10 ms·
A first look at Europe's alternative iPhone app stores
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nickburns 3y agothat it's taken this long for an iOS clipboard manager (using obvious SDK controls) is nutty.
- gnyman 3y agoAgree, and the fact that apple can still enforce an obviously inefficient and stupid workaround is even nuttier. > The first version I tried used the user’s location to remain active, but was rejected by Apple. Testut then updated Clip with a Map feature — so there’s a reason for the app to remain active in the background — to receive approval. Yes, I'll admit that I prefer some limitations on background processes in order to preserve my battery. But apple is not doing that, instead they allow it but only after the app adds some pretend functionality which makes the user experience worse for everyone. And let's think about how many pointless background processes they themselves have added over the years, it seems that every patch level there is a bunch more.
- nickburns 3y agothey allow it but only after the app adds some pretend functionality which makes the user experience worse for everyone. or nefariously worse. how curious that "verification" is extended only after the app implements a location 'ping', which is inevitably reported to or observed by the system. the more i think about it, i honestly wonder if it hasn't taken this long because Apple's been reluctant to reveal and therefore open up to public scrutiny any sense of what the system does with clipboard functionality and/or its contents 'behind the scenes.'
- nickpp 3y agoThe fact that I don't have to worry if the newfangled clipboard manager my grandma was tricked into installing is sending the passwords she is copy&paste-ing to a server in China is wonderful.
- nickburns 3y agoconsider grandparental controls for your nan. much better to have control than give it up. good god man, help her!
- nickpp 3y agoI have parental control for my children and they sidestep it every day. Suggesting that to my nan would get my ass kicked.
- jamil7 3y agoIt seems like "think of the grandmas" is the new "think of the children" line.
- Rinzler89 3y agoI wish people using the Grandma argument for security would provide some statistics on how many grandmas got hacked and robbed from side loading android apps before trying to die on that hill for Apple.
- cjk2 3y agoBoth my father and my mother got their banks ripped off by keyloggers on both an android handset and a windows computer separate occasions. They have been divorced for 30 years and do not even live near or speak to each other. The only thing that keeps them safe these days is iOS.
- Rinzler89 3y agoThat sounds terrible indeed, I'm sorry to hear that, but anecdotes don't make a statistic. For example my parents had always been tech illiterate android and windows users and never got hacked or robbed online. >The only thing that keeps them safe these days is iOS. BS. If a resourceful and motivated actor wants to phish your credentials they can do it even if you use iOS as well. They can call you and impersonate your bank. They don't need to get privilege escalation on your phone's OS.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jocoda 3y agoI have no interest in distributing IOS apps but I would like to be able to install and run my own code on IOS. Right now I can install my own code on my iPhone but if I don't have a Apple developer account Apple will remove apps after a week. And presumably when the account lapses, so does the install. How, if at all, are these Apple restrictions affected? Are we still stuck in the thrall of Apple or do we get more options? Maybe one day that could make it possible to install projects directly from github. I suspect that there are thousands of interesting projects on the Apple Store that you can't find unless you know exactly what they are called because for obvious reasons the App Store search is a POS. Github would be a much more useful source of the apps that Apple doesn't profit from.
- shaunkoh 3y agoAltServer from the AltStore folks allows you to automate the renewal of sideloaded apps. It’s not perfect, but it’s an excellent workaround. http://altstore.io/ http://altstore.io/
- extraduder_ire 3y agoAn app called "reprovision" can do the same on an iOS device, without requiring a copy of altserver running. I haven't used it since 2021 when I used it for signing a jailbreak app, and development has stalled since then, but it worked for me.
- dadoum 3y agoYou can also use SideStore which can do the same without a server.
- dagmx 3y ago> How, if at all, are these Apple restrictions affected? They are completely unaffected by the DMA. The only exception might be if another store decides to allow sharing of signing keys across apps they host, however one bad actor could take down the entire set of keys used if flagged.
- emsy 3y ago
- uyzstvqs 3y agoAFAIK this is just Apple-approved apps, just through another app and servers. How does this change anything? Apple still has full control over what apps users can install. There is no side-loading. They still need to approve every app on third party platforms. Or has Apple actually decided to remove app signing? They sure didn't when they announced this change.
- dagmx 3y agoThese are Apple notarized apps. As with macOS, they still have to both be signed and go through some verification , but they don’t apply any of the other App Store rules to it.
