9 ms·
Google to delete records from Incognito tracking
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y ago[flagged]
- rsstack 3y agoI'm sure everything was already sold to a third-party that will lease it back to Google for "research purposes".
- vkou 3y agoLarge ad firms don't tend to sell, or 'sell' that data, for five reasons. 1. The data is your competitive advantage, and costs billions of dollars to gather. You would be insane to sell it to someone else. 2. Regulatory. GDPR will absolutely destroy you for doing this. 3. Technical. Most targeted advertising relies on low-latency pipelines, with a lag time from minutes, to, at most, days between events being recorded, and ad targeting engines reacting to the event. You aren't going to sit around waiting for some third-party integration to 'launder' the data for you (Because it won't actually help you against regulatory scrutiny). 4. Practical. Ask people who have actually worked on these systems. Building it that way would be a fucking nightmare, both technically, and for the compliance pain. Or, if you don't believe anyone, get a job at a large ad firm, and see for yourself... That there isn't any such Rube Goldberg contraption. 5. Even if, against all judgement, all of this happened, a large firm can't keep this a secret for very long, there's way too many moving parts, way too many people involved, and someone on the periphery will whistleblow, and the firm will be in a mountain of legal shit.
- rsstack 3y agoPoints 1 & 3 & 4 are less important when you know you're in the process of negotiating a settlement for a class action suit where you will likely lose access the the data. And yes, I worked in AdTech. People really overestimate how many people need to know these things, and how likely people are to whistleblow when the "crimes" are morally grey.
- vkou 3y ago> People really overestimate how many people need to know these things If there's a giant friggin' third-party endpoint feeding your engine a firehose of data that the firm's whole business relies on, everyone will know about it. These systems are held together with spit and bailing wire, everything breaks all the time, everything's idiosyncrasies have to be worked around all the time, and all of the component behaviors have to be well-documented for integration and testing and release and design purposes. This might fly in a small shop, not so much in one with thousands and tens of thousands of eyes involved. The bigger you get, the harder it is to keep a secret.
- rsstack 3y ago> If there's a giant friggin' third-party endpoint feeding your engine a firehose of data that the firm's whole business relies on, everyone will know about it. But they won't know where that third-party's data came from.
- shadowgovt 3y agoOccam's razor suggests that they were to go to that much trouble, it would be much easier to just keep the data and pretend to delete it. But there are very solid reasons that isn't what they would do (see "It's impossible to keep a secret of that scale in a 100,000 person firm").
- Cheer2171 3y agoIt would be hard to keep that a secret inside Google, given the potential rewards to a whistleblower. This is a formal legal settlement that is on regulators' radar. It just takes one whistleblower to tell, and that whistleblower would make 10-30% of the hundreds of millions of dollars in potential fines Google was facing.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y ago> that whistleblower would make 10-30% of the hundreds of millions of dollars in potential fines Google was facing. citation needed I know whistleblower rewards exist in tax cases, but in almost every other case I'm aware of, the only "reward" whistleblowers get is losing their career and highly paid job + becoming unhireable.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Syonyk 3y ago> "We are pleased to settle this lawsuit, which we always believed was meritless," Google spokesman Jorge Castaneda said in a statement, noting that the company would not be paying any damages. > "We are happy to delete old technical data that was never associated with an individual and was never used for any form of personalization." In other words, "We've already processed the raw data into the useful forms we want, so, sure, we'll delete the raw stuff to make you happy now!"
- htrp 3y agoAI model has already been trained
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- shadowgovt 3y agoYou're catching down votes but this is almost certainly accurate. A lot of that data is almost certainly not very useful beyond a one to three month time window. Google can you use traffic data on search to keep tabs on trending topics, tune the algorithm against new human behaviors, and other time boxed benefits. There isn't a lot of use for data that's 6 months old in this context.
- summerlight 3y agoFor those who believe that "incognito" is actually something private and secret, no it is not and was never meant to be! It still can access the major part of your personal configuration and history, mostly for a convenience purpose. Its main purpose is to stop appending more data there, not to hide you. If you really want to keep your browsing private, you should be using guest mode.
- dspillett 3y ago> guest mode Or a completely separate browser. Or at least a separate profile.
- skybrian 3y agoThis is a pretty vague warning. What part of your "personal configuration and history" becomes available to websites in Incognito mode? Where did you learn this?
- jeffbee 3y agoWhich part strikes you as vague? """Others who use this device won’t see your activity.""" Seems like plain language to me. Anyone who thought this feature was hiding them from the websites they were visiting simply imagined that.
- skybrian 3y agoI can't tell what they're warning that websites are doing. Let's say I'm running a website. What information do I get from a browser that's running in incognito mode? "Personal configuration and activity": where in the HTTP request or JavaScript API is that? What data are we talking about? IP address, obviously, but that's not news. Or is this about browser fingerprinting?
- kccqzy 3y agoYou get nothing. No cookies no previous local storage. The whole point of Incognito is just that. Personal configuration: for example a website can query whether a user prefers dark mode or light mode. Incognito browsing doesn't attempt to hide that. Or consider that you have a fairly unique browser window size accessible using window.{inner,outer}{Width,Height}. Incognito also doesn't hide it from websites. None of this is inherently newsworthy. It's only newsworthy because people misunderstood Incognito and filed a lawsuit. I'd say that people seemed to have mixed up the privacy offered by the Tor browser and the privacy offered by Incognito at some point.
- DueDilligence 3y ago[dead]
- nancyp 3y agoChrome is good browser, Google is evil. Ungoogled chromium is a project that removes all reference to Google. Bit tricky to get the extensions work, but once it's setup works like charm.
