7 ms·
AltStore to offer iPhone apps backed by Patreon in the EU
- dlivingston 3y agoI think in ~5 years, after all of the fine details shake out and 3rd party app stores are common across the globe, it will be very exciting to be an indie iOS developer. Open source or demo or hobby apps really don't exist on iOS because the barrier to usage is too high (dev must upload to App Store, or user must compile from source / get an .IPA & sign w/ an Apple Developer Certificate, or convoluted sideloading techniques must be used). Native terminals & package managers & IDEs... the iPad could turn into an amazing development machine, despite Apple's best efforts to the contrary.
- drewg123 3y agoIs the virtualization framework available on iOS/iPad? That would make the iPad into a killer dev platform if so.
- kmeisthax 3y agoNo, but Apple could enable it in like 10 seconds if they so chose.
- cglong 3y agoIt's going to be interesting watching Apple's strategy unfold over the next few years. If third party stores prove wildly popular in the EU, then what? If people worldwide start demanding parity, how will Apple respond? Will they oblige or dig their heels further into the sand?
- tiltowait 3y agoGiven Apple’s recent history, I’m betting dig in their heels—which I think is a bad strategy, so I hope I’m wrong. They’ve brought this regulation on themselves with their unnecessarily ham-handed actions. People—even big Apple fans—have been calling it for years. It’s been frustrating to see so many unforced errors.
- lancesells 3y agoDig in their heels and watch other parts of the business get even more agressive. More ads in iOS settings and the App Store. More notifications for their products and ecosystem. I can see it in them making the TV app the only way to watch your media. Now I'm subject to their TV+ advertisements whenever I want to watch my iTunes purchases. I can look up a comedy show in their store and the "related" shows are TV+ before everything else. It's like they're hiring from Amazon Prime TV or something. I honestly don't update my tvOS because it seems to be gets worse in content and having strange UX choices.
- thejohnconway 3y agoI hope they give up on the App Store as a significant income stream. It's a terrible strategy tax, and pretty gross and un-apple-like (the old Apple anyway). Everything is "free" except for predatory in-app purchases, so you can't tell how much anything really costs. It's full of gambling type games that kids play. The apps at the top of searches are often just garbage, and the truly capable apps are very few and far between, or don't exist because of sandboxing. What I want from apple if they are going to have an App Store is a curated collection of Apps that are good, and aren't scummy, and yes, often expensive. You can chose to use it or not, but if you want the best app, go there.
- quitit 3y agoJust a few thoughts: 1. Are 3rd party stores popular on Android? How about preinstalled vendor-run stores such as the Samsung Galaxy Store? 2. Small developers are the primary beneficiary of unified stores. On the desktop Steam is a good example of that, while large developers can afford the costs of generating direct sales via ATL marketing and support, small developers largely rely on in-store discovery/visibility to reach a larger audience. 3. However a Steam-like store hasn't eventuated on Android likely because Google's store is already good enough. Steam largely benefits from being early and maintains that position despite the numerous copycat stores having compelling offers (e.g. the Epic store is largely a dud despite regularly giving away popular gaming titles.) 4. If the final legislated position for Apple's App Store is simply to be a Steam-esque add-on store, i.e. merely a place of convenience but not at all necessary, Apple will no longer be beholden to accomodating hostile competitors. 5. The EU is still discovering how they can balance strict control versus existing commercial freedoms, and we're about to see this play out with Facebook. Since the EU has suggested that Facebook cannot charge for an Ad-free tier. Which has a few obvious run on implications, i.e. that a company cannot set the price of their own product and ad-supported "free" services (such as Google, etc.) are not in compliance. 6. Don't expect any of the "gatekeepers" to self-regulate their actions, because they can't read the mind of the EU. Instead they'll now sit and wait to be told what to do. All of these thoughts obviously point in different directions, but there are some themes that apply to all of them. 1. Large software developers are pushing for independent stores because it benefits them, and protects them from disruption from emergent competitors. 2. Small developers will still need to rely on hive/halo visibility (i.e. Steam, Google Play, Apple App Store). Even though this costs them more than direct sales. 3. Either Apple has no control and thus no responsibility, or they have full control and can wield that against hostile competitors. There is no scenario where Apple has no control and full responsibility. 4. People don't like that last point, and that mental disconnect is on display - but that's where all of this takes us. It's a case of careful what you wish for.
