3 ms·
Yes, it hinders competition for cloud hosting in certain ways. Someone could set up a separate hosting service for it as long as they made their supporting cod
by graemep 3y ago
Yes, it hinders competition for cloud hosting in certain ways.
Someone could set up a separate hosting service for it as long as they made their supporting code FOSS too.
It also lets you self host, including on a cloud platform.
The rules for hosting SSPL software, are not very different from those for distributing GPL software. It certainly seems to be in the same spirit as someone offering software under GPL with a proprietary alternative.
What I do think is unfair is when there is an element of bait and switch.
> Alternatively, had I chosen MySQL or Postgres, well established DBMS not built by startups with a single product
That was how MySQL started, IIRC?
- newzisforsukas 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MySQL_AB https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MySQL_AB
- arielcostas 3y ago> Someone could set up a separate hosting service for it as long as they made their supporting code FOSS too. Isn't this more-or-less what the AGPL does? Allow hosting for others, but sharing the server-side code. I get that big providers aren't happy by this for multiple reasons, though > The rules for hosting SSPL software, are not very different from those for distributing GPL software They are in the way that they forbid you from competing with them. For a GPL program, I could build my own redistribution (see Linux distros consisting on packaging and distributing software made by others) > That was how MySQL started, IIRC? Actually, it seems so, but they used the GPL instead of BSD, and based their business on support and dual-licencing, and was later on bought by Sun/Oracle, being just one of their products and not their only product, like Redis or MongoDB.
- pizza234 3y ago> What I do think is unfair is when there is an element of bait and switch. What's the bait? The expectation to get free development and support forever? The pre-switch Redis code is still BSD licensed, that can't be changed. Additionally, using SSPL licensed code doesn't concretely change anything for essentially any end user/developer besides BigCos - which are free to use and hack Redis at will as before. As a matter of fact, almost all those who complained about the license change on HN, are actually not affected.