5 ms·

But why use the web browser as local interface for it? Why not a separate, native application?

mdrzn 3y ago
If my data is already in the browser (Sheets, Gmail, other websites to scrape) why have another app instead of doing the work in the browser?
- some_furry 3y ago
  While we're at it, why not shove our financial passwords etc. into our HTTP headers for every website we visit? That would be awfully convenient. You'd never lose them or need to deal with another native application. Just open any web page that echoes all HTTP headers and then check your account balance. Or maybe having a separation of concerns for different applications in a general purpose computer is worth the friction.
  - foverzar 3y ago
    I don't get it.
shutupnerd0000 3y ago
You missed the joke
- notachatbot1234 3y ago
  I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. It seems that my information about the poster's intent was outdated or inaccurate. Upon further research, I have found that I misread the word "unnecessarily".
Zambyte 3y ago
Web browsers have become to Javascript what Emacs is to Elisp. It is an interactive, extensible, "everything application". The main difference is that right now, just about everyone with a computer uses a web browser. Personally I prefer to use a separate, dedicated service to run my language models, and I bounce between a few clients for various things. One of them is a (local) web interface (open-webui).
kaibee 3y ago
Why does the address bar go to a search engine? When you use an LLM, you provide it context. Where do you usually get that context from? Some service, JIRA, whatever, in your browser.
zamalek 3y ago
For the same reason that a netbook/Chromebook is probably enough for most people: users rarely install native apps on laptop form factors these days - apart from the "essentials" like an office suite, and possibly specific programs they use to get work done (image/video editors etc.). A browser is one thing that users will go out of their way to replace, making it a pretty attractive vehicle for stuff like this.

If my data is already in the browser (Sheets, Gmail, other websites to scrape) why have another app instead of doing the work in the browser?

some_furry 3y ago
While we're at it, why not shove our financial passwords etc. into our HTTP headers for every website we visit? That would be awfully convenient. You'd never lose them or need to deal with another native application. Just open any web page that echoes all HTTP headers and then check your account balance. Or maybe having a separation of concerns for different applications in a general purpose computer is worth the friction.
- foverzar 3y ago
  I don't get it.

shutupnerd0000 3y ago

You missed the joke

notachatbot1234 3y ago
I apologize for the mistake in my previous response. It seems that my information about the poster's intent was outdated or inaccurate. Upon further research, I have found that I misread the word "unnecessarily".

Zambyte 3y ago

Web browsers have become to Javascript what Emacs is to Elisp. It is an interactive, extensible, "everything application". The main difference is that right now, just about everyone with a computer uses a web browser. Personally I prefer to use a separate, dedicated service to run my language models, and I bounce between a few clients for various things. One of them is a (local) web interface (open-webui).

kaibee 3y ago

Why does the address bar go to a search engine? When you use an LLM, you provide it context. Where do you usually get that context from? Some service, JIRA, whatever, in your browser.

zamalek 3y ago

For the same reason that a netbook/Chromebook is probably enough for most people: users rarely install native apps on laptop form factors these days - apart from the "essentials" like an office suite, and possibly specific programs they use to get work done (image/video editors etc.). A browser is one thing that users will go out of their way to replace, making it a pretty attractive vehicle for stuff like this.