3 ms·
> Courts have ruled that code is protected under the 1st Amendment because it is something created by human beings, and expresses the ideas and style of its hum
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Courts have ruled that code is protected under the 1st Amendment because it is something created by human beings, and expresses the ideas and style of its human authors.
They’ve also allowed non-content-based restrictions of that speech under intermediate scrutiny, and content-based restrictions under strict scrutiny, so that LLMs might be within the scope of things to which 1A protection applies does not mean that restrictions on distributing open LLM weights would necessarily violate the 1A.
- skissane 3y agoI agree. I just posted a reply to a sibling comment saying the same. I personally think the odds are decent that content-neutral parameter size-based distribution restrictions will be upheld under intermediate scrutiny. Personally I am opposed to such restrictions and think they are a stupid mistake, but I can separate my own feelings about a topic from how SCOTUS is likely to perceive it Whereas, I’m sceptical that any content-based regulations (require LLMs to have safeguards to prevent them from generating disinformation, extremism, hate speech, etc) will survive strict scrutiny. Even if there is some category of content which is so horrible that SCOTUS will conclude the government is justified in restricting LLMs from producing it, it is basically technically impossible to design safeguards that only apply to that horrible content without collateral damage on less horrible content. Given that reality, I doubt any content-based LLM restrictions will be upheld