3 ms·
I think its not a good idea to teach the statistics and model of I.Q. and not teach the socialised history of its (mis)application. Science and society are inex
by ggm 3y ago
I think its not a good idea to teach the statistics and model of I.Q. and not teach the socialised history of its (mis)application. Science and society are inexorably interlinked and there is probably no field of human endeavour which does not have downsides, which therefore need to be discussed in learning about that field. I do not believe I.Q. is any different in that regard.
The relationship of I.Q. to the eugenics movement, its application to social policy justifying the sterilisation of people at the low extreme, to exclude immigrants, to argue for substantive racial differences justifying laws of exclusion and difference, I really don't think can be ignored.
"Importance" is in the eye of the beholder I find. If it's not important to you, so be it. I don't doubt there is a model of intelligence which an I.Q. test can try to quantify but I doubt intelligence a singleton, is quantifiable so simply, or based on the evidence to hand that rules based on the statistics of intelligence do very much good.
- noch 3y ago> Science and society are inexorably interlinked and there is probably no field of human endeavour which does not have downsides Ha! You're definitely not 62. This is something high schoolers and undergrads say and think is a profound and true observation but it's trivial. An exercise: Try saying "there is probably no field of curing cancer which does not have downsides" > Importance" is in the eye of the beholder I find. No it isn't. Moral relativism will not get you far, which is what life teaches. The whole point of education is to learn to discern an objective hierarchy of importance. E.g. play video games or study for test. We then say "that person has good judgement" when they can consistently figure out what is truly important which allows them to make progress in life. The reason political battles, even if frequently silly, are so heated is because people do believe certain values are absolutely more important than those of their opponents and are willing to fight for them. Anyway, now we're digressing. But thanks for the conversation and have a good week.