- cglong 3y agoRemember the DMA is also targeting Google. I find it interesting that Epic didn't even bother with an Android store until now.
- dagmx 3y agoAll the things you listed aren’t blocked by the App Store. They’re system level restrictions based on the security model (whether or not one agrees with them) Today you can already find terminals and IDEs in the App Store beholden to those restrictions.
- lukeschlather 3y agoThe DMA also prohibits companies from placing restrictions on third-party apps that don't apply to their own apps. So if any first-party Apple apps can ignore these "security restrictions" then Apple may have some compliance issues that force them to remove the restrictions.
- theluketaylor 3y agoBut the DMA also requires (not just allows) platform owners to maintain the security of their platform. Many of the security model restrictions for iOS that app developers bump into are unlikely to be lifted by Apple. Most of the places Apple has given themselves special powers is mostly a shortcut to avoid the hard work of a publicly accessible API and entitlements. Not always, sometimes it really is them favouring themselves, but I'd say that's the exception rather than a rule. I'm guessing Apple will mostly do the legwork to create entitlements and APIs and transition the Apple apps rather than actually remove the restriction. This will result in some types of apps that are currently not allowed being possible, but I think it's going to be a lot fewer use cases than people think. For example, I don't see side loaded NES emulators being allowed to have a JIT.
- cglong 3y ago> For example, I don't see side loaded NES emulators being allowed to have a JIT. Why not? If third-party browsers are allowed to have a JIT, why couldn't an emulator?
- theluketaylor 3y agoApple has a slam dunk case to place a ton of barriers on browser vendors being allowed to JIT code due to the risk to the rest of the platform and the user's data. Little emulators for NES and Sega Genesis are not going to meet those barriers and Apple will have a pretty easy time excluding them under the security provision. Dev environments like VS Code will be more interesting. I suspect Apple will choose to build a VM layer to execute complied code inside an even deeper sandbox rather than allowing execution directly inside the iOS layer, thereby severely limiting what a binary complied on device is able to interact with. This would almost certainly be hidden behind an entitlement that Apple will be try to be allowed to gatekeep under the DMA requirement to maintain platform security.
- oorza 3y agoI haven't thought much about this, but given the historic failure of alternative app stores to gain traction in Android, what makes you think this will change? Hardly anyone I know outside of tech circles (and some within them) are even aware that alternative web browsers are an option for their phone, let alone alternative app stores. I think best case is sites like itch.io and Patreon have dedicated app stores that funnel more money to creators and it's easy enough to manage having multiple active app sources on your phone, but they will always have a very small niche market compared to Apple or Google. Even Amazon hasn't been able to eat away at the defaults' market share. The most viable path I can see to getting alternative app stores as a common scenario and user expectation is basically just... Steam. But mobile gaming is such a flaming shit show, I don't know if that will ever happen. Something like Steam getting traction on smartphones would absolutely help change that problem though.
- doctorpangloss 3y ago> Open source or demo or hobby apps really don't exist on iOS because the barrier to usage is too high Every credible developer I’ve talked to is not hung up on item 1,000 of 10,000 they have to do to develop software. Steam also has a lot of requirements. The issue is the store is shit, discoverability is the worst of any platform. Steam is great for discoverability. Indie developers can thrive if the stores are better designed.
- traverseda 3y agoThis might actually drag me into the apple ecosystem. It's a nice ecosystem, it's largely POSIX compliant, but to get the most out of it you should be using IOS devices, and that's just too locked down for me.
- nikodunk 3y agoThis is the first time I've been excited about the future of mobile computing in a while. It's also the first time I've read an article on MacRumors in a while. I really hope a few of these early experiments work out, and wish them luck!
- guywithabike 3y agoI'm just not looking forward to the inevitable subscription billing dark patterns that are almost guaranteed to be rife in alternative app stores. Call to unsubscribe, early cancellation fees, unsubscribe "errors", etc. Say what you want about the App Store, but the fact that you can quickly and easily see all your subscriptions in one place along with how much they cost and the ability to cancel them easily is incredibly nice.
