> Dead cockroaches are gross. Drinking dead cockroach water is gross. Says who? Surely this is a subjective belief. And whether that belief is rational is the

> Dead cockroaches are gross. Drinking dead cockroach water is gross. Says who? Surely this is a subjective belief. And whether that belief is rational is the question. > Therefore not drinking the water was rational. Only if believing "dead cockroach water is gross" is rational.