- themoonisachees 3y agoWell, except that they do. TFA says that the clipboard app in question had to include a map because it requires a dirty workaround to stay active in the background, at apple's demands. Yes, they're not "app store rules" and they're "notarization rules" but the end result is the same, they could choose to make those rules the same and yeah maybe a European court could force them to comply but in reality land apple has more money and lawyers than god.
- dagmx 3y agoYou’re conflating two things. There’s App Store rules and then there’s system rules (security, multitasking etc). The DMA only side steps the former not the latter. The issue in the article is the latter.
- themoonisachees 3y agoSure, but as long as apple will play hardball like they're clearly doing, they could very well enforce app store rules as app signing rules and it'd be years before the eu would force them to stop, not even counting on the fact that current app signing rules are already insane.
- 3y ago
- VagabundoP 3y agoI was hoping for something similar to f-droid for iPads when this all shook out. But alas not to be. The vast majority of Android tablets seem to suck for some reason.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 3y agoOnly for now. This is a brazen bad faith effort at compliance and the EU courts will see right through. Apple would not be the first FAANG to make multi €B donations to the EU budget.
- resource_waste 3y agoThink of the bright side, at least Android users finally get some competition so Android has to try harder. For so long Android was the only place to get widgets. Finally iphone has them. Now they are going to have multiple stores! If they sold iphones with aux ports, they might even convince me. (Probably not, Apple's security record is abysmal and I have an expensive secret on my phone)
- Animats 3y agoThe Verge: "Whether it’s security, user privacy, app updates, fraud protection, or refunds, you feel confident that Apple has it under control on the App Store." Oh, yeah?[1] [1] https://www.techradar.com/news/these-dangerous-scam-ios-apps-are-still-lurking-on-the-app-store https://www.techradar.com/news/these-dangerous-scam-ios-apps...
- ktosobcy 3y ago> Currently, the new version of AltStore is deep in Apple’s approval process and will be ready to go live once it gets the thumbs up from the company. I do hope that EU will push harder and we will be able to install anything we want (even alternative stores) without blessing from greedy mega-corp...
- robertfall 3y agoWhat I don't understand is why people keep using Apple? There are already platforms that allow this. Use them!
- whywhywhywhy 3y agoThe user experience is just that much better that they choose it over other things.
- _factor 3y agoApple does a lot of things right, for better or worse. Want copy paste? It’s consistent across the whole system because you have one choice. You don’t have to guess how the pop up is going to work beyond context. Other more open platforms get messy and fragmented hoping the developer chose a good implementation. Want encrypted messaging? Easy, just talk to other iPhones. Want less infection risk? Live in Apple’s walled garden. I get less calls from grandparents asking for iOS assistance than Android, the interface is more intuitively laid out. Have years of apps purchased with no way to transfer without paying again? You’re probably not switching.
- happymellon 3y agoI'm pretty sure I have a consistent copy/paste experience on my Fedora laptop, despite it being "open". Do you have examples of a "fragmented experience"? > I get less calls from grandparents asking for iOS assistance than Android, the interface is more intuitively laid out. I'm trying to think of a time that either my parents or grandparents called for support on Android. On iOS I've had plenty of questions posed, though usually because Apple don't want people to get WhatsApp notifications, for example.
- tgv 3y agoWouldn't Nintendo be going to go after Altstore? It seems a likely win.
- hakdbha 3y agoEuropean iPhones will have more freedom than American iPhones. Amazing
- grumpyprole 3y agoWell I guess there's more freedom in the US for Apple to do whatever they like!
- nickburns 3y agoat least some of Apple's chickens would finally appear to be coming home to roost, and us in-the-know Americans appreciate those in-the-know Europeans for leading the charge (on both this antitrust protection and separately, GDPR/privacy regulation as well).
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- shiroiushi 3y agoThe Europeans have done some good work on things like privacy, but as for Apple and their app store, it's really trivial to simply not buy an iPhone. There are lots and lots of other phones out there that aren't nearly as monopolistic in their treatment of users.
- nickburns 3y agowe're talking about trust busting, not personal device options or preference.
- shiroiushi 3y agoAgain, Apple does not have a monopoly, or anything approaching it. 50% marketshare is a lot for a single vendor, but it's not even close to 100%, and there are plenty of viable alternatives which apparently a lot of people don't want to consider because it isn't "cool" enough for them.
- difosfor 3y agoI wonder if/when real versions of Chrome and Firefox will become available through these stores. Or would that still not be allowed without using Safari WebKit as the base?
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39907488 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39907488