- lukeschlather 3y agoThe exciting thing will be a real open source repository. An entire app source with no dark patterns of any kind.
- grishka 3y agoBut then there's the flip side of how inflexible the app store subscriptions are: https://www.hey.com/apple/iap/ https://www.hey.com/apple/iap/
- oktoberpaard 3y agoIf those stores comply with EU law, that shouldn’t be the case. See for example https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_22_4186 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/ip_22_.... I can see how stores will pop up that don’t care about laws and regulations, but I would be hesitant to pay for anything there.
- kmlx 3y agohave you seen spotify’s new app in europe? https://newsroom.spotify.com/2024-01-24/the-dma-means-a-better-spotify-for-artists-creators-and-you/ https://newsroom.spotify.com/2024-01-24/the-dma-means-a-bett... they pushed hard for apple to open up in order push more ads.
- kmeisthax 3y agoThis is absolutely great and Riley Testut deserves a medal. However, I'm fully expecting Apple to pull some bullshit along the way, like either demanding Riley stop supporting AltStore Server[0] or demanding he not distribute unsigned binaries period. Apple is hellbent on "containing" third-party distribution by any means necessary. They implemented frameworks for region detection specifically so the iPhone can stop complying and shut off your third-party apps if you travel. They tried to kick Tim Sweeney out of the app distribution market before he even began, for the crime of... opening his mouth[1]. Riley hasn't been as insubordinate as Tim, but he has actively been involved in app distribution, and that is even more of a threat to Apple than mean tweets. [0] A Windows/macOS application that resigns applications for sideloading and makes remote debugger requests to enable JIT on-device. It notably requires your iCloud password to get your signing certs, which almost certainly already violates something in Apple's terms even if it's otherwise entirely legal. [1] Casual reminder that the entire tech industry is opposed to freedom of speech, except when it's far-right radicals like Elon Musk trying to redefine freedom of speech as freedom of slurs.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoThere's an app called reprovision that can do the signing on device. (it also needs to sign itself, so that uses up one of your free slots) IIRC, when I used it any icloud login worked for signing, not just the one tied to the phone.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoWhat Apple wants and what they get are two things. At this point, there's a significant risk that their attempts to contain this will backfire and will result in even more unfavorable rules. The mood here in the EU is not in favor of entertaining their bullshit. There is not a lot of sympathy for Apple here. Rulings against them are fairly uncontroversial. There's also the notion that the continued negative press around Apple's anti competitive behavior is going to have an effect on their competitive position. Iphone marketshare in the EU is much smaller than that in the US. They don't have as tight a grip on the market. Things like Facetime or Apple messenger aren't widely used because they don't work with other phones and lots of people have those, which makes using these apps impractical. And this stuff will likely spill over to other regions. Once Apple shows they can grudgingly behave a bit nicer in the EU, other countries are going to insist on the same. China already does that of course. Apple sells iphones there. But with a Chinese appstore, Chinese maps, and under very strict Chinese laws. And of course this stuff might eventually come back to the US where people might rightly wonder why they have to be nannied by Apple.
- Alifatisk 3y agoIs this the return of third-party stores we had back in the days? Remember Tutuapp, Altstore and many others for non-jailbroken devices?
- thih9 3y agoHow does it compare from the point of security? Does an app installed via a non-Apple app store can access more on my device for some reason? E.g. because it uses undocumented APIs that wouldn’t be allowed on the regular App Store?
- RandallBrown 3y agoYes. That's why there are several massive warning dialogs when installing apps from alternate stores.
- kranke155 3y agoIt would be ironic if the open app store would create an european app develoment renaissance. New apps on iOS, Europe only, built for european standards by european developers.
- alberth 3y agoWeb At times, I feel like I’m only person who makes SaaS app for mobile, but on the Web (no App Store need).
- difosfor 3y agoI wonder if/when real versions of Chrome and Firefox will become available through these stores. Or would that still not be allowed without using Safari WebKit as the base?