake 3y ago
I don't even know why shell companies and companies with secret ownership are even allowed. Well, I mean we all know the real reason: because it benefits rich people and they make the rules. But, what would a politician disingenuously cite as the public interest aligned justification for having these entities? Are there legitimate non-nefarious uses?
- ebiester 3y agoGame theory: Any country can do it, and the company in which the corporation is registered is not going to suffer. So what is their incentive not to allow it?
- dartos 3y agoIdeally it should be votes, but that doesn’t really work out like you’d want :(
- mkmk 3y agoI'm not very familiar with shell companies, so I'm curious – why isn't this just a matter of privacy for those involved? I'm generally pretty understanding of pro-privacy-oriented behavior.
- arrosenberg 3y agoOligarchs using transnational legal arbitrage to avoid paying taxes isn't a matter of privacy.
- tensor 3y agoNor is it due to the existence of shell companies. Rather it's due to poor enforcement and loopholes in tax law. You also don't need to make any of the information public to enforce it anymore than it's required to make your personal earning information public to enforce you paying taxes.
- arrosenberg 3y agoIt's hard to take that position seriously. The people using the loopholes are the ones that pushed to put them in the law and degraded enforcement budgets. One hand washes the other and it takes place in the dark. Let's put a little sunshine on it and see what happens. We might find some very interesting networks exist...
- itopaloglu83 3y agoI don’t know any other case where someone can own an entity like a house, car, estate, etc. where they get to hide who benefits from it.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoYou can hide ownership in real estate using land trusts in states that support them. You can fund an LLC with a vehicle to hide ownership of the vehicle by VIN or plate search. In both cases, startup costs are a few hundred dollars, and ~$100-200/year upkeep per asset. Trusts in general are simply good estate planning compared to probate costs, at least on the topic of real estate holdings and titling.
- mcguire 3y agoThose are essentially shell companies.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ensignavenger 3y agoNew Mexico has fairly decent LLC privacy and you don't have to pay an annual fee to upkeep your LLC at all. Just need to have a registered agent, which can be had for under 100/year.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoAppreciate the info!
- itopaloglu83 3y agoCould you elaborate on reasons to do so? Using LLC to limit liability makes sense, but I’m not familiar with hiding identity behind a corporation.
- micromacrofoot 3y agobecause it's a lot easier to have privacy when you're rich the default for normal people is for all of this data to be public unless you can either navigate bureaucracy (costs time and money) or pay someone to do it for you (costs money)
- digging 3y agoI'm quite big on privacy rights for indibviduals but I also feel that when corporate wealth (thus, influence on culture and politics) reaches a certain scale, radical levels of transparency become very important for the health of our society. For an extreme example, the public deserved (and still does) to know who were the individuals at Shell devising a decades-long misinformation campaign about climate change -- and that the bullshit they were hearing about climate change being fake was driven by nothing but greed. To address inevitable replies: No, I don't know exactly where the line is (or lines are - it should probably be a tiered system), and I recognize defining those lines is itself a position of immense power. Those are solvable problems though and don't make the idea bad. (It could still be a bad idea, but for other reasons.)
- truckerbill 3y agoIt's about the usage. No single dogma ever makes sense without context. These are abused by many to hide taxable wealth. It's in the public interest to understand what very powerful people are doing , because the public are usually getting the short end of the stick- this should override any ideology regarding 'privacy', 'freedom' and other fuzzy words (not that some interpretation of these things isn't also important)
- ensignavenger 3y agoIt is very much a matter of privacy for most folks doing it. And you don't have to particularly be rich to benefit from it.
- Veserv 3y agoNot all are bad, but they are frequently abused to not only protect privacy, but to protect against legitimate legal need. It is like hiring a contractor on your house who gives you a false name so they can skip out of town when you figure out they cheated you. There is no legitimate purpose for that degree of privacy. They wanted privacy for the express purpose of providing you no legal recourse. Pseudonymity is perfectly valid, but there needs to be efficient, effective, and crystal clear means to pierce it and find the actual humans making the decisions with intent when there is a legitimate and well-supported legal need.
- ensignavenger 3y agoCan you cite any research on just how frequent you mean by "frequently". It certainly happens sometimes, but I have found no evidence that is is the norm.
