3 ms·
> If you did some kind of shell game with 5 different people all passing around their items, then you don’t get charged correctly is it theft? IANAL but I'm co
by Terr_ 3y ago
> If you did some kind of shell game with 5 different people all passing around their items, then you don’t get charged correctly is it theft?
IANAL but I'm confident the legal answer is "yes", the same as if someone was using sleight-of-hand with objects at a cashier-and-conveyor-belt checkout station.
Whether charges are brought and how easily the case can be proved is another matter, but the intent is what makes it a crime.
- pcchristie 3y agoI thought one of the marketing lines was that Amazon was so confident/comfortable in their implementation was that they assumed all liability for mistakes (though as I type this I realise they may have worded it to encapsulate only honest mistakes rather than people trying deliberately to break the system).
- lupire 3y agoBeing forgiven doesn't make it not a crime, or just reduces the chance of enforcement.
- Terr_ 3y ago> they assumed all liability for mistakes To get a little pedantic, assuming such a promise existed, it actually doesn't mean as much as most people think. A merchant saying "we won't sue you in civil court for the missing money" does not prevent the local government from criminally prosecuting that same person for theft. American TV dramas often show the police asking people "Do you want to press charges?", but the idea that the question matters is a myth, since victims of crime don't get to decide that. At best, it's a terribly misleading shortening of: "Just for my own private curiosity, do you plan to lobby or press upon your local government officials into pressing charges?"
- astura 3y ago>though as I type this I realise they may have worded it to encapsulate only honest mistakes rather than people trying deliberately to break the system Exactly. Retailers generally assume liability for honest mistakes made by their system/employees and sometimes even their customers. However, when people knowingly exploit a loophole for financial gain it becomes fraud. Here's a real example - https://www.wfmynews2.com/article/news/local/greensboro-woman-pleads-guilty-to-qvc-scam/83-402367135 https://www.wfmynews2.com/article/news/local/greensboro-woma...
- idontwantthis 3y agoIt sounds different to me because each person can say they were just trying to buy the items they walked out with and didn’t get charged. Like if you scan an item at self checkout and the machine says it’s free, that’s not going to be theft. At least I sure hope not.