- supposemaybe 3y ago[flagged]
- shadowgovt 3y agoIncognito mode stops the browser from logging information about its use to the local machine. There is no technical mechanism for preventing servers on the internet from logging the fact that a client connected to them, or logging every piece of information the client is willing to divulge for that server.
- nox101 3y agoNo, they were recording data from every user in any browser that accessed google.com and their other sites. That behavior is normal for the majority of sites on the internet. AFAICT, reading the article, Google is going to stop collecting data from all browsers/machines that connect to their websites and only collect data from browsers/machines that are logged in to a google account. Further, they are deleting data saved from browser/machines that were not logged in. Users that were using incognito-mode are a subset of all users that use their sites that are not logged in. In general, a website can not distinguish between a user in incognito-mode and a user not logged in except in that, a user not logged in but using a non-incognito mode would have manually clear their cache, cookies, local storage, etc where as in incognito-mode that is done automatically when you close the last tab.
- imadierich 3y ago[dead]
- djbusby 3y agoThis is why I make specific profiles for all kinds of things in chrome & Firefox. I've got a little wrapper for browser-launch that lets me pick. It's a unique `--user-data-dir` and the like. I've got about 100 right now. Unique to project, or use-case or special command line (eg using mitmproxy).
- rezonant 3y agoThe funny part about this whole thing is that Google actively works to ensure that websites cannot tell that you are in Incognito mode. For instance, see [1] If Google servers have a way to detect that a request arrives using Incognito mode, then so does everyone else, which means its a bug that Google needs to fix. And if we assume that a server cannot tell you are in Incognito mode (specifically), then there is no way to turn off the normal tracking mechanisms that a website might employ. This is one of those things where it sounds like a good idea to tell websites to not track users who use Incognito, but in practice that would actually be a bad idea, because then websites would constantly tell you that you are not allowed to browse their site in Incognito, and thus no one would use it... Now, the kind of tracking that would work across independent Incognito sessions would be user fingerprinting, and using fingerprinting to bypass the desire of a user to shake off being associated with an identity is shady behavior. If the lawsuit is alleging that Google is using fingerprinting techniques to associate traffic without cookies to a common identity, well then why aren't they suing them for that? That's bad whether you use Incognito or not. The whole thing is pretty dumb. Also interesting: Assuming that Google indeed cannot tell server-side whether you are in Incognito mode, exactly what are they deleting as part of this settlement? The article does have a quote: "We are happy to delete old technical data that was never associated with an individual and was never used for any form of personalization." I guess this means Google is just deleting old data that they were unable to associate with a person, but the entire claim was that Google was associating Incognito traffic together with a person's non-Incognito traffic- so effectively Google is doing nothing here. And yet I'm not sure what they could do. [1] https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/google-news-initiative/protecting-private-browsing-chrome/ https://blog.google/outreach-initiatives/google-news-initiat...
- Terretta 3y ago> well then why aren't they suing them for that? Because “they” already sued Google for misleading average people not on HN, and Google already lost. > The whole thing is pretty dumb. Indeed, fully half of Google's users are below average.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y ago""We are pleased to settle this lawsuit, which we always believed was meritless," Google spokesman Jorge Castaneda said in a statement, noting that the company would not be paying any damages." The case was Brown v. Google. The filing below has a decent summary of the case. Google's spokesperson claims Google "believed [the suit] was meritless" but at the same time Google chose to settle. Are the company's actions congruent with its alleged beliefs. Will settling "meritless" claims lead to more "meritless" claims in the future. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.360374/gov.uscourts.cand.360374.1096.0_1.pdf https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.cand.36... Google's spokesperson notes that "Google would not be paying any damages". However Google will be paying the plaintiffs lawyers' fees, costs and service awards; was this litigation inexpensive. Moreover, Google can still be sued for damages for wiretapping by the individual plaintiffs. For example, a first batch of 50 plaintiffs are currently suing for damages under California law. (Will Google settle these "meritless" claims.) Google will also pay damages to the class representatives as decided by arbitration. Unfortunately the injunctive relief negotiated in the Brown settlement, requiring Google to stop collecting data via 3rd party cookies in Incognito mode, expires after 5 years.
- lupire 3y ago> Lawyer David Boies of Boies Schiller Flexner LLP, who represented users in the fight, called the deal an "historic step in requiring honesty and accountability from dominant technology companies". He isn't interested in honesty and accountability for himself or the technology companies he hires, though: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Boies https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Boies > In 2017, Boies' firm reportedly directed the Israeli private intelligence company Black Cube to spy on alleged victims of Harvey Weinstein's sexual abuse and on reporters who were investigating Weinstein's actions.[46] Over the course of a year, Weinstein had Black Cube and other agencies "target", or collect information on, dozens of individuals, and compile psychological profiles that sometimes focused on their personal or sexual histories. "Boies personally signed the contract directing Black Cube to attempt to uncover information that would stop the publication of a Times story about Weinstein's abuses, while his firm was also representing the Times, including in a libel case.
- downrightmike 3y agoWow, what a perfect example of a two-faced lawyer
- what2 3y agoNo, I only see one face: winning the case no matter the means used.
- cpeterso 3y ago> On Monday, Google also agreed to delete "hundreds of billions" of private browsing data records it had collected, the court filing said. > "We are happy to delete old technical data that was never associated with an individual and was never used for any form of personalization." How does Google know which data records to delete? Did they store data collected from private browsing sessions differently from non-private browsing sessions?
- xnx 3y agoGood question. There are various Incognito detection techniques (with varying degrees of success), but we probably would've heard if google.com was employing these techniques.