- Veserv 3y agoWhy does that matter? I said that pseudonymity is perfectly fine, there just needs to be a straightforward and effective means of piercing it when there are legitimate legal purposes. Are you arguing that because it is not a majority of cases that they should be impervious even if there are legitimate legal purposes? There are enough high profile cases of shell corporations being used for unsavory and explicitly illegal behavior, to the extent that it is literally a meme, such as the crimes unveiled in the Panama Papers [1] that simple and robust mechanisms to prevent abuse are warranted even if abuse is uncommon. It is not like being able to pierce the privacy with a court order is even some new mechanism, you can already do that, it is just expensive, time-consuming, and difficult if they fight. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Panama_Papers
- ensignavenger 3y agoThe cost of providing such mechanisms and properly securing them against abuse have to be weighed against the benefit. In order to know the benefit, we need to know the size of the problem we are seeking to solve, and whether or not the proposed system would actually solve the problem. So yes, knowing the size of the problem matters a lot, and is a good first step to running a cost benefit analysis.
- tensor 3y agoYes, privacy. Corporations are often used for trusts and investments. I wouldn't call those nefarious at all, though yes they are mostly only useful for more wealthy individuals. These structures all still pay taxes and are 100% legal. Arguments about tax law being good or bad are really a separate issue, and those should be addressed directly by updating the law, not erasing privacy for wealthy. As much as the wealthy rightly get shit on for various things, they are still entitled to the same rights as everyone else.
- lostlogin 3y ago> they are still entitled to the same rights as everyone else. Has there ever been a time when the wealthy had less rights than the poor? The speeding ticket fine which is charged as a percentage of ones wage comes to mind. https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/06/finnish-businessman-hit-with-121000-speeding-fine https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/jun/06/finnish-busine...
- vlovich123 3y agoThat’s not really less rights though. That’s like saying the rich have fewer rights under progressive taxation. And no, generally the more rich and/or powerful you are the more rights society provides you. Even countries which strive for more equality simply try to shore up the most egregious instances but there’s always a difference. That’s because not all rights matter equally to everyone. For example, rich and poor both don’t have the right to sleep on a park bench but in practice that right is only particularly relevant to one party.
- sdeframond 3y agoDo you mean that fining more for richer people is unfair? That's an interesting view. One could argue that a flat fine allows rich people to break the law more, because they can afford it. Which IMHO seems pretty unfair.
- lostlogin 3y agoI agree with it and think there should be more penalties like it.
- CPLX 3y agoNot every corporation is some wealthy shadow network. The owners of an abortion clinic, or a store that sells fur coats, or a therapy practice for the criminally mentally ill, all might have good reasons why they’d like additional privacy.
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoIt could also be a programmer who is within their legal right to start their own company, but who doesn't want their current employer harassing or singling them out for it. Further common situations involve trying to keep details out of the public record because they can be abused by bad actors; ones who may be looking to spam you, engage in a frivolous lawsuit, or personally harass you/your family. At least these are some of the scenarios mentioned by companies that do asset protection. Edit: In regards to harassment, think about the abuse retail, fast food, or other customer-facing employees endure for perceived slights. It feels easy to understand why average small business owners would want privacy and to keep things in legal channels. Personally, I think the government knowing who's in charge (Corporate Transparency Act) is a good halfway point, but it's not unrealistic to be concerned about leaks or abuse with that system.
- tetromino_ 3y agoAs a working class individual, you can get excellent financial privacy. You can stick your $10k in savings in cash in a glass jar behind your bed, and neither the government nor big banks nor investigative journalists get to know how much is in thar jar, and they have no say what you spend that money on and when. A more wealthy individual has no such privacy. Their wealth is not truly wealth and not truly theirs, it is fundamentally a trust-us IOU from a bank or a stockbroker which is shared with all kinds of parties, a publicly visible number on the screen which at any second could turn zero or negative on the orders of a corrupt official or due to a buggy algorithm or mistyped name on a sanctions list. The more wealthy individual yearns for a glass jar - but no jar is big enough to hold the sums the more wealthy individual operates with. Hence, shell companies.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Are there legitimate non-nefarious uses? Have you formed an entity? In Delaware it’s file and go. You don’t need a lawyer nor to fill out a bunch of paperwork. That’s efficient. Where we demand disclosure is when that entity touches money through